3 ms·
No, if the entire population of the United States, except the members of the Supreme Court agreed on something they can and would override all Supreme Court dec
by endisneigh 6y ago
No, if the entire population of the United States, except the members of the Supreme Court agreed on something they can and would override all Supreme Court decisions. The Supreme Court does not function the way you think it does.
The main reason the Supreme Court appears to have so much power is because our Legislative Branch has been slow to actually pass new laws, meaning the interpretation of existing laws to new scenarios is becoming more and more important.
- ghaff 6y agoIf an overwhelming percentage of the population disagrees with the Supreme Court on something, they can of course pass a constitutional amendment. For example, if enough people didn't like the Obergefell v. Hodges decision (gay marriage), a constitutional amendment could presumably (IANAL) have been passed that said states can only recognize marriage between a man and a woman.(This may get into state sovereignty issues but not important for this discussion). Now, as a practical matter, the Supreme Court is a political creature and tends not to stray too far from popular opinion. Thus, the decision above was possible in 2015. It's likely not a right they'd have "discovered" in 1980. However, the Supreme Court has certainly made decisions such as Brown v. Board of Education that were almost certainly not majority opinion even in many relatively liberal locations.
- endisneigh 6y agoI think we have a slight misunderstanding. I'm not saying that the Supreme Court doesn't make decisions that are not popular. I'm simply responding to the original claim that the Supreme Court exists so the majority doesn't have absolute power, as you originally stated. This we now apparently agree on. Now, as for the rest of your post - I completely agree.
- ghaff 6y agoYou're splitting hairs. The Supreme Court is absolutely a check on majority rule--even if it's also the case that it can effectively be over-ridden by a supermajority that goes through a typically lengthy constitutional amendment process. That it's a check doesn't mean that it has absolute final say for all time.
- mamon 6y ago>> the Supreme Court is a political creature and tends not to stray too far from popular opinion. Supreme Court's role is to be a stabilizing factor, because majority can switch from Democrats to Republicans every four years. Supreme Court's partisan composition is basically a moving average of the last 5-6 presidential election's results, thus smoothing out temporary whims of the society.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> majority can switch from Democrats to Republicans every four years. Two years, actually, assuming only regular elections and ignoring other changes in office-holding.