3 ms·
> In real life you are never presented with such a binary problem. Everything is a mix of arbitrarily unbounded priorities, predictive ambiguity, and even ambig
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> In real life you are never presented with such a binary problem. Everything is a mix of arbitrarily unbounded priorities, predictive ambiguity, and even ambiguity in the outcome.
One real-life example that comes to my mind is whether we should have done COVID vaccine challenge trials. I always thought they were a good idea. Yes, it would have put people at risk, but it could have potentially saved many more lives!
My father is a doctor, and in fact is an infectious disease specialist. He's been very busy this past year, working primarily on COVID research. When I talked to him about the idea of a challenge trial, he was completely against the idea—so much so that he got a bit upset, and we had to stop talking about it. That doesn't happen often.
The idea of purposefully giving participants a deadly disease—even with their consent—seemed fundamentally wrong to my father, regardless of how many other lives could have been saved in the process.
- davidgay 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primum_non_nocere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primum_non_nocere would seem to be the ethical principle at play here .
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoRight, but that's the essence of the trolly problem, isn't it? Whether you can take one life to save multiple lives.
- MrPatan 6y agoYou're right, and for exactly the same reason: If somebody dies in the human challenge trial it's very specifically your fault. The people that die due to a delay in the vaccine because of not using human challenge trials? Nobody knows them, they don't count, and they can't sue you.
- jerf 6y ago"One real-life example that comes to my mind is whether we should have done COVID vaccine challenge trials." You don't know what the result of the trial will be, already taking us out of the domain of the trolley problem. If you knew it was going to kill everyone who had it but you'd get this particular bit of info that was guaranteed to have this result for the general population, then we'd be much closer, but there are multiple false assumptions to get there... and we still haven't discussed all the different ways we could run the trial because it's not a matter of "Either we do the trial this exact way, or we don't"; do we do a double-blind? Base it on multi-armed bandit math? Do we focus on certain demographics? And so on and so on. Not a binary choice between these two guaranteed results; a huge range of possibilities, unknown outcomes, even things that are hard to measure outcomes.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoSure, real life adds complexity! I still think the simplified question is a useful framework, similar to how the concept of an infinite two-dimensional plane is useful in mathematics. We can use it to understand the more-complicated real world. And, note that my father's stated position was that regardless of anything else, the risk of giving COVID to participants wasn't worth the potential of a faster vaccine, period. He wasn't thinking of those other issues you raised, because he hadn't gotten there yet. (He did say there was one scenario in which he'd support a challenge trial—if we found a drug which rendered COVID non-deadly, but could only be manufactured in low quantities. He had a specific candidate in mind. But that's basically opting out of the problem—he would pull the lever if the trolly wasn't deadly to the other guy.)