3 ms·
> What if the majority make a law saying "anyone gay or black is to be executed"? What you're saying has already happened. The majority realized that was a ter
by endisneigh 6y ago
> What if the majority make a law saying "anyone gay or black is to be executed"?
What you're saying has already happened. The majority realized that was a terrible idea and undid that law.
> Or "anyone with more than $1 million in assets should pay a 90% tax rate"?
What's wrong with that? If it ends up being a bad idea the majority will undo the decision.
> Or "wildfire prevention, nuclear power plant inspection, SEC regulation, should all be defunded in favor of a federal football team with free bread at the stadium"? Maybe it takes 10-20 years for huge-impact consequences to be felt, and in the meantime you get free bread.
Yes, and once the realize the consequences the majority will undo their decision.
There are no problems with any of your examples. What's the alternative? The minority of the population makes all of the decisions?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonahx 6y ago> What's the alternative? The minority of the population makes all of the decisions? That some decisions are based on evidence and expert-knowledge. Of course, this can be gamed, but it's not clear at all that this risk is greater than the risk of damage by the short-term thinking or false reasoning of an uninformed majority.
- endisneigh 6y agoI disagree - in your post you're assuming an "uninformed" and "false reasoning" with respect to the majority but not this so-called "expert" minority. Knowledge spreads - the majority will take it into account, and if they're wrong the majority will undo it as the majority will feel the effects.
- jonahx 6y agoI would argue this claim is empirically false. > and if they're wrong the majority will undo it as the majority will feel the effects. This assumes the majority will correctly identify the root cause. Whereas, in fact, they cannot do this even in simple cases, let alone a case where the root cause was an innocuous-seeming policy enacted 10+ years ago. Especially while the current politicians du jour are providing dramatic, simple, alternative narratives of the cause to suit their own goals.
- endisneigh 6y ago> This assumes the majority will correctly identify the root cause. Whereas, in fact, they cannot do this even in simple cases, let alone a case where the root cause was an innocuous-seeming policy enacted 10+ years ago. Especially while the current politicians du jour are providing dramatic, simple, alternative narratives of the cause to suit their own goals. I agree, but it's still no worse (and in practice much better) than trying to let the minority figure it out, whom are no more likely to figure out the root cause either. We can probably agree that governance is complicated though.
- jonahx 6y ago> We can probably agree that governance is complicated though. Yes. I don't think there is an obviously correct solution either way. I'm really only arguing that "trust the majority" is not something I trust. Not that "trust experts" is without its own (possibly equally fraught) set of problems.