3 ms·
> Now to see the insanity of the A-->B-->C-->D-->D-->E-->F setup: how can I lend you a chair, it goes from hand to hand from A to F, and at the same time I stil
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Now to see the insanity of the A-->B-->C-->D-->D-->E-->F setup: how can I lend you a chair, it goes from hand to hand from A to F, and at the same time I still have it on my patio?
You don't. Nobody claims you do, not even in the short-selling situation you're trying to describe; you can't vote a share that you've lent out.
> Stocks used to be pieces of papers. In the goold old days, in the end of the day people were spending hours moving papers "stocks" around from your account to my account (literally, papers)
This didn't change; it's just that, under US law, you can no longer own any stock. (Well, more specifically, you can't own stock that you buy on a stock exchange.) Instead, there is a company that exists solely for the purpose of owning all the stock and registering your interest in it. When you sell a stock to someone else, DTCC owns that stock before and after you sell it; what changes is that their internal records may or may not update the name under which that stock is registered.
There's a fun paper here ( https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1017206 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1017206 ) going over the history:
> Congress, in the 1975 Securities Acts Amendments, took the extremely unusual step of legally imposing a single technique for settlement on the markets. The effect on securities settlement was somewhat comparable the effects of a law that would require all computers plugged into the internet to run on DOS.