4 ms·
The distinction between "central bank" and "ordinary bank" is only meaningful because of tight regulation and a central banking system that constrains ordinary
by wpietri 6y ago
The distinction between "central bank" and "ordinary bank" is only meaningful because of tight regulation and a central banking system that constrains ordinary banks.
The whole reason we have a strong central bank is because we tried the alternative before and it worked terribly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking
- bhupy 6y agoThat constraint is only really required because paper money can be minted in a way that BTC (or gold) cannot. That's why the distinction is relevant in the case of cryptocurrency. The overall point is that the ship has mostly sailed with regards to whether Bitcoin can be a deflationary store of value like gold. The question now is who will provide the vaults to hold the new "gold bars". These vault providers are not really comparable to central banks. > The whole reason we have a strong central bank is because we tried the alternative before and it worked terribly I think there's a strong argument to be made (derived from history) that having a purely gold-backed currency be the sole and legal tender is bad. That said, there's a third option: "porque no los dos?". Do we know for certain that there's anything inherently disastrous about a society that has BOTH fiat-backed legal tender as a hedge against "Wildcat banking" alongside "digital gold" backed currency as a hedge against fiat-backed legal tender? I think the answer is "probably not". I'd even go so far as to argue that we've already been doing that for the last 70-odd years; people still use gold as a hedge against the USD. Bitcoin is just digital gold that derives value because it's easier to trade Bitcoin for bread than gold bars (in theory).
- wpietri 6y agoI am always entertained by the line of argument that goes, "Do we know for certain this new twist will be as hugely destructive? If not, what the heck, let's find out!" Personally, I think the burden of proof goes the other way. Especially when after 12 years of Bitcoin innovation in practice it's so far mainly useful for scams, ransomware, market manipulation, money laundering, and other kinds of light financial crime. (Plus speculation of course, but there were plenty of options for that before.) If hobbyists want to speedrun reinventing financial regulation that's ok by me, but I'd rather they do it without the collateral damage. That's especially obvious in contrast with actual digital money efforts like MPesa, which have real user bases, scale perfectly well, and aren't ongoing ecological disasters.
- bhupy 6y agoWell, I'm glad I could provide you some entertainment! > Personally, I think the burden of proof goes the other way. Well, it's not exactly a brand new experiment, we already know what happens when you have a deflationary store of value alongside fiat currency, and we see that in Gold today. The concept isn't strictly unheard of. I think what's debatable is if the last 70 or so years of gold alongside fiat currencies is sufficient enough information for us to conclude that having things like gold and gold-like assets won't be disastrous to a financial system. > so far mainly useful for scams, ransomware, market manipulation, money laundering, and other kinds of light financial crime. (Plus speculation of course, but there were plenty of options for that before.) This is true of paper cash, too. There’s a common saying that if cash were invented today, it would be illegal, since it’s hard for the government to track and they wouldn’t like it, which I find amusingly true. The preponderance of bad people using a tool doesn't immediately render the tool itself bad. Bitcoin (and crypto) has been around for only 12 years now. Is it perfect? No absolutely not, there are a ton of kinks that need to be ironed out. Costs and speed need to be improved (probably through L2 protocols), we need to find ways to reduce energy consumption and use green energy as much as possible, we need to make sure that the money flowing into schemes like Tether is legitimate. I think the proponents all know that there is still lots of work to be done, and it feels like the detractors think that the adherents don't know that. What's especially entertaining to me, personally, is that I have no horse in this race; I don't work with or for any crypto institutions and I hold a tiny amount of play BTC/ETH just for curiosity's sake. I am neither a proponent nor a detractor. But the sheer amount of misinformation and strawmen arguments leveled against BTC has has pushed me to seek out the strongest possible arguments in favor of BTC, so thanks for that.
- wpietri 6y agoIf Bitcoin is the same as gold, then we don't really need Bitcoin. But its point is being different. So you can't handwave away concerns based on it being exactly the same. I'm not saying Bitcoin isn't perfect; nothing is. My point is that Bitcoin has not demonstrated any significant value certainly not in excess of its costs and harms, and it's had plenty of time. Bitcoin and Android are basically the same age. Bitcoin is still at best a niche, probably a shrinking one. Android is coming up on 3 billion users worldwide, providing clear daily value.