6 ms·
One thing I've noticed with bitcoin related threads is that people who have bitcoin tend to be much more defensive when there's any anti-coin criticism, which i
by endisneigh 6y ago
One thing I've noticed with bitcoin related threads is that people who have bitcoin tend to be much more defensive when there's any anti-coin criticism, which is kind of amusing.
Another thing I wonder with bitcoin in particular is if everyone had bitcoin and no other currency, and something like COVID happened, what entity would provide liquidity in order to help those affected by a disaster?
disclaimer: I do not hold any crypto.
- wongarsu 6y ago> what entity would provide liquidity in order to help those affected by a disaster? For most of history, countries couldn't make money appear out of thin air (outside of mining more silver or later gold, which has practical limits). In good times countries made a tax surplus that they could spend in bad times. Or they borrow money from financiers and pay it back later.
- omegaworks 6y agoAnd we saw how a blind obedience to those principles prolonged the Great Depression[1]. FDR's economic reforms, including getting the world economy off the Gold Standard, propelled the recovery and allowed the US to meet the needs of the war effort. 1. https://www.history.com/news/how-did-the-gold-standard-contribute-to-the-great-depression#:~:text=The%20government%20raised%20the%20price,depths%20of%20the%20Great%20Depression https://www.history.com/news/how-did-the-gold-standard-contr....
- wongarsu 6y agoIt certainly has disadvantages. Great Britain lost their US colonies in large part because they needed to raise taxes to pay for their debts. But the power to just print money has to be used responsibly, there's no shortage of examples of countries damaging their economy by triggering hyperinflation. And if you want a global currency there is no institution that would be trusted with that kind of responsibilty by enough countries.
- omegaworks 6y agoNot sure how your first point is relevant. The Great Depression was in the 1930s, the US colonies declared their independence in 1776. Of course the power to print money comes with responsibility. That isn't up for debate. I think you will find hyperinflation more tightly correlated with economic sanctions that cut off countries from the global trade market. A currency is worthless if you can't buy goods with it. It's a phenomena that grew out of western imperialists that levied massive debts on their former colonies in exchange for independence. Colonies that reneged on those debts were sanctioned. Physically and violently prevented from engaging in trade, ships pilfered etc. Many new governments responded by printing the money those debts were issued in - if they could.
- piracy1 6y ago> Another thing I wonder with bitcoin in particular is if everyone had bitcoin and no other currency, and something like COVID happened, what entity would provide liquidity in order to help those affected by a disaster? What? It's not specific to the way you transact. Governments are providing liquidity, if the whole world used crypto they would do payouts the same way just in crypto. Perhaps I misunderstand the question.
- sanderjd 6y agoThey would not be able to immediately mint trillions of dollars of crypto assets (at least not bitcoin specifically).
- endisneigh 6y agoModern governments usually provide liquidity by simply printing money out of thin air and giving it to those who need it. This causes inflation potentially but is thought to be a fair trade for stimulus. What "entity" would give people bitcoins?
- cfcosta 6y agoNone actually, inflation is felt immediately on Bitcoin. The government would have to keep their books in order, which thankfully crypto also helps. Market making in crypto is usually done by overcollateralized liquidity pools, farming and staking.
- piracy1 6y agoOh, well that's kinda the whole point, it has real value beyond the whims of a centralized body, you can't do that, save for a rainy day.
- xiphias2 6y agoIt's normal to be defensive, as what your net worth is put in is one of the most important decisions of your life, like a religion. I'm sure a person who uses apartments as a store of value in San Francisco (and renting them out) would be quite defensive if the city would want to get rid of zoning regulations.
- 6510 6y agoCOVID coin!
- ausbah 6y agothis is one of the "selling points" of most cryptos isn't it? that the # of assets in circulation is fixed and not susceptible to manipulation by a central entity
- Matumio 6y agoI guess next year's taxes will have to be paid in NewGovCoin, which nobody has yet. Then hand out NewGovCoin to those who need help.
- wmf 6y agoIf everyone had Bitcoin and no other currency you'd have a feudal hellscape. Maybe the bitocracy would offer victims some sort of indenture...
- leesalminen 6y ago> what entity would provide liquidity in order to help those affected by a disaster? Maybe if governments weren’t able to paper themselves out of bad decisions, they would make fewer bad decisions?
- leereeves 6y agoGovernments made plenty of bad decisions when money was still tied to the gold standard. And to fix those bad decisions, they resorted to drastic measures like seizing property. Gradual inflation of fiat currency is a dramatic improvement over those days.