6 ms·
https://engineering.gusto.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-perspective-part-1/ https://engineering.gusto.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-pers... A good time to remi
by dragontamer 6y ago
https://engineering.gusto.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-perspective-part-1/ https://engineering.gusto.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-pers...
A good time to remind people that the USA's money-transfer system (aka: ACH) is a giant Rube-Goldberg machine involving FTP transfers of specially formatted files.
So it sounds like the Fed's FTP server is down?? Or something like that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ohiovr 6y agoWhy wouldn't they use SFTP?
- sodality2 6y agoMeet the US government... Triple DES is still used for backwards compatibility in banking
- dragontamer 6y agoThe Fed is a private entity actually. The Treasury is US Government. But the Fed is owned by the member banks. The US kinda coopted a seat at their table and Congress + President appoints the Fed head. But otherwise, the rest of the board is made up by private companies.
- Meekro 6y agoCalling the Fed a private entity is really misleading. It was created by an act of Congress and its highest ranking officials, the Board of Governors, are all appointed by the President. Yes, it shares some power with the banks it regulates (who can elect representatives), but the US government didn't "coopt a seat at the table." It built the table and had most of the seats from the start. And it's true that member banks own stock in the Fed, but it's a super-funky kind of stock ownership. That stock can't be sold or traded, and doesn't grant the kind of voting rights one normally associates with stock ownership. It only entitles the stockholder to their share of the dividends the Fed pays every year. The Fed actually returns nearly all of its profits (something like 95%) to the US Treasury, and pays the rest as dividends to shareholder banks.
- jerry1979 6y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but people constructed a cleavage between the Fed and the US Govt because they thought we shouldn't trust democracy with money creation.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe proper role of the US Government and Money has been under debate ever since Hamilton was appointed Treasury Secretary under George Washington. (EDIT: actually, even earlier than that, but the country didn't exist yet...) Jefferson wanted one system, Hamilton wanted another. And the two sides have been arguing for the past 200+ years. Sometimes, the central bank appears, sometimes it disappears. Then silver+gold, then removal of the silver standard (gold-only standard), then etc. etc. etc. The Revolutionary War required money and bonds. Immediately upon the end of that war came the question of how to organize and pay those loans. Should it be held by the states? Or by the national government? Should a central bank even exist, or is a loose collection of banks good enough? Should there be a national currency, or should the States make their own currency? The Continental Congress's dollar was hit severely by inflation: losing 99% of its value in just a decade or so. Not a big deal: most Americans used Spanish Pesos back then due to their reliable silver weight. The money issue was front-and-center at the birth of this country. Lots of debate and discussion (and duels!!) occurred over the issue. Arguing about money (literally to death) is a proud American tradition.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The proper role of the US Government and Money has been under debate ever since Hamilton was appointed Treasury Secretary under George Washington. (EDIT: actually, even earlier than that, but the country didn't exist yet...) In regard to the parenthetical, the country existed either from the First Continental Congress, the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, or the surrender at Yorktown, but in any case before the adoption of the Constitution, much less Hamilton's appointment under it as the first Secretary of the Treasury, which is a really odd point to chose as the starting point of the nation.
- 6y ago
- smitty1e 6y ago>The Fed is a private entity actually. The idea of the Federal Reserve urinates all over the Constitutional principle that people weilding power stand for election. Doom on us for permitting such.
- lrem 6y agoDon't touch if it isn't broken? From what I've seen in other countries, you don't update protocols for this. You introduce better ones and kill the old ones once nobody used them for a while. Which might take longer than expected, because "free instant transfers" might be seen as cannibalizing the "slightly less slow expensive transfers" any given bank might have on offer.
- xtracto 6y agoI deal with the ACH network on a daily basis and let me tell you it IS broken. The fact that you only receive negative ack when a transaction fails, otherwise you have to pray your transaction went through is so bad it sounds like a joke. For comparison, the third world underdeveloped country where I live has an electronic cash transfer system allowing me to send ANY amount of money in 10 minutes at most for $0.5 usd.
- throwaway20875 6y agoI worked in fintech in NYC for a bit. The technology driving most critical financial infrastructure in the US is astoundingly antiquated. It is only sustained through the sheer amount of bodies and ingenuity thrown at it.
- gruez 6y agoIt's probably VPNed and/or FTP over TLS (aka FTPS).
- xtracto 6y agoNo, these things use SFTP which is mainly ssh over 22
- gruez 6y agoanecdotal counter-evidence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7647166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7647166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7638063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7638063 This is probably because people often conflate SFTP (ssh-based protocol) with FTPS (FTP over TLS) eg. royal bank which says "secure ftp" (which suggests SFTP), but also mentions SSL (which suggests FTPS). https://www.rbcroyalbank.com/ach/cid-212563.html https://www.rbcroyalbank.com/ach/cid-212563.html
- throwawayboise 6y agoIt's OK, customers can use the backup system which is sending in 9-track tape reels via FedEx.
- analog31 6y agoIt's reassuring to know that our money system is safe from parity errors.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- efficax 6y agoSome of the first software I ever wrote for pay was a daily shell script that pgp encrypted an ACH batch and sent it from one financial institution to another over a dedicated frame-link, via FTP. This was over 20 years ago! Can't believe it's still the same.
- cout 6y agoSounds like bliss! Twenty years ago I was working on a project that received financial data through a Y-cable connected to a printer port. One day, we stopped getting data and could not figure out why. Turns out the printer had run out of paper.
- aksss 6y agoWe had to write jobs to encrypt the NACHA files and send over FTP years ago, but I was at the same company long enough (prior to 2010) to see the banks at least adopt SFTP. Slightly better, but still encrypted the files. Hey, it works and is reliable. I learned banks are really cheap, though, definitely not in the mood to spend money on new systems/processes even if they'd improve productivity.
- agumonkey 6y ago> involving FTP transfers of specially formatted files. during my internship, a big healthcare representative came at the company to ask for help about their IT system. Turns out it was mass FTP transfer. I was silent for a few minutes thinking hospital networks relied on this.
- dmd 6y agoAnd then there's DICOM for transferring medical images, which most places don't authenticate at ALL (or do just based on the AETITLE, which is almost always the name of the manufacturer e.g. SIEMENS).
- toomim 6y agoFedwire is not ACH. Those are different systems. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedwire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedwire [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACH_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACH_Network Fedwire is a much faster, more modern system than ACH. You can only access it if you are a bank, though. ACH is available to anyone, but it's old and uses FTP. There are also a faster modernized next-day and same-day versions of ACH available as of the last few years. I haven't checked out their protocols, though, to see if they still use FTP.
- avereveard 6y ago> FTP transfers of specially formatted files. there's nothing wrong with that, at least it isn't fake-rest, and most other delivery technology are proprietary anyway.
- samstave 6y agoSo an FTP story of history: TL;DR: this is how LinuxCare came to be: 1997 - BindCo was a contract manfacturer for the publication of all SUN Systems OS CD media... Based in Redwood City Ca. I was the IT manager there... So SUN has a conf call with us, as we were creating and serving and receiving orders via FTP (I cant recall the name for the process) - but basically: We would receive an order manifest via FTP to a server and then we would have to make an order form for what was required... Our FTP servers required us to login and manually accept and find these manifests.... So we hired some consultants; Dave Sifry and some others who went on to google etc.. But here was the thing: We were taking orders via FTP and SUN wanted us to start accepting this new protocol they deemed XML and wanted us to be the test case for XML and I did something stupid: I, on a call with SUN, said the following as a young IT manager: "So let me get this straight; *"You have a crappy data reporting system and you want us to install an unknown system called XML for data qualification into our system and we have never heard of it"* Yeah, I might have prevented months of adoption of XML by accident. What have you done as a major fuck-up in your career? That company became LinuxCare and Sifry was valued at $100 million Just based on me telling david he should create a company that offered Linux support...