10 ms·
I got instructions from more than one party this past fall on how to fill out a ballot and mail it early and etc.
by duxup 6y ago
I got instructions from more than one party this past fall on how to fill out a ballot and mail it early and etc.
- sodality2 6y agoDid they tell you which way to vote, though? And giving reasoning for why (this actually wouldn't surprise me)?
- duxup 6y agoYes they told me exactly who I should vote for and why.
- sodality2 6y agoHm. In my opinion that isn't as bad, but I can't put my finger on why. This is one reason: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26263866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26263866
- duxup 6y agoI thought it was weird, but I can't imagine a basis for not allowing that. Even if it was someone's boss... they too get to talk / have an opinion... even if I think it is wrong. I've certainly worked for employers who I thought had some very wrong ideas, I still did my own thing voting wise.
- kedean 6y agoIMO the key difference is that you were getting mail from political parties. I think the correct comparison would be if the US government were sending you mail instructing you on how to vote for the party already in power. There's a big difference between the party pleading its case to you and the government itself endorsing that party. I think Amazon's power over employees makes it more like the latter, although neither is a perfect analogy. If I had gotten mailers last year directly from the United States government instructing me "how to re-elect Donald J. Trump", I would have been livid. Individual within the company should be able to make their case for why they think unionization is bad, but I don't think the company itself gets a say in this.
- rtpg 6y agoIt wasn't your boss telling you how to do that though. The direct power imbalance is pretty different, I think.
- SilasX 6y agoThen I don’t understand the outrage. What’s offensive about instructions on how to fill out a ballot above and beyond the fact of them asking you to vote no? The GGP seemed to think that there was something particularly bad about the detailed six page instructions. But the GP correctly pointed out they do the same thing in regular government elections (to milk as many voters as they can).
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> What’s offensive about instructions on how to fill out a ballot above and beyond the fact of them asking you to vote no? Nothing. The outrage is about them telling you to vote no. If they were trying to help you fill out your ballot in good faith, there wouldn't be a problem.
- SilasX 6y agoNo. The OP was complaining about something already assuming they're telling you to vote no, meaning the OP was adding something on top of that. I was asking what that thing-on-top is. So it has to be something more than: >The outrage is about them telling you to vote no. Which, indeed, you correct yourself on in the next sentence, to say that the issue is that it pretends to be neutral ballot instructions, but, if followed, end in you voting no, and are thus misleading (just guessing -- again, no one here seems to be making it easy to understand what they're objecting to). If so, it would have been helpful for the OP to communicate that the first time around. Remember rtpg joined in to clarify, but actually objected to something else, the power imbalance -- and yet s/he seemed to believe s/he was agreeing with the initial comment! Not everyone can read minds about what a speaker thinks is the most salient part, and we don't deserve to be ridiculed for asking. If you want others to be outraged, it helps to clearly communicate what they're supposed to be outraged about -- starting form a clear model.