5 ms·
You seem to underestimate the pressure from the market. At one point the younger generation does not even remember there was a local-first software. Sadly the
by pdimitar 6y ago
You seem to underestimate the pressure from the market.
At one point the younger generation does not even remember there was a local-first software.
Sadly the relentless efforts of the corporations are paying off.
That doesn't mean people are okay with it. It means their choice is made for them.
- mvzvm 6y agoI disagree. I think HN is rabid about privacy and "owning your data", but by and large, most people just don't care.
- codemac 6y agoMost that I talk to do - but it's similar to how they care about the national debt. There's nothing they can do, they have no realistic expertise or control, and they vote with what - dollars once every phone purchase?
- mvzvm 6y agoI think this is a good analogy, because the national debt is not a good measure of anything. People bring it up at all the wrong times, and takes grandstanding postures around it. Just like this, eh?
- astrange 6y agoAt least there might be a reason to care about privacy, but there actually isn't a reason to care about the national debt. There's no evidence the model of it being debt means anything - it certainly isn't household debt when it's in a currency you can just print more of. And even under the model where printing money causes inflation, we're in a negative interest rate regime meaning printing money would cause /deflation/.
- deathanatos 6y ago> and they vote with what - dollars More and more, I am seeing many companies that realize they can do both: take the user's money and feed them ads. After all, that's more profitable than just taking their money. As examples, T-mo, Verizon, my local gas station, various airlines all both take my money and give me ads. Some are even known to sell my data. So, can I actually vote with my wallet?
- hinkley 6y agoThere’s a whole thing with growing or making your own food as much as you can. We keep outsourcing food production. In affluent areas that’s a boon, in others it’s an active problem. Probably we will see the same play out here.
- ibeckermayer 6y agoConsider who taught them not to care.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoI know plenty of enterprise guys who won't store critical documents, designs, code, or IP in cloud services. Also, local untethers from SaaS changes (prices/features), snooping, data loss, hacking, etc. at the expense of supporting, backup/restore, disaster recovery, and securing it yourself. It's fine if you have a competent IT shop and already have the scale to do it, but it's not the first choice for small, non-technical ventures.
- pdimitar 6y agoIndeed, it seems there's a market opportunity there, isn't it?
- oscargrouch 6y agoNot just that, but there also a lot of cases that the local-first software will perform much better given the resources might be cached. If you mix the two crowds: the people that actually care with the people that will just want faster apps, you get a powerful bootstrap traction. Lets also not forget that things might just vanish and when we are able to collect them and make personal relations that make sense to us, we will want to be secure that things that matter to us wont go away because we are keeping them. Its pure psychology. The parent poster is forgetting that before we get use of how things are right now in the digital realm, we had to deal with the material world and thats how we shaped our minds. And in that world we learn how important is to keep things nearby and have mnemonics to help our minds that needs to keep so much information that our devices become our second brains. I'm working on a fancy chromium inspired prototype to tackle this exact issue and just with what i got here working in "prototype mode" i kind of don't want anything else.. it's just.. another level. Its technologically superior and even ordinary, unaware people will just want this. Cloud have its place of course, but "local-first" will eat a lot of their lunch in the coming years.
- pdimitar 6y ago> If you mix the two crowds: the people that actually care with the people that will just want faster apps, you get a powerful bootstrap traction. Do we really though? Most people just buy a new phone, idly agree to all cloud sync stuff that the Android vendor has slapped on it and only notice "hey, I have 500GB free storage for the next 6 months!" and that's the end of it. There is a market for local-first. Absolutely. But I question how big it is. Maybe in corporate? If not there, I don't think you can make it big in that area. We at HN are a fairly negligible rounding error compared to most of the internet-connected humanity.
- oscargrouch 6y agoI agree with you. But that's because the state-of-the-art in clients are cloud hungry applications, giving their parent companies have much to profit from this behavior. Local-first is a technological sophistication from the current tech status-quo, so it requires more labor to get at a point where it can stand against the current cloud-first applications. We will only be able to see how far it can go, once the next-gen applications reach the same level. It will be a harsh competition, but if we can just ship the platform along with it, and at least Android make it possible, users wont even notice, because it was the dev's that made that decision for them. And the dev's will do it because it might make their apps a little better, more responsive and fail proof. Of course this all must happen before 5G or part of the leverage is gone unfortunately.. But we need at least try anyway, because a world where all the information is centralized on the FAANG titans is a world where freedom, civil and human rights are constantly endangered(especially in the age of AI automation).
- dnautics 6y agoeverywhere outside the US this may be true, but in the US there is the millennial age group, which is a mini-population-boom. The millennial age group remembers stuff like handbrake and bittorrent, is socially conscious about the effects of centralization, and is about to become the largest demography with consumptive power (they are in their earnings/savings prime right now and having children). Increasingly, millennials also are having children, and I think there is a market opportunity for these sorts of products (e.g. I want to sort pictures by my kids, but without giving facial recognition to fb/google).