4 ms·
My Jewish family was kicked out of Gaza in 1929. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1929_Palestine_riots#Jewish_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1929_Pales
by fortran77 6y ago
My Jewish family was kicked out of Gaza in 1929.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1929_Palestine_riots#Jewish_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1929_Palestine_riots#Jewish_co...
You've probably never been to Israel or Gaza.
I've very happy to read the story of this woman getting a job in Silicon Valley, and of the success of the people in Gaza.
- patall 6y agoMy grandma was born in 1936 in the city of Poznan as ethnically german child with a polish passport. Her family owned a shop and house the shop was in. Then, the nazis occupied poland, and the family prospered shortly. But the father, who had been a polish soldier before, had to enlist in the german forces and fell on the eastern front. Then the SU conquered the entire area and my grandmas familty lost every thing they could not carry: the house, the shop, the grandparents house with farm land, etc. More people lost their lives, greatgrandma was most likely raped, etc. Grandma missed a year of shool and ended up 5-10 centimeters shorter than the relatives. Now, 70 years later, does she hate the polish, or the russians, for what happened? Of course not.
- fortran77 6y agoBut you haven't been "flagged" for telling your story. I get flagged for telling mine.
- dang 6y agoI think you're getting flagged for personal attacks and slurs (e.g. "You're just an American who wants to hate someone"), which is quite different than telling your story. I totally get and appreciate why you have strong feelings on the topic. But we can't have comments breaking the rules like that here.
- 2fc00c733a5519 6y agoBut why should she ever hate Poles in the first place? Poland was occupied by the Germans and Russians, one after another.
- DSingularity 6y agoI’ve been to multiple cities in Israel and the occupied territories.
- poweronselftest 6y agoReferring to Jewish settlement in Palestine as "immigration" doesn't really paint the complete picture, generally. Sure, some Jews immigrated to Palestine/Israel as we think of immigration. But many did not. For example: I had a great-great uncle who was originally from Poland. Fearing the Germans, he escape Poland (on foot, alone, as a young teenager) shortly after the German invasion to live with his family in Ukraine (my direct ancestors). They survived together in Evacuation [1]. After the war, he decided to go back to Poland. What happened to him there, in 1946, was that he was forcefully removed from the country by his neighbors [2], who were pleased that Jews had been removed from their society and did not want them to return. He ended up in a DP camp, and with nowhere else to go, went to Palestine. Did he displace the local population there? I guess. Did he have other options? No. What was he supposed to do, drown himself? In his story I see a plight not very different from Syrian refugees in Europe or Guatemalan refugees in the United States. I think his story is hardly unique, and explains largely why Israel exists in the first place. If you view the presence of Jews in Palestine as European Colonialism, I think your perspective has a very limited and selective in scope. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evacuation_in_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evacuation_in_the_Soviet_Union [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielce_pogrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielce_pogrom
- Daho0n 6y ago>Did he displace the local population there? I guess. Did he have other options? No. What was he supposed to do, drown himself? Those were not the only two options. You mentioned the Syrian refugees. They did come here where I live but unlike in Palestine they don't displace anyone but became part of the populace. No-one is or were forcing anyone to displace Palestinians. You are turning a sad story into a propaganda piece which helps no-one. Just like my Syrian friend, who now owns a restaurant he started with local help, one could become part of israel without being part of the forced displacement programs.
- poweronselftest 6y ago> You mentioned the Syrian refugees. They did come here where I live but unlike in Palestine they don't displace anyone but became part of the populace. No-one is or were forcing anyone to displace Palestinians. The displacement of Palestinian Arabs occurred as the result of a civil war that took place between them an Palestinian Jews in 1948. Prior to that, there was no displacement, at least nothing like what happened in 1948. Yes, the dynamic with Syrians in Europe is different, because they can't possibly engage in a civil war with the local population. But the Civil War between Jews and Arabs in Palestine occurred, and the result was mass displacement of Arabs as the Jews won. Had the Civil War not occurred, Arabs would have been part of the Jewish state as partitioned by the United Nations in 1947. Many Arabs are, in fact, Israeli Citizens (with a Covid vaccination rate roughly as high as Ultra Orthodox Jews).* What I am saying is: Yes, there were aggressive Zionists who came to Palestine to fight fight fight**. But the majority of refugees who came to Palestine just wanted to be left alone, and were forced into a fight by their ethnic alignment that was decided for them at birth, the same ethnic alignment that forced them to Palestine in the first place. [*] And why are these Arabs citizens of Israel? More often than not, because their ancestors who were alive in 1948 had a history of peaceful enough co-existence with Jews, or their village was location geographically such that they did not pose a perceived threat during the civil war. As bad as population displacement is, the Jews by and large did not arbitrarily displace people in 1948. The perspective was at the time that either a strategic foothold is established, or the opposing Arab armies will finish Hitler's job, which would have certainly been the case. [**] For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ze'ev_Jabotinsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ze'ev_Jabotinsky