4 ms·
Sure, real life adds complexity! I still think the simplified question is a useful framework, similar to how the concept of an infinite two-dimensional plane is
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
Sure, real life adds complexity! I still think the simplified question is a useful framework, similar to how the concept of an infinite two-dimensional plane is useful in mathematics. We can use it to understand the more-complicated real world.
And, note that my father's stated position was that regardless of anything else, the risk of giving COVID to participants wasn't worth the potential of a faster vaccine, period. He wasn't thinking of those other issues you raised, because he hadn't gotten there yet.
(He did say there was one scenario in which he'd support a challenge trial—if we found a drug which rendered COVID non-deadly, but could only be manufactured in low quantities. He had a specific candidate in mind. But that's basically opting out of the problem—he would pull the lever if the trolly wasn't deadly to the other guy.)