2 ms·
I broadly agree with a lot of the principles here, but there are distinctions that should be drawn. Firstly, there is the question of uncertainty. I am not cer
by roenxi 6y ago
I broadly agree with a lot of the principles here, but there are distinctions that should be drawn.
Firstly, there is the question of uncertainty. I am not certain that donating money will result in lives saved. The charity might be corrupt.
Secondly, there is the donation-vs-useful-work. Someone like Bill Gates is a fantastic example - the more money he donated pre-becoming-a-billionaire, the more less helpful he'd have been. It was better that he focused on making more money so he has more to give away.
Thirdly, there are complicated but powerful arguments that people have to privilege their own life beyond what the trolley problem answer suggests.
- Practically, people are going to do that.
- An individual can be much more certain that they exist and benefit from living than others (maybe they are surrounded by philosophical zombies?).
- If moral people make choices to weed themselves out of the gene/social pool then society will become less moral over time.
Cynical, self serving, but true.