4 ms·
> If you look at the Chinese chip industry, then you see that a lot of money comes from the private sector. Huawei, Xiaomi, etc are investing a ton of money in
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> If you look at the Chinese chip industry, then you see that a lot of money comes from the private sector. Huawei, Xiaomi, etc are investing a ton of money in semiconductor companies.
Where do you think those "private companies" got the money to build their businesses? Notice also that it's domestic (i.e. controlled by the Chinese government) "private companies" doing this.
China isn't allowed to just nakedly subsidize everything under trade agreements, so they have to do money laundering like that in order to get away with it.
> Clearly it's not all government money.
It doesn't actually have to be. All it has to be is enough government money to put competitors out of business.
> There's also a big difference between investing in an industry with the goal of dominating the world and eliminating competition, vs the goal of becoming a sovereign equal. Why is it necessarily the former, and not the latter?
Because the former results in one country being effectively the sole source in the world for certain products, e.g. cell phones, whereas the latter results in a domestic industry but not the destruction of all foreign industry in that market.
> The US is trying to kill the Chinese semiconductor industry
The US is trying to prevent the world semiconductor industry from becoming monopolized by China the same way they've been doing to so many other industries, because semiconductors have significant national security implications.
- FooBarWidget 6y ago> Where do you think those "private companies" got the money to build their businesses? By... selling stuff to people? I'm sure they get government subsidies, but that's not all of their money, or even a majority. > so they have to do money laundering like that in order to get away with it I'd like to see some proof that 1) they launder money and 2) that it's in significant enough amounts as to allow companies to adopt a kill-the-rest-of-the-world strategy. The latter part of your post basically boils down to "action X is evil when they do it, but not when we do it, because we're the good guys and they the bad guys". Where's the proof? Has China actually killed competition via years of state-funded undercutting, or is it just speculation that they might?