5 ms·
How very brave to call for the taking of someone else’s property!
by refurb 6y ago
How very brave to call for the taking of someone else’s property!
- TeMPOraL 6y agoSuch is the complexity of laws, that, through a series of steps that each seem reasonable individually, one can become an owner of a thing that should not be their property.
- oli5679 6y agoAaron cofounded Reddit, resigned, turned down multiple opportinities to build out other tech companies, dedicated himself to open access activism and eventually killed himself as he was prosecuted for wire fraud. Meanwhile, Relx currently has a market cap of £33 bn, and revenue of £8 bn, when it is essentially providing the service of pdf publishing to its unpaid authors and editors. Arron and Alexandra are extremely brave, and it is Relx and other companies that are taking my property when my tax money is spent to generate research that they then want to charge millions of dollars for others to access.
- refurb 6y agoMy point still stands. Very easy to argue for taking other people’s property.
- logicchains 6y agoIt's not "taking property" if somebody still has the "property" afterwards.
- refurb 6y agoNot a convincing argument. We wouldn’t have artists if their work could just be copied whenever.
- shenberg 6y agoThat's exactly the difference: the scientists don't get paid from the money you pay the journal. They do the work for free and the reviewers do the work for free. If all the journals somehow disappeared, nothing much would change. In some fields the pre-print is what counts anyways, and you don't pay to download a paper on arXiv.
- refurb 6y agoYour comment makes no sense. No one is forced to publish in these journals. It's a choice. So if these journal did disappear I highly doubt "nothing would change".
- rsfern 6y agoThe choice of publication venue is driven by prestige. Researchers want to publish in “high impact,” high visibility venues. In many fields those are closed journals, but if those journals magically disappeared the research community would probably just take a bit to figure out a new pecking order, and in that sense nothing would change. JMLR is an interesting example, where the editorial board of a top journal in the machine learning field basically forked the journal to an open alternative, and of course nobody hesitated to publish there because that’s where the prestige was. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Machine_Learning_Research#History https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Machine_Learning_...
- 6y ago