3 ms·
Studies like this are structured from the outset to lead to trivial politically-motivated false dichotomies. It's like commissioning a study on whether reducing
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
Studies like this are structured from the outset to lead to trivial politically-motivated false dichotomies. It's like commissioning a study on whether reducing the number of cars would reduce the number of car accidents.
The interesting question, given that many people want cars and nobody wants car accidents, is what alternatives exist that allow you to have fewer car accidents without having fewer cars?
Because the implementation of those solutions change the original conclusion. If you have a lot of robbery homicides as a result of poverty, and keeping guns away from the perpetrators would keep them from committing as many homicides, but so would effective anti-poverty programs, one of these solutions is clearly better and obviates the need for the other.