4 ms·
> Are you saying that Chinese semiconductor companies are outcompeting US semiconductor companies because they have greater access to capital? That doesn't seem
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Are you saying that Chinese semiconductor companies are outcompeting US semiconductor companies because they have greater access to capital? That doesn't seem right to me.
Suppose you have two companies in an industry where the start up cost is ten billion dollars. One can borrow ten billion dollars at 0% interest for the next five years, but they have to pay it back. The other just gets ten billion dollars from the government that they can keep.
Obviously the second company has a competitive advantage. The first has to charge higher prices in order to pay back the loan, which they can't do if the second undercuts them in the market.
This has been China's business model for decades. Then once all the competition is out of business they can raise prices to the point of profitability, but not to the point that anyone who hasn't already paid off their fixed costs can enter the market, and use the profits to do the same thing to the next industry.
- Udik 6y agoIsn't that equivalent to starting up with VC money (and stocks, later)? You get billions to start up, and if you fail you don't have to pay anything back. It's the business model of Amazon, Uber, Tesla, Airbnb...
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoAll of your examples are companies that were pioneers in immature markets. And then if you succeed, the VCs own your company. It's not charity. Whereas China will give a Chinese company billions of dollars to unseat an incumbent in a mature industry and expect nothing in return except for that industry to be in China.
- yellowapple 6y ago> and expect nothing in return Aside from the expectation of unwavering loyalty to the Communist Party of China, you mean.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIs that not what I said?: > except for that industry to be in China.
- yellowapple 6y agoFair, but the implication seemed to be that China was somehow not expecting ownership over the corporations in which it invests (since there was an implied contrast with VC investment where said ownership is expected). That is: it goes a fair bit beyond merely keeping companies in a given geography.
- scott_codie 6y agoAre you saying that the Chinese government is subsidizing the entire semiconductor industry to drive US companies out of business?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoAre you saying that the Chinese government is not subsidizing the entire semiconductor industry in China to drive companies outside of China out of business? They have a documented history of doing this in multiple industries over the course of many years. Notice how substantially all of the consumer electronics devices that used to be made in the US or Japan or Korea or Germany are now made in China.
- scott_codie 6y agoThat would be great if they were as it would make Chinese silicon cheaper for the US since they are trading partners.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoReview the part where they only do this until the competitors are out of business. It's called predatory pricing and is an antitrust violation when companies do it.
- FooBarWidget 6y agoI'd like to see this documented history. You mentioned electronics, but have they raised prices?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe trend in electronics prices is to decline over time, so you get the same result by not reducing prices as much as the ongoing reductions in cost. Check how much a piece of consumer electronics costs in China vs. the US. They could charge the same amount.