4 ms·
For collective transportation to succeed, collective living has to succeed. That is, a lot of people should live densely enough in towns. This is what you see i
by nine_k 6y ago
For collective transportation to succeed, collective living has to succeed. That is, a lot of people should live densely enough in towns. This is what you see in Germany, Netherlands, (northern) France, England, for instance. Public railways are well-developed there, and have been for a century or more.
But you can't expect the same in the US Midwest, for instance, where countryside and suburban living is prevalent. It's just impractical, so cars reign supreme.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> It's just impractical, so cars reign supreme. And a dedication to dense urban living would also seriously impact the development of those regions. Remote mining/lumber towns. Enormous farmsteads. The loan cowboy walking a fence for days. These are romantic concepts but they are also how resources are extracted efficiently. If people only ever stayed near mass transportation hubs North America would not be the powerhouse it is. To this day, huge areas of economic activity rely on that most common of tools: a person with a truck able to go where needed on a moment's notice. Beyond the suburbs, when your power goes out at 3am or your farm catches fire, the first and most likely only people on the scene will be driving their own vehicles.
- bluGill 6y agoThose regions would still have trucks to work with. In some ways they would be better trucks because they wouldn't have to sort though the trucks aimed at people who don't need a truck. When inspecting a fence line you want a slow truck with a lot of suspension travel. When you fill the bed of the truck you want a suspension that doesn't point the headlights at the sky, and don't care that the suspension system that can do this results in a rough unloaded ride.
- sandworm101 6y agoNothing angers country people more than city people telling them whether they should be allowed to drive a truck. Emissions control, gas over diesel, even all-electric is open for discussion. Just don't suggest that they use an app to call an uber when smoke comes over the horizon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Fort_McMurray_wildfire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Fort_McMurray_wildfire
- adam-a 6y agoWhat proportion of car owners do you think are also farmers or miners? I would have thought many more cars were in use by commuters who could take public transport if it were available.
- FlyMoreRockets 6y agoIt's not just farmers and miners, but the extensive support system that grows up around these activities. People living in mining and farming towns have to regularly drive longer distances than battery technology will support. For example, I am taking classes 5 days a week, but live 100 miles away in a farming community. Due to the nature of the course work, a significant portion is hands-on and cannot be done online. The campus has no charging stations and only relatively recently have electric cars had sufficient range.
- sandworm101 6y agoI'm in a similar boat. My car has been recalled (airbag issue). The nearest dealer who can do the service is 175km away. Being in a "town" of over 10,000 people doesn't mean you have honda/ford/toyota dealership nearby. The nearest tesla dealer is over 600km away. I have never seen a tesla round these parts and doubt I will for many years.
- qball 6y agoAlso, remember that if a new electric car is capable of performing a commute just barely within its range, it won't be in 5-10 years once the battery is sufficiently worn down, so you can forget about buying used. Oh, and once it's cold out, you might find out that you now no longer have the range to make it to where you need to go on a single charge. Maybe the car tells you in advance, or it doesn't and it runs out of juice, which a simple jerry-can isn't going to solve for obvious reasons. Electric cars are inferior to gasoline-powered ones in the long term due to their very nature as a consumable product and require more expensive maintenance to continue being useful than a gasoline car will over its useful lifetime. That is, if the car company even bothers to make replacement batteries, since the battery is the bulk of the cost of the car in the first place.
- 0_____0 6y agoIt took decades of car-centric design for American cities to be converted to sprawl. It will take decades more to converge back on livable cities.
- bluGill 6y agoThat isn't really true. While density does help, suburbs are still dense enough to support transit if everyone uses it. The problem if only a few people who don't need to drive drive anyway (and there is no real incentive for them not to - there is no traffic!) the whole fails. One the other hand, in the world where transit is common cars are expensive and primitive because there isn't manufacturing scale. Countryside living in some parts of Europe gets a bus even half an hour - enough to be useful for people who have a choice (but still annoying)
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoCity centers are too large! Take the train downtown from your suburb, sure. Then what? Walk 3 miles to work? If you need a car at your destination, then shared transportation moves way down the list of preferred options.
- nine_k 6y agoIn many dense cities (NYC, Tokyo, Berlin, Paris) transferring from a suburban train to a subway train is often walking like 0.05 mile, or even not at all. Then you have to walk maybe 1-2 blocks from a subway station to work, sometimes zero (in NYC at least).
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThat sounds ideal. And explains why cities without subway system, have no commuter train service either.
- kalleboo 6y agoUp to 3 miles is also easily doable on a bike
- eertami 6y agoIn the UK at least you often are not allowed to take a bike during rush hour on the busy train lines.
- southerntofu 6y ago> where countryside and suburban living is prevalent. It's just impractical, so cars reign supreme That a car is practical in many situations, i have no doubt. However being on the countryside doesn't mean you can't get trains near you. Half a century ago in France most folks on the countryside had a train station within walking range (or at least biking range) with a few trains going through every day. But these stations/rails have been discontinued in orchestrated policies dismantling public services (along with the hospitals, schools, etc). You can clearly see the result of such policy on a map of railway networks in France through time: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/09/Railway_map_of_France_-_animated_-_fr_-_medium.gif https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/09/Railway_... Simply because modern capitalist politics consider the countryside as an enormous farm or waste dump doesn't mean it is the only way. Also related, some french regions still have countryside buses going regularly and for a cheap fare (1-2€). It's simply a matter of policy/will.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoFrance has four times the population density of the United States. This doesn’t even begin to factor in just how sparse rural areas of the United States really are. The places that would see the most benefit are the suburbs, and ironically many blue states would benefit the most; and also have a rampant amount of NIMBYism to prevent this from ever happening.
- southerntofu 6y ago> France has four times the population density of the United States. Fair enough. But that doesn't refute entirely the idea that collective transportation could (not necessarily would) be more efficient / ecological.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoIt has its place, where the population is dense. In principle every city should have a well-running light rail or subway; and high speed trains can (and should) connect major metros. In reality, politics and NIMBYism makes this impossible. Eminent domain was meant to address this but somehow it’s abused for realtors and small-scale owners and not so much for grand, infrastructure projects that it was meant for. The United States could have gone a very direction, but we’re living with the legacy of Robert Moses—-who even then had to battle NIMBYism—who favored roads and cars.