5 ms·
I have no doubt that if humanity wanted to, it could sequester all the carbon necessary to reverse climate change, and more. The question isn't really whether h
by endisneigh 6y ago
I have no doubt that if humanity wanted to, it could sequester all the carbon necessary to reverse climate change, and more. The question isn't really whether humanity is capable of doing it (we are), but rather whether we will do it.
In particular, for those who have the majority of "ability" to make change, would it be easier for them to take more and more clean resources in a zero-sum battle or have a short to medium term hit in allying themselves with the rest of the world to fix climate change in the long term?
If COVID has shown us anything, the answer to the last question is unequivocally no. COVID has been a very obvious salient problem and most nations failed the test. If we can't beat COVID, we will not beat climate change. No technology can change human nature.
- ekianjo 6y ago> If we can't beat COVID, we will not beat climate change. No technology can change human nature. Erm, looks like we are doing pretty well to beat COVID with vaccines developed in record timing.
- wffurr 6y ago500,000 dead in the US, largely due to failure to wear masks and observe distancing protocols, is a strange way to "beat" COVID.
- ben_w 6y agoThere are massive gaps between losing to COVID (which would’ve been 1-10% deaths depending on if they happened suddenly enough to overwhelm the healthcare system or not), versus what actually happened in any given nation (0.2% in Belgium to 0.00003% in Burundi, 0.155% in the USA), versus the best possible combination of decisions and actions in response to this virus (it being stopped in China before it ever spread outside Wuhan). Same with climate change. Worst case is Venus, we’re heading for a few degrees Celsius change that persists for centuries, we could’ve prevented almost all of the problems we’re looking at now if we’d made the best choices even as late as the 60s and 70s.
- ekianjo 6y agoand your point is? The fact that vaccines are here makes the COVID problem irrelevant a few years from now. That's called beating COVID.
- rayiner 6y agoThere is very little evidence that the death rate in the US is "largely due to failure to wear masks." Mask wearing in different countries is all over the map. The US is actually on the higher end in terms of mask wearing: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/07/08/face-off-over-face-masks-europes-latest-north-south-split https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/07/08/face-off.... Meanwhile, countries like Denmark and Norway with very low rates of mask wearing have seen very low COVID death rates. EDIT: More recent data from YouGov showing same pattern: https://yougov.co.uk/topics/international/articles-reports/2020/03/17/personal-measures-taken-avoid-covid-19 https://yougov.co.uk/topics/international/articles-reports/2.... Mask-wearing rates in Denmark and Norway picked up in 2H 2020, but were still on the low side.
- adrianb 6y agoAnd I think a valuable COVID lesson is: once a natural process is started (the virus spreading worldwide) we don't have much power to stop it. But we can successfully mitigate it by developing vaccines in record time and manufacturing them in large scales. Similarly, for global warming it would be a waste of time and effort to try to stop the natural process (limit human activity to revert the temperature increase) and instead focus our innovation and resources into mitigation (carbon capture, green energy, fortifying coast lines...)
- dools 6y agoSome nations stopped it. I live in Australia and aside from a handful of days long lockdowns life has basically been normal. China stopped it and they have heaps of people. The US failed spectacularly because it was being run by a bunch of anarcho capitalists
- ekianjo 6y ago> Australia It's fairly easy to prevent stuff from entering the country when you are an island. Singapore also had no problem in doing it. Notice some kind of pattern? > China stopped it and they have heaps of people Do you trust any data coming from China? Because North Korea also claimed they had zero death from COVID. Also, it's fairly clear by now that there is some genetic component with COVID: there are less death in asian ethnic groups compared to others, so having less deaths in China/Japan/Korea is consistent in that regard anyway. > The US failed spectacularly Comparing to death rates across Europe, not that much different actually. Media brainwashing much?
- dools 6y agoYes you are clearly the victim of media brainwashing.
- rayiner 6y agoThe same anarcho capitalists running France, Spain, Italy, Germany, etc?
- js8 6y agoNot only that. The countries that are capable of rejecting the ideology of individualism, like China, have actually much better track record in beating it. For the record, I am not advocating completely ditching liberalism, but we should understand that it became (in the form of neoliberalism) too ideological in the Western world. That prevents us seeing alternative social solutions that can be very effective in beating the pandemic. (And I am writing this from Prague, Czechia. Strangely enough, our government managed to beat the 1st wave by doing lots of early restrictions, but then we were massively hit by 2nd wave in the reluctance to do restrictions again. This cannot be explained away by human nature, it was purely a matter of cultural perspective.)
- bserge 6y agoOf course they are. People in the west couldn't even be arsed to wear a mask, the simplest thing one could do to at least show some social solidarity. The kind of shit individualism has evolved into is ridiculous.
- dools 6y agoIt’s not an evolution it’s engineering. This whole movement is a deliberate libertarian project.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Not only that. The countries that are capable of rejecting the ideology of individualism, like China, have actually much better track record in beating it. Oh we all know that data coming from China is super reliable, right? After all, they never lied about the Wuhan fatalities in the first place.
- Kydlaw 6y ago> I have no doubt that if humanity wanted to, it could sequester all the carbon necessary to reverse climate change While this solution is appealing, it always leads to more questions than answers. Let's assume the How is solved. Where do you store it? Can it scale and if yes with which scenario? - Infinite growth? No way, it's physically impossible. - With a reduction? Maybe, but what will be the cost then? Will it be cost effective? I think at that point we are back at the OP question.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Where do you store it? Someone creates some magical building material that is high in carbon, non-reactive (or at least doesn't leach carbon into the air), economically viable and is mostly recyclable. Imagine something along the lines of synthetic high carbon asphalt or masonry products.
- Retric 6y agoA lot of CO2 has been released. 10 Trillion metric tons / 7.8 billion people ~= 1,300 tons per person which is well beyond the amount of building materials used.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYup, but the point is that with such magic building material, we could not only build buildings and facilities with it, we could just pile heaps of it above ground for the purpose of only sequestering carbon.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThat's about 130 trees or 13 houses. Yes, that's well beyond the amount of building materials used, but not unimaginatively so.
- lostapathy 6y agoHow much pavement exists per-capita? I'm sure that would lower the multiplier a lot too.
- bserge 6y agoYou assume the wealthy and powerful want to save everyone. I'm quite sure they don't. Just being upper class seems to turn most people into assholes who would rather let the poor die. "Why can't they make it, I did" is a common theme. The wealthy and powerful will be fine even as millions die off in newly unlivable areas. That's the brutal reality.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Just being upper class seems to turn most people into assholes who would rather let the poor die. "Why can't they make it, I did" is a common theme. That's dumb upper class. Smart upper class realizes their wealth and lifestyle are entirely dependent on keeping the rest of the world working, and satisfied enough they don't try to tear everything apart.
- rayiner 6y ago> If COVID has shown us anything, the answer to the last question is unequivocally no. COVID has been a very obvious salient problem and most nations failed the test. If we can't beat COVID, we will not beat climate change. No technology can change human nature. I think COVID actually teaches a different lesson. Our experience with COVID teaches that it has to be technology that addresses climate change, not political or sociological solutions. Lockdowns ultimately failed in even the most socially disciplined countries like Germany. But we got a vaccine developed in record time. Similarly for climate change, solutions that require "everyone to cooperate and do their part" won't work. It just won't. Even if the USA and Europe went to zero emissions tomorrow, growing CO2 emissions in industrializing China, India, and Africa are going to keep increasing global CO2 emissions. It's rational for them. Bangladesh is going to be one of the hardest-hit countries from climate change--an estimated 30-50% hit to GDP by 2100. But investing in rapid growth and industrialization, even at the cost of climate, still makes sense for Bangladesh. One, because of game theory--Bangladesh cannot by itself avoid climate change, due to emissions by other countries. Two, because of math--a 30-50% hit to what Bangladesh's economy could be in 80 years with strong growth would still leave it better of on net than risking doing anything to compromise the 5-7% annual GDP growth it has now and stagnating for that time. To mitigate climate change, the developed world needs moonshot technologies. We need to not only be investing in renewable energy--although that's necessary, going to zero emissions will still not be enough. We need to be investing massive amounts of money into carbon sequestration technology.
- telotortium 6y agoAnd to those who point out "China, Taiwan, South Korea, Australia, and New Zealand were able to suppress COVID through lockdowns", it's important to note they were able to nip it in the bud, before community spread had become established. This does speak to the effectiveness of a drastic lockdown, combined with travel restrictions, in eliminating COVID if there are only a small number of infections, and we should commend those countries for being able to do so. However, if you don't lock down very early, lockdowns don't seem to be able to control spread enough to eliminate the disease, only to somewhat reduce the infection rate, and even a successful suppression of COVID spread in a country will fail in the long term if travel restrictions are not extremely strict (see the EU). In other words, suppression achieved through lockdowns is an unstable equilibrium. Only herd immunity, ideally achieved via vaccination, produces a stable equilibrium for suppression. Similarly with global warming, while we may be able to temporarily reduce emissions, at significant economic cost, via political and sociological solutions without new technology, this reduction is an unstable equilibrium. The only permanent solution - the only stable equilibrium - is via technological means (cheap renewable energy and carbon sequestration).