6 ms·
Unions are at least nominally directly elected by their constituents and beholden to them, which is why they are protected when engaging in politics. If you th
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Unions are at least nominally directly elected by their constituents and beholden to them, which is why they are protected when engaging in politics.
If you think they do not represent them, then maybe the solution is to develop better union structures that are more democratic and representative.
But by and large, teachers do not support the Libertarian party and instead favour the Democratic party, quite heavily in fact. So why is it wrong that their alignment follows their base?
- mc32 6y agoAgree with your points. However, using that line of thinking people voluntarily join a company too. Often to work for a company with union rep one HAS to join, whether one agrees or not, so it’s not entirely voluntary in a strict sense. All this said, I do believe Amazon is treating their warehouse workers unfairly and they deserve pushback though I admit I do not favor bringing in a Union due to my past member experiences with them.
- kennywinker 6y ago> people voluntarily join a company too A choice between starvation and warehouse job at amazon where you’re penalized for taking a bathroom break is not a choice made freely.
- mc32 6y agoI agree. We need better labor laws. I just don’t like having a middle woman or man in there because they have other motives.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoHow do you get better labor laws without middle men groups lobbying? The same Amazon workers have neither the time nor energy themselves.
- mc32 6y agoIn SV parlance unions are rent seekers. They are a bandaid over the symptom not the cure.
- sudosysgen 6y agoUnions do not rent seek. They provide value to society via higher wages and act as a counterbalance to externalities from capital. They are indeed not a cure, but the cure to the symptoms we are seeing is nothing short of a total overhaul of the capitalist system, which is both not politically feasible, and requires something like unions to make politically feasible to begin with. That is because by definition such a changé even if it was in the larger interests of society wouldn't be in the interests of capital.
- mc32 6y agoThere were and are workers’ unions in communist countries. They didn’t always have their worker’ best interests in mind. Often they were a tool of the communist state to control workers. In addition sometimes you had student movements pitted against workers’ unions and so on. Exploitation or at the minimum the potential for it exists in every economic system. It’s not a feature exclusive to capitalism as much as people dream it to be so. Even in a barter economy, can I not take advantage of another worker? Of course I can!
- sudosysgen 6y agoI never said that we should install Soviet socialism/state-capitalism, it's not a good system. Workers unions in socialist countries were basically illegal, there was only one legally allowed union pretty much. In the Soviet Union the role of labour unions were mostly for the state to resolve interpersonal problems, and in theory to allow the state to receive feedback from employees to optimize production, but not in practice due to dysfunctions because of the broken political and economic framework.
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago
- moioci 6y agoThe one time I worked in a union shop, I was told that I didn't have to join, but I did have to pay dues. If I chose to join, there were certain benefits provided by the union to members (optical coverage IIRC).
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere is a huge difference. People have no choice but to work, and once you are employed, you cannot have any democratic control over the company. In contrast, for the union, even if you were forced to join, you'd still have democratic control over the union itself. So there is a big difference. It's the difference between choosing in which dictatorship to live and living in a (sometimes direct!) democracy.
- gowld 6y agoBy that argument, Trump's behavior is OK because he was elected.
- syshum 6y agoThe libertarian party supports School Choice, Actual Education for children, and less protectionism based on "seniority" So it is no wonder that unionized teachers would oppose the Libertarian Party, libertarians want children to get a good education and allow parents to choose the type of education their child gets, taking away large amounts of power from Teachers who believe they should supplant parents and "know better". This has never been more clear than in the Age of COVID where the hypocrisy of Teachers and their union has been on full display with their refusal to teacher (aka their job)
- jakelazaroff 6y agoAt best it's very arguable whether school choice results in children getting a better education.
- mc32 6y agoI dunno. School isn’t primarily about academics. It’s mostly about moulding pupils, their minds to their current society. It’s mostly political in that sense. Whether it’s patriotism, community building, stressing this over that, etc. The three Rs are kind of incidental. Now to be clear, we do need to grow up to be functional adults, but public schooling is not the only one option to achieve that.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoTo be clear — when people refer to "school choice", they usually mean a system that funnels taxpayer dollars to private schools based on student attendance. Similarly, when people oppose "school choice", they usually oppose that appropriation of public funds specifically, not public school alternatives in general. It's a sneaky name designed to make you conflate the two.
- leesalminen 6y agoI always thought that school choice means a system that funnels taxpayer dollars to any school, public or private, based on student attendance. Parents can choose to send their children to public school, if they feel the outcome will be superior to alternatives.
- worker767424 6y agoOne thing I'd like to see is competing unions. The UAW supplies labor to the big three US automakers, putting them in an unfair negotiating advantage; the UAW can easily bully them around. The UAW ultimately hurt themselves because it put the Big Three at a big competitive disadvantage. Some manufacturing left for right-to-work states, and some business left for (mostly) Japanese automakers.
- mc32 6y agoI think that could help. Some unions at least, like the UAW shoot themselves in the foot. It’s very adversarial from both sides and often the worker in the middle is the one who loses out. Example the steel industry. They made labor so expensive the companies folded. Admittedly the industry ran aged inefficient systems that made their process uncompetitive. But the Union only cared about protecting itself. The companies only cared about immediate profits.
- jjk166 6y agoThat's not at all what happened to the steel industry. 50% of all US steel production capacity has been built in the past 30 years and steel production has seen continuous and massive improvements in productivity. In 1920 it took 3 man-hours of labor to produce 1 ton of steel in the US, now 1 man-hour produces 300 tons. The contraction in steel employment during the 70s coincided with a recession and the development of the electric arc furnace. From 1974 to 1999, global steel industry employment fell by 1.5 Million people with large decreases both in developed countries and developing countries like Brazil and South Africa as employment per ton of production fell everywhere. The actions of one union in one country had nothing to do with it.
- mc32 6y agoOld outdated technology (not sure about the stance the unions had back then on productivity improvements that would lower headcount) plus outsized pay demands for the given the productivity.