3 ms·
I'm not military, but worked with them for two years, sometimes with similar schedules. My view about being a soldier, a serviceman has changed drastically dur
by bayindirh 6y ago
I'm not military, but worked with them for two years, sometimes with similar schedules.
My view about being a soldier, a serviceman has changed drastically during that projects. The cause is noble, and the thing they're doing is very hard. Make no mistake here.
On the other hand, they're stripped of their emotions and humanity to an extent. They become something else, an hardened being after some time.
Because, they need to do what has to be done and they shouldn't think through it, but just act.
I'm a grandson of a commander. I love soldiers, but this is how they're trained, and this is how they should be to be able to perform this duty.
- watwut 6y agoImo, whether being soldier is noble depends very very much on which army you are in and what are current goals and conduct of said army.
- zdkl 6y agoOne could argue the qualities of a soldier or officer (individuals) transcend their organisational context (groups) and time. In other words: politics, technology or best practices change, not the responsabilities. The ability (necessity, even) to adapt to that fact defines a fit-for-service soldier/officer. So, I contend you find remarkable soldiers even in terrible groups, and that they (individuals) should not be judged on their group but on their own qualities of service. Whether you find those parameters noble is entirely subjective and not mine to question but I do believe anyone who sincerely understands and accepts these obligations deserves respect, as an individual.
- bayindirh 6y agoThanks for clarifying. This is exactly what I was trying to compose in my mind as an answer, but unable to do so.
- watwut 6y ago> So, I contend you find remarkable soldiers even in terrible groups, and that they (individuals) should not be judged on their group but on their own qualities of service. So, we should praise ISIS fighters? I am intentionally picking up example of extreme, but very real organization. Same question can be asked about SS members. They knew what they joined. Does them doing good job in that organization is really praise worthy? The better quality their service was, the more victims they have.
- bayindirh 6y ago> So, we should praise ISIS fighters? You're distorting it. I was trying to point out that, they have to deform themselves to somewhat non-human states. It's not valid only for servicemen. Firefighters are same. Police are same. Long haul truckers, cargo ship crew are same. I think everybody making sacrifices for doing what they find worthy are eligible for some respect. They accept to deform themselves to do something they find value in. Do not add ethnicity, politics, geography, race into this. It's about being human, and other parts are neither part of my comment nor has place in this specific thread.
- watwut 6y agoI am not distorting. I am using unambiguous example of what I have in mind. > soldiers even in terrible groups, and that they (individuals) should not be judged on their group but on their own qualities of service. Unless you was forced into that group, which was not case of SS but in some cases could be ISIS, you know what you were joining. I don't think sacrifice itself is worth respect, if the goal of that sacrifice is destructive and wrong. If you sacrifice yourself in service of group that does genocide or tortures to get power and so on, you did genocide and tortured people so that your group have power. The ideology of "sacrifice is worth respect no matter what" empowers exactly these groups first. Believing this makes people more likely to join these. The victims, especially those who stood against that group should be celebrated. Those who said "no" deserve respect. Those who were avoiding still deserve more respect.
- bayindirh 6y ago
- closeparen 6y agoA society gets no points for having noble goals if it lacks the capacity to attain them.
- mbrodersen 6y agoBeing a soldier is in itself not honourable or noble. Most atrocities are committed by armed soldiers killing unarmed civilians (or killing civilians using drones because they happen to stand near a wanted target). It is what you do as a soldier (or civilian) that makes you honourable or not.