4 ms·
> What's fair about making people pay more tax just because the market value of their house has increased? If you believe that, then why ratchet them up just b
by ryandrake 6y ago
> What's fair about making people pay more tax just because the market value of their house has increased?
If you believe that, then why ratchet them up just because the property is sold? If you're going to detach property taxes from the value of the property, then do it for new homeowners too.
If we are scaling property taxes with the property's value, we might as well do it for everyone and not treat people special just because they were living there longer. Other costs people deal with scale at least by local cost of living. Groceries, electricity, water service, etc. all increase year after year. Do we let people pay 1960s costs for everything else just because they happened to move to the area in 1960?
Prop 13 as it currently stands, is a wealth transfer from young, new homeowners to elderly, established homeowners.
- eweise 6y agoProperty values go up over time. I initially paid $8k a year and now its $14K, which is actually about right for the market. I am protected from wild increases so that I don't have to move my kids out of a neighborhood and school they've grown up in. I agree that scaling property taxes with their values is bad. Not sure why government expenses magically double when housing value do.
- gkop 6y agoLook into land value tax. The goal of property tax is not just to fund collective expenses, but also to encourage the most valuable use of the land for the collective benefit (eg. let's not waste valuable inner Bay Area land on single family homes, but instead with more dense uses like four plexes). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
- eweise 6y agoI guess that makes sense if your goal is to use land most efficiently. Not sure that what is most important though.
- gkop 6y agoAgreed, it's a balance. I think replacing prop 13 with taxes deferable until sale would be a good step in the right direction.
- rcpt 6y agoThe existing lock in effect of 13 would be orders of magnitude stronger. Nobody would ever sell and prices would skyrocket.
- gkop 6y agoHuh? Eventually the current owners will die
- rcpt 6y agoYes but there are places in the world where the house you buy when you're 30 isn't the one with your deathbed. Ideally living people will move out and make room for the next generation when they no longer have use for 4 bedrooms in a good school district close to jobs.
- gkop 6y agoAre you satisfied with the status quo in California, or do you think we can do better?
- rcpt 6y agoObviously we can do better. And the best way to go about it is to end Prop 13 in it's entirety immediately.
- gkop 6y agoGreat. So to get that rolling, split roll obviously was a great first step, that unfortunately failed. But we should try again. Beyond split roll, do you have ideas to 1) protect people that would be harmed by an immediate rollback of 13 and 2) build the political coalition to get it done?
- jjav 6y ago> If you believe that, then why ratchet them up just because the property is sold? An argument here is that it's about budgeting and predictability. If I choose to buy a $1M property today, I need to consider and budget for the $10K+/yr in taxes on it because I know full well that's what I'll have to pay. If that doesn't work for me, I don't have to buy it. But someone who bought a $50K property and responsibly budgeted for the $500 in taxes on it will be severely punished through no fault of their own if that $500 becomes $10K.
- rcpt 6y agoPeople who made a $50k leveraged bet which is now worth $1M are who we're supposed to ruin our schools, parks, infrastructure and housing market for?
- jjav 6y ago> People who made a $50k leveraged bet They did not "make a leveraged bet". They bought a home to live in and watch their child grow in it. Not everyone looks at real estate as a investment vehicle to maximize profits. It's just a home. It's not healthy for society to view homes merely as if they were shares of stock to be traded for maximum value. If you want to make leveraged bets, better to play the options market.
- rcpt 6y agoOh ok great. So how do I buy one of these "just a homes"?
- jjav 6y agoFind a city and neighborhood you like and are interested in setting roots there for the long haul. Find a house that you love that can be a forever home for your preferences. Don't think of it as an investment to flip. Think of it as home. After the purchase, no need to ever look at the property value estimates again. Just live it.
- wooger 6y agoIt doesn't even need to be someone who moved to the area who's grandfathered in to the cheap taxes: Families can share ownership of a property and retain it forever. It's an insanely unfair system.