6 ms·
rpi-open-firmware: open-source VPU side bootloader for Raspberry Pi
- h2odragon 6y agofrom 2018: Is this project dead? KB - No not dead but on hold, see my response · Issue #37 https://github.com/christinaa/rpi-open-firmware/issues/37 https://github.com/christinaa/rpi-open-firmware/issues/37
- ullarah 6y agoThis branch is 173 commits ahead of christinaa:master.
- bscphil 6y agoA side note to developers who fork Github projects to continue developing them: it's extremely helpful if you document the fact that your fork is a fork in the README, as well as the most significant changes, and remove any old information. You should also link to a complete list of changes (if possible) and say something about your future plans (i.e. if you are hoping to upstream your changes, whether you're planning to maintain this software long term, etc). Otherwise you're bound to get quite a bit of confusion from people who stumble across your work.
- nimbius 6y ago>It's not being developed but it's not dead. The bigger problem is that the pi is a solution waiting for a problem, and until it sees more purchase outside everyones desk drawer there is very little impetus to clean up the ARM/Microsoft dumpster fire that virtualizes a guest OS on the device. The only people pedaling it are FAANG, war-drumming furiously for kids to learn to code for the love of god so they can stop paying programmers a reasonable wage. everything the pi is touted to do, you can either accomplish with existing general computing or something like an arduino (and as a benefit, learn some electrical theory as well.)
- bscphil 6y agoUpvoted because while your comment is provocative, it's at least interestingly so. > everything the pi is touted to do, you can either accomplish with existing general computing or something like an arduino (and as a benefit, learn some electrical theory as well.) This may be true, but was it true when the Pi was released? For me, the Pi sits in an uncomfortable position where it's not really the best at anything it does. It's promoted at being for education, but arguably there are better solutions, and almost certainly the overwhelming majority of Pis purchased are by individuals and businesses, so this is a kind of misleading advertising. They included a chip for media decoding (including 4K HEVC), which is a dead giveaway that much of the draw isn't the education market, but it's shockingly limited. For instance, despite support for HDR being advertised with the release of the Pi 4, as far as I know it still doesn't work at all. High bitrate media often fails to decode in real time. So if it's a HTPC type use, you'd be much better served by an Nvidia Shield or something like that. The emphasis on netboot support suggests that they envision enterprise use cases, but it took them forever after the Pi was released to have this working fully. They include hardware design files that suggest it's designed for the hobbyist hardware market, but yet it's not truly open hardware at all, and in fact they've been drifting further away from that ideal over time. If anything, the niche is probably tinkering with hardware (given the number of add-on products), without having to jump in all the way with an arduino, but how many people who buy a Pi actually end up doing any of that? In the end, I suspect a lot of people bought them for the novelty of a $35 Linux computer. I say all that, but naturally I own 3 of them myself. :-)
- wmf 6y agoThe RPi uses chips originally designed for set top boxes which kinda explains the video focus (that and every SoC has video decoding these days).
- kingosticks 6y ago> and in fact they've been drifting further away from that ideal over time. Can you provide a source where "open hardware" was touted as an ideal for the Raspberry Pi Foundation. It's a cheap education platform built on Broadcom hardware. I don't think there was ever much chance the Broadcom h/w was going to be open. And that's maybe sad for some people but it won't stop the Foundation achieving its actual goals. Open hardware enthusiasts can vote with their wallet, for all the impact it'll have. It must be one of the best selling novelty products of all time.
- sneak 6y agoNote that this is probably only applicable for Pis <= v3. The RPi v4 is quite a different animal.
- pabs3 6y agoThere is work being done on the RPi4, for example the SHA1 HMAC protecting the boot on the RPi4 had to be cracked (and was easily), I hear future versions have RSA signing support, so the proprietary firmware might become mandatory at some point. https://github.com/librerpi/rpi-open-firmware/blob/master/docs/cracking-rpi4-hmac.txt https://github.com/librerpi/rpi-open-firmware/blob/master/do...
- SilverRed 6y agoThe RPI is pretty sad from a software freedoms point. The entire thing is backdoored with proprietary firmware and filled with DRM. Even the camera module uses DRM to communicate.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoHowever it does not come "bundled" with an OS. It is more versatile than many development boards in the sense of running different OS "out of the box". Granted the boot process is not ideal, but the design does give users a degree of freedom of choice in OS that many other SBCs do not. Most dev boards (certainly ones pre-RPi) are targeted at a single OS "out of the box": Linux. How many run Plan9. I read this complaint about the RPi firmware so often on HN but I have never read how it actually is being used to stop RPi owners from doing what they want with their RPi. It is theoretically a problem but in practice what has actually happened. There has been an enormous amount of tinkering with RPis, people are using them for all sorts of things, and are able to build on the work of others. DRM is important but viewing copyrighted works is not the only use for a computer. There is no perfect computer but the RPi for its OS-versatilty is arguably better than many others who fail miserably on that point. There are certainly better dev boards from a spec standpoint, but if it cannot boot off external media and is only intended to run a single OS, I think it is missing some "freedoms" that the RPi provides.
- j-james 6y agoWhat is the reason the Raspberry Pi is not open at a lower level? Is it because the Raspberry Pi foundation is shipping a premade chip package, or do they run their own software and have their own reasons for keeping it closed? Also, what does this closed-off lower level hinder or prevent?
- segmondy 6y agowill probably get cloned and sold at a discounted rate undercutting the foundation
- chungus_khan 6y agoI can't speak specifically to the raspberry pi, but generally SOCs like it uses do work like that. Most customers are concerned with the chip's high-level capabilities and actively don't want to touch the lower-level stuff, as it's irrelevant to what they're making.
- pabs3 6y agoProbably they are constrained by their choice of using Broadcom SoCs, which happened because the project was started by Broadcom employees.
- MisterTea 6y ago> What is the reason the Raspberry Pi is not open at a lower level? Broadcom. Much of the Raspberry pi lower level software has been closed since its inception as Broadcom will not publicly release specs.