2 ms·
My question would be: if you buy N drones for price of one F-35, do you get better military value for your money or not? At the very least, N drones can't be d
by inglor_cz 6y ago
My question would be: if you buy N drones for price of one F-35, do you get better military value for your money or not?
At the very least, N drones can't be destroyed at once (unless stored really carelessly) and can be individually specialized in a way that provides wider spectrum of capabilities.
A massive bonus: pilotless aircraft can perform manoeuvres unsurvivable for humans, and the ability to maneuver was always a strong point in the air.
- jazzyjackson 6y agoWhen I go looking for a source I see a lot of "may be" and "soon will" but I've heard one capability of the F-35 is to command drones without connection to base stations, since radio relays can become (lets say) unreliable in open war. There are also offensive capabilities against enemy drones, remember when Iran landed a US drone by hacking it? Whose to say that any drones in the vicinity of an F-35 aren't captured mid-flight and turned against their own team? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid...
- inglor_cz 6y agoThe radio troubles that you mention is probably the main reason why the US military is so interested in Starlink. Few potential opponents have the capability to destroy Starlink, or even jam it thoroughly.
- greedo 6y agoStarlink has nothing to do with C3I. And it can easily be jammed, as any frequency can.
- hef19898 6y agoThese drones themselves are rather expensive, and you need large numbers of them. Also, smaller drones would tend to be expendable one-use things. But sill that's what most concepts call for today. These concepts do need refinement, so, especially on the cost side. An for continued use in a conventional conflict.
- spiritplumber 6y agoGeneral Zevo was right...
- hyko 6y agoQuantity does have a quality all of its own... It’s obviously possible to imagine a scenario where you have a massive number of drones, the question would be whether you could channel that into tactics that would give you an advantage. Numeric superiority is sometimes useful, and sometimes a liability. The F-35 currently has a massive advantage over cutting edge drones - a MK I brain in control of the airframe that cannot be jammed. Its electronic warfare capabilities could create havoc for the drone swarm and deny the enemy remote sensing etc. Until there’s actual conflict though, it’s pretty much like asking whether Mike Tyson or Bruce Lee would win in a fight :)
- manquer 6y agoBruce lee would win a street fight easily. A boxing match ? Mike tyson will probably be better at. It doesn't have to be theoretical at all. The air force can just easily have mock battles v drones to evaluate performance if they wanted to. The speed of autonomous avaition navigation development is far exceeding the speed of innovation in traditional nth generation fighter planes. Inherently the human will always be slower. The drone will have higher manuverbilty has high g will not be a factor. Imprvoing the algorithms to match or improve human response will happen sooner or later (it is not hard AGI category of problem). The drones are cheaper and easier to manufacture then fighter planes or pilots trained for this kind of high end aircraft. AFAIK the electronic warfare capabilities of f35 are not designed towards drones. Even then performance against cluster of drones is different matter altogether.