8 ms·
Scientists begin building highly accurate digital twin of our planet
- Barrin92 6y ago>"Observational data will be continuously incorporated into the digital twin in order to make the digital Earth model more accurate for monitoring the evolution and predict possible future trajectories. But in addition to the observation data conventionally used for weather and climate simulations, the researchers also want to integrate new data on relevant human activities into the model. The new "Earth system model" will represent virtually all processes on the Earth's surface as realistically as possible, including the influence of humans on water, food and energy management, and the processes in the physical Earth system." I think I've seen something like it on the latest season of Westworld. Jokes aside this reminds me a little bit of the brain project. I'm really not sure if attempting to build full fidelity models of hugely complex systems is the way forward to understand this systems. It seems increasingly that scientists are trying to replace theoretical models of the say, the mind or the city with purely data driven approaches that don't necessarily produce any insight, or even accurate forecasts. Sometimes it feels like with increasing computing power we've gone back to the problems of empiricism of the mid 20th century.
- whatshisface 6y agoYou couldn't call it full-fidelity.
- etiam 6y agoLast I saw anything of it, the EU brain Flagship project had lots of actual brain scientist unhappy about having almost no scientific or professional benefit from the huge public spending, and one happy Henry Markram for having the final say that huge chunks of the money should go into his guys building a really, really big computer. I foresee a Big Science project with little to no benefit for meteorology, climatology, geology, etc and a lot of public money going into building a really, REALLY big computer. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing to buy per se, but if the intent really was to understand Earth, they'd be better off putting the money into fundamental research in the Earth sciences.
- zoomablemind 6y ago> ...It seems increasingly that scientists are trying to replace theoretical models of the say, the mind or the city with purely data driven approaches that don't necessarily produce any insight, or even accurate forecasts. It may seem like a logical desire to integrate the existing massive data feeds about various aspects of the planet into a progression of coherent states of it. With the hope to gain insights for the dynamics and trends. The first challenge is to figure out if such feeds are indeed integratable and at all could lead to any sort of coherency. The next challenge is to understand what should be considered a "state". It is a complex system, yet one needs to choose the parameters. It is nice to have such a global view of the observations. But I'm sure the goal stretches further and means to produce projections and forecasts. This may have some political impact, but practically may just be as good as a speculation, given the vast scale.
- plumsempy 6y agodibs on biyomon
- thisisbrians 6y agoThis is an extremely ambitious project, and hopefully turns out to be worthwhile. For complex/interconnected systems, building ~accurate simulations can vastly decrease the cost of decision-making, and I'm very bullish on digital twin technology, generally. Trying things out in a simulation can be a cheap way to guide more detailed engineering analysis and 'rough in' an approach. As an example, my startup, Bractlet (bractlet.com), uses detailed, physics-based energy simulation (aka "digital energy twin") technology as a tool to optimize HVAC design and controls in large commercial buildings. I'm sure efficacy varies widely by domain, but it's worked extremely well for us so far; we typically help our customers save about 20-30% on their energy expenditures annually, and the digital twin is the bedrock of our approach.
- datalus 6y agoI also like the digital twin concept as it applies to sci-fi. Sometimes I daydream our universe is a digital twin built by an advanced civilization meant to simulate the universe's history looking for clues as to what lead to a calamity that they're trying to undo. Random thought :)
- eightysixfour 6y agoCan/does your system simulate the quality of the air as well? In particular particulate matter and CO2 levels.
- thisisbrians 6y agoWe've given this a lot of attention in the age of Covid, as you might imagine. Many modern HVAC control systems include CO₂ sensors in the return air streams to make sure they're bringing in enough outdoor air to meet indoor air quality standards, and that's fairly easy to simulate. Particulate counts are trickier, and may be better estimated using out-of-simulation engineering calculations based on the type of filtration in place.
- eightysixfour 6y agoInteresting, mind if I shoot you an email? My family has a business in this space (residential side) and I'd love to chat more.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 6y agoYou know the fjords in Norway? I got a prize for creating those, you know.
- FigmentEngine 6y agohere's a towel
- mceoin 6y agoTo think, there was a time before we had a permanent, high-res historical record of the entire planet that we could wind forwards and backwards and observe history through.
- olivermarks 6y agoReminds me of the biosphere projects whose failures have been the subject of multiple debates over reasons why. https://www.euronews.com/living/2020/07/09/living-in-a-bubble-did-this-failed-90s-experiment-predict-the-future https://www.euronews.com/living/2020/07/09/living-in-a-bubbl... Highly sceptical the digital version of this will be playing with a full deck of data resulting in skewed results. still think it's a good idea but definitely not the accursed 'settled science', more an experiment.
- ravi-delia 6y agoI'd imagine that like weather predicting, the best way to simulate a complex system is to slightly vary the starting conditions and sample the results. Obviously it's not going to be perfect, but it gives a clear idea about what things to worry about. Reading the article, it seems that the purpose of the twin isn't simulation, it's mapping. That data can then be used as the input to simulation of your choice.
- jetrink 6y agoIs 'digital twin' anything other than a buzzword? Is there anything that distinguishes one from a model or a simulation? I had the misfortune of being introduced to the term by an executive who repeated it until is lost all meaning so I still bristle whenever I hear it. I've read the Wikipedia article, but it only increased my skepticism with blustery paragraphs like: > Healthcare is recognized as an industry being disrupted by the digital twin technology.[45][34] The concept of digital twin in the healthcare industry was originally proposed and first used in product or equipment prognostics.[34] With a digital twin, lives can be improved in terms of medical health, sports and education by taking a more data-driven approach to healthcare.
- jarenmf 6y agoIt is a shame they are using these buzzwords, It's basically an earth system model, one that we had for many many years. They probably will improve the code base, I don't know if they want to build everything from the ground up or use some physics aware hybrid machine learning approach for sub-grid parameterization but really nothing seem novel except trying to improve the resolution of the current models we have.
- roter 6y agoAnd building science[0]. But building science has always been full of buzzwords. [0] https://www.iesve.com/digital-twins https://www.iesve.com/digital-twins
- scrooched_moose 6y agoThe one distinguishing feature (in theory) of digital twins is it is supposed to be such a hyper accurate model that it can be used to predict absolutely anything about the system in question. No changing of model setup, it's a "perfect" representation. The down side is everything explodes exponentially - setup time, mesh count, solve time; and we usually get worse results than more focused simulations because we can't squeeze enough detail in across the board. It generally starts because some manager hears that we've created 8 different specialized models of something due to different areas of interest, and has the bright idea of "lets just create a single super-accurate model we can use for everything". I've been fighting against them my entire career, although 10 years ago it was "virtual mockups" The next buzzword in the pipeline seems to be "virtual lab" which I can't figure out either. I've been simulating laboratory tests for over a decade and no one can explain to me why that isn't exactly what we're already doing. None of this is to say that this team isn't doing great work, but somewhere along the way it got wrapped up in some marketing nonsense. Edit: Restructured my reply to better address OPs question.
- jiofih 6y agoJust expand the map in GTA V to cover all countries, should be accurate enough.
- OneGuy123 6y agoThis will be a failure of epic proportions. Due to the complexity of the real world we can't even predict weather for 2 days in advance and you they think they can predict the world... The sad part is that they will then use this model and its result to create policies not knowing that you can never rely on such a "copy" because even the smallest difference will create an insane amount of divergence even 1 day down the line of future simulation let alone years...
- hikerclimber 6y agohopefully this fails.
- TimTheTinker 6y ago“Digital twin” is such a misleading term, as it implies the ability to perfectly model a non-digital system, which is inescapably impossible. The best we will ever be able to create is approximate models that have varying tradeoffs. The term "digital twin" obscures the fact that there are tradeoffs involved in the first place. It also causes harm to decision-makers, who ought to be able to choose which tradeoffs to make.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI would hope (and where I work, it seems to be the case) that decision makers understand that "digital twins" are only twins with respect to a select set of parameters that are being optimized by use of such model. But then, buzzwords do have a life of their own.
- tejtm 6y agoWonder if there is a way to wrap it in Dwarf Fortress or something and crowd source the intractable parts.
- jrochkind1 6y agoEh... I'm skeptical this will work out very usefully. The proof is in the pudding though. But sure, I can see why someone would fund the research project. But this is mostly just a press release with buzzwords, right?
- jandrewrogers 6y agoI am highly skeptical of this approach. Not only has this been attempted before, it appears to be on course to repeat the same technical design mistakes that caused prior attempts to fail. You can't decompose weather/climate style supercomputing models below a certain resolution because the fundamental characteristics of the computation are not meaningfully representable that way. Scalable models that correctly and efficiently capture the macro effects of many types of sparse, high-resolution dynamics require much more sophisticated computer science, systems engineering, and ways of representing data. You can't brute force it. In particular, this is a notoriously poor approach to modeling complex large-scale interactions between humans and their environments. There was a study I was involved in last year to determine why one of the epidemiological models for COVID was so badly off target. The root cause was modeling human behavior in the same way you would model weather, which is quite inappropriate but the implementors of the epidemiological model did not have the expertise to know better. The selection of GPUs is also not appropriate for the nominal objectives of the program. When modeled correctly, i.e. not as weather, these kinds of things aren't the kind of workload GPUs are good at. They tend to look more like very high dimensionality sparse graphs -- latency-hiding is more important than computational throughput. CPUs are actually quite good at this. This looks more like a program more designed to produce press releases than useful results.
- alecst 6y agoI know it's off topic but I'd love to learn more about how the modeling of COVID went wrong. You can pm me if you want to take the discussion elsewhere.
- rajansaini 6y agoSeconded!
- neolog 6y agoI would like to read about that too.
- nostromo 6y agoThe models tended to overshoot the number of deaths by huge amounts. For example, the Imperial College of London estimated 40m deaths in 2020 instead of the 2m that occurred. https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2020/03/18/covi-m18.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2020/03/18/covi-m18.html https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01003-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01003-6 https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/196496/coronavirus-pandemic-could-have-caused-40/ https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/196496/coronavirus-pandemic-... The model authors have since argued that the data was correct, but people responded to the pandemic by changing the way we live. That's OP point: that feedback cycles and corrections exist and they make modeling dynamic systems very difficult.
- robertlagrant 6y agoThe carbon generated by running this simulation will be offset by planting trees in the simulation.
- ruined 6y agothey better plant some trees in real life too or we'll diverge from canon
- martingoodson 6y agoDoes anyone know any evidence for or against the feasibility of this concept? Policy makers in the uk are talking about investing in digital twins for the purpose of AI research and it just seems to be buzzword salad. Can someone point me to a reference?
- logicchains 6y agoThere is sound mathematical evidence that certain systems are impossible to model this way: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory. "Small differences in initial conditions, such as those due to errors in measurements or due to rounding errors in numerical computation, can yield widely diverging outcomes for such dynamical systems, rendering long-term prediction of their behavior impossible in general. This can happen even though these systems are deterministic, meaning that their future behavior follows a unique evolution and is fully determined by their initial conditions, with no random elements involved. In other words, the deterministic nature of these systems does not make them predictable. This behavior is known as deterministic chaos, or simply chaos. The theory was summarized by Edward Lorenz as: Chaos: When the present determines the future, but the approximate present does not approximately determine the future."
- dreamcompiler 6y agoChaos theory absolutely, unequivocally prevents such models from making detailed long-term predictions. But that doesn't mean the models are worthless; they can still make detailed short-term predictions and gross long-term predictions. Ed Lorenz was a weather modeler; he invented chaos theory to explain the long-term failure of his models. But weather models and climate models are nevertheless useful today if we're aware of their limitations.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoMy student has started training GANs based on satellite imagery to model changing landscapes. I think they are mesmerizing to look at. https://youtube.com/shorts/sdlx8yxdLPo https://youtube.com/shorts/sdlx8yxdLPo
- grahamburger 6y agoI am reminded of this short story by Neil Gaiman https://kartoweb.itc.nl/kobben/files/The%20Mapmaker-Neil%20Gaiman.pdf https://kartoweb.itc.nl/kobben/files/The%20Mapmaker-Neil%20G...
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAn interesting story. But the nerd in me screams about an unexplored obvious plot point: such a map of the land would have to contain in it the map of the map, creating infinite recursion, which is especially unresolvable in the last map the Emperor desired.
- grahamburger 6y agoYou are thinking of the story as it would have been written by Neal Stephenson ;-)
- crazygringo 6y agoFrom the press release I had the same reaction as many commenters here: this seems like a terrible idea because any model that tries to be better at everything inevitably winds up being better at nothing. But I want to be charitable and so I wonder if there really is a game-changing idea in here that the press release does a poor job communicating. Could this wind up physically measuring a ton of stuff that hasn't been measured at a decent resolution before, and so produce genuine meaningful improvements? Or is there really some kind of new viable "supercomputer" architecture unique to climate modeling that will pay off massive dividends? The AI part worries me the most, since it can be a notorious black box where critical biases and errors get amplified without even being detectable. But are there actually techniques here to drastically speed up the production of expensive calculations, that are cheap to verify as correct? Or is there genuinely a divide between earth scientists and computer scientists where neither side is benefiting from advances in the other, and there's a huge genuine opportunity here for a massively productive paradigm shift? I'd really like to hope there's something of value here, and perhaps someone here who has worked with climate modeling and knows actual details about this project has some insight.
- nanis 6y ago42 If you need clarification, isn't this similar to Deep Thought?