3 ms·
> I think this is the problem the article is addressing I think the article has misidentified the problem. > "calling something what it is" doesn't convince p
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
> I think this is the problem the article is addressing
I think the article has misidentified the problem.
> "calling something what it is" doesn't convince people
Very seldom does anything convince anyone of anything.
> that don't agree with you on what it is, especially when the terms you use are loaded with possible implicit interpretations.
These kinds of culture signals work both ways. They can be used to filter out—to identify world views you don't wish to engage—but they can also be used to filter for refining one's own worldview. Identifying where an idea comes from a shared set of values and might illuminate something you haven't already considered within that same value structure (or might expand it).
> Which is to say that in a discussion or persuasive piece, it should be clear what you are arguing for or discussing without having to expose your whole worldview.
I categorically disagree with should here. You're welcome to value that, if your motivation is to engage in rigorous debate absent the impact that the topic of debate might have. If my motivation is to engage the topics by impacting them, I might care less about the rigor and more about some degree of blunt force response to the kinds of things which leave people I care about traumatized or dead.
> Arguments about the distribution of chores between males and females in a household, doesn't need to use the word "patriarchy" to make its argument.
It doesn't need to, but to the extent the argument is aware of patriarchy omitting it is either dishonestly hiding a system of power or reinventing a process of describing it that has generations of prior art.
> In fact, it tends to make the argument weaker given that "patriarchy" hides a lot of things that would otherwise need to be unpacked.
Hiding in what way? Why would a more assertive and clear description of the case obscure more of the reality than something mealymouthed?