4 ms·
But the books are also well-meaning busybodies. Worse: The books that most resonate with you may well be the ones you need to ignore. Take strict vs permissi
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
But the books are also well-meaning busybodies.
Worse: The books that most resonate with you may well be the ones you need to ignore.
Take strict vs permissive parenting, for example. Say you're by nature a more permissive parenting. The books that say you should be permissive will resonate more with you than the books that say that you should be strict. But it's the ones that say to be strict that you need to hear, because they're the ones that are against your natural bent. (Nobody needed to tell you to be permissive, you were going to do that anyway.)
(My position here is that either strict or permissive, taken too far, will be problematic. So you can swap strict and permissive in the previous paragraph, and everything is still true.)
So don't just read parenting books and listen to the ones that strike a chord with you. It's the other ones that you need to carefully consider what they say.
- gumby 6y agoFunny you should say that, I just read a comment on HN claiming the opposite. Let me search for it and then edit this comment with the link...
- ianai 6y agoThat’s the thing about the internet. If you posit P to be true then a vehement Not P believer will attack your comment with “fire and fury” and any form of attack that could work but still be false. And some of the times they’re correct of course and Not P is indeed true While P is not.
- gumby 6y agoWe’re all complicated humans. What’s amazing about the child rearing is that each of us has such a small n. Yet we (me included) think we know the secrets. When my kid has a kid I hope I will be smart enough to keep my trap shut until asked.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI'm confused... Why would I want to ignore something which resonates with me? Isn't that the whole point of "resonance" and "feelings", to use them to guide our reason? I would read the books on permissive parenting not to convince myself that it's right, but to find techniques and strategies which work.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIn Zion National Park, there's a trail called Angels Landing. It goes up a ridge with a 500 foot dropoff on one side, and a 1000 foot dropoff on the other. The ridge between them is only a couple feet wide in places. I think of parenting that way - there's a cliff on one side (too much strictness, say), but don't back too far away from it, because there's also a cliff on the other side (too permissive). So when you see the cliff, don't back too far away from the cliff you see, because there's a cliff in the other direction too. So if you lean toward permissiveness, say, you don't need a book that warns you not to be too strict. You're already not going to be too strict. You need a book that warns you not to be too permissive. > Isn't that the whole point of "resonance" and "feelings", to use them to guide our reason? That only works if your feelings are more correct than your reason is. That happens, sometimes, but... I don't think it should be the default mode of operation. Reason alone can also lead you to absurd results. You need both, your feelings to know when you have reasoned yourself into a position that just doesn't fit, and your reason to know when your feelings are liars.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI think that's a pretty extreme view... But when navigating a narrow ridge like that, books can wait and I'm definitely following my gut.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoSure. But on the actual trail, you can see the edges. In parenting, you can't, and it takes you years to realize that you fell off it.