5 ms·
Finding ways to maximize profit, as is being done here, is exactly the ideal of capitalism. Anything else is a post-hoc, just-so rationalization. More so, Elba
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Finding ways to maximize profit, as is being done here, is exactly the ideal of capitalism. Anything else is a post-hoc, just-so rationalization.
More so, Elbakyan herself says that the work she is doing is motivated by anti-capitalist thought.
- logicchains 6y agoThe ideals of capitalism are the ideals of classical Liberalism: small government limited mainly to the protection of citizens rights under the standard of "natural law". Intellectual property isn't such a right, because unlike with real physical property, when you "steal" intellectual property from somebody you're not preventing them from using it in future. I can't imagine many of the founding fathers would be supportive of the massive state apparatus for enforcing IP.
- bitdizzy 6y agoThese are the ideals of capitalism in the same way that the ideals of European feudalism are those of upholding the natural order of things as mandated by God.
- tomrod 6y agoProfit maximization is not capitalism, it's human behavior. Cash is simply one measure of it. </economist_hat>
- sudosysgen 6y agoProfit is not human nature, until you abandon actually senseful definitions of profit. People selling their labour at a market price by definition cannot make profit, meaning that the vast majority of people don't make a profit, so how can it be claimed that it is human nature? Human nature is to sometimes, with a ton of exceptions, maximize resources and utility. This does not mean maximizing profit, unless you redefine profit to be a meaningless word.
- young_unixer 6y ago> Finding ways to maximize profit, as is being done here, is exactly the ideal of capitalism That's just like, your opinion, man. I could also say that finding ways to maximize individual freedom is the ideal of capitalism, and that's exactly the opposite of what Elsevier et al do, so they're the anti-capitalist ones and freedom of information is a capitalist ideal. In reality, intellectual property is a controversial topic in libertarian/capitalist ideology. See: https://mises.org/library/against-intellectual-property-0 https://mises.org/library/against-intellectual-property-0
- sudosysgen 6y agoIntellectual property is a good example of the contradictions of capitalism. It destroys the principles of freedom, but in truth is necessary to perpetuate the capitalist system. As for that being my opinion, it isn't. Capitalism has never been about maximizing individual freedom. The foundational act of capitalism was the Enclosure Act. How does the Enclosure Act increase individual freedom? It doesn't. You're conflating a specific subset of negative freedoms for human freedom in general. Which itself was a post-hoc justification for capitalism. As for freedom of information being a capitalist ideal, why then is it that institutions like state secrets, patent law, copyright law and so on were created under capitalism? You claim that it is controversial, so why is there no capitalist country that doesn't have it? And why was it specifically lobbied for by early capitalists and created with capitalist? This is just a nice fantasy that was established after capitalism already started. The very birth of capitalism, the Enclosure Act, was to restrict freedom to increase profit. In fact, the original libertarians and anarchists were a movement that sought to end capitalism, precisely because of its coercion.
- rualca 6y ago> Intellectual property is a good example of the contradictions of capitalism. It destroys the principles of freedom, but in truth is necessary to perpetuate the capitalist system. Your assertion is quite wrong and far-fetched. Intellectual property is not necessary to "perpetuate the capitalist system", at all, and asserting otherwise has no bearing in reality. Your right to private property and to own means of production does not depend in any way on the state being able to stop others from copying concepts or ideas.