4 ms·
I understand what you're saying, but in terms of coming up with a decision in which the majority is happy, a majority decision is inherently always the most opt
by endisneigh 6y ago
I understand what you're saying, but in terms of coming up with a decision in which the majority is happy, a majority decision is inherently always the most optimal. The parent post example is effectively an example of that.
I do concede that for general governance what I'm talking about obviously requires more nuance.
- whimsicalism 6y agoWhat about a 60% majority voting to commit kill the other 40% of the population because they felt mildly irritated by that 40%? How does killing 40% weigh against relieving the irritation of 60% and how is that optimal?
- endisneigh 6y agoAgain, this has already happened in the American Civil War. In your example the issue would be resolved or the country should fracture. Also, would the reverse scenario (40% deciding to kill the 60% majority) be more optimal? No, it wouldn't. Assuming people have to die, it would be more optimal for the 40% to die than the 60%. Obviously if this was actually happening a moderate stance would emerge and they (being the majority likely) would decide there shouldn't be any death at all and that would win out. Your examples are ridiculous and make having a meaningful discussion difficult. A good example, if you can think of one, is one where the minority is right and the majority is wrong without stating the majority is somehow worse than the minority.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I understand what you're saying, but in terms of coming up with a decision in which the majority is happy, a majority decision is inherently always the most optimal Sure, but why would that be the goal unless one believes that utility is a simple binary of “happy” vs. “not happy” and policy choices are also simple binaries? If the amount of (un)happiness is more complex than 0/1 and you have a complex multidimensional policy space, majoritarianism may be the most tractable general approach, but it is delusional to think it is necessarily inherently optimal. A lot of rules diverging from majoritarianism in otherwise majoritarian systems are designed in recognition of this and in the belief that the concentration of impacts of decisions in a particular domain make it particularly prone to the kind of things where majoritarianism is distinctly nonoptimal.