10 ms·
AROS is a lightweight, efficient, and flexible desktop operating system
- mikece 6y agoWho is the target audience for this operating system? What use cases does it seek to address? EDIT: is this a current project? References to running in a VM on Mac OS 9 with Virtual PC seem awfully dated.
- teddyh 6y ago“aiming at being compatible with AmigaOS at the API level”
- unixhero 6y agoIt is upstream for other OS projects in the far alternative side of retro- and exotic- side of computing. Recent Github commits from this week, so I'd say it is active.
- vidarh 6y agoThe target audience is mostly a subset of former Amiga users, and the occasional person curious about retro-computing who is more focused on the software than hardware side. Yes, it's a current project - the mailing list is more active than it has been for a long time, though the number of developers active at any given time is probably in the single to low double digits (for a very generous definition of "active" - people sometimes pops up for a single patch and then disappears for years; this is a niche project). [I wrote most of the scrollback support for the console handler about a decade ago. Haven't done much with it for years.]
- vhodges 6y agoGiven the legal turmoil it's been adopted/forked for use on the Vampire series of Amiga accelerators/clones. See also: reactos (Windows2k) and haiku-os (BeOS)
- grahamlee 6y agoTo be clear, the legal turmoil in question is over the current ownership of the original Amiga brand and IP, not AROS itself. AROS is published under a license that is not OSI approved but is actually a fork of the MPL with the word "Netscape" changed.
- cmsj 6y agoI wondered if the parent comment was actually talking about the Vampire folks distributing an AmigaOS image with programs/games pre-loaded, without having the rights to do so?
- grahamlee 6y agoThe ApolloOS distribution of AROS that Apollo ship still has plenty of proprietary software on it. In the Discord they’ve discussed that the problem they had with CoffinOS/Amiga Coffin was the rights to Amiga OS.
- vhodges 6y agoAh, sorry for not being clearer. Yes this is what I was talking about.
- spijdar 6y agoOne big difference is AROS only aims for essentially source compatibility with Amiga, while both ReactOS and Haiku aim for binary compatibility[0]. I've only toyed around a little bit with AROS back when I was a teen, but my impression is it's something a bit different than just a clone of any Amiga OS. It's sort of Amiga-like, but does things differently, and targets very different hardware. Which I think is pretty cool :) [0] I believe Haiku intends to drop binary compat with BeOS at some point, maybe they already have? It's why Haiku still uses (used?) a version of GCC from 2003, for binary compat
- vidarh 6y agoI think the M68k version does aim for binary compatibility where practical, but outside of M68k it doesn't really make much sense as AmigaOS4 on PPC deviates quite significantly from older AmigaOS, and for the other architectures there of course isn't any AmigaOS software.
- xeromal 6y agoPeople who don't use HTTPS apparently. :P
- grahamlee 6y agoyou can build openssl on AROS: there is a port on Aminet of OpenSSL 1.1.1i that _will_ build (the maintainers only build for AmigaOS 3/m68k and AmigaOS 4/PPC but it'll work on MorphOS and AROS too), and of course aminet is available over HTTP which is how we avoid the bootstrap problem :). Aside: pretty much anything that will build on a BSD will build on an Amiga/AROS with ixemul.library, but some people think that's cheating.
- spijdar 6y agoI think it's a jab at how AROS's site doesn't offer HTTPS. Personally I don't understand why some people are so bothered by this, but I guess conversely it's really easy to add letsencrypt to about anything nowadays...
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoTwo obvious points where leaving it unencrypted is a problem: 1. downloads - which is mostly mitigated by not actually having software downloads on their own site, although of course now the links are subvertable, and 2. they have a paypal donation form on http://www.aros.org/download.php http://www.aros.org/download.php - I assume that clicking into that sends you to the real paypal page, so at least they're not sending credit card details in the clear, but again leaves them open to a nice little tweak to change where the money goes.
- fogihujy 6y agoThey cater to what's left of the old Amiga community. It is a re-implementation of AmigaOS 3.x, so it's probably not for everyone. :)
- justapassenger 6y agoIt’s a toy for developers who are building it. No real target audience, other than maybe some extreme Amiga geeks, who will launch it once every few months.
- squarefoot 6y agoTrue, but it has been ported to other platforms, including ARM, which makes it interesting as graphical OS for embedded systems. I mean control panels showing data, graphs etc. rather than desktop applications. To me it would make sense to experiment with AROS on small boards where a full fledged Linux GUI would require too much beer to be usable, or simply to get the most performance from the available CPU/RAM/storage.
- justapassenger 6y agoIt could be cool toy for cases like that, but you need to do a lot of work yourself to get it to behave like embedded system, build custom ui, etc, aka, toy for developers. It’s very dangerous to be used for real production. It’s AmigaOS at the core, which means that it’s fairly complex (compared to other embedded systems) and at the same time, comes with literally 0 security (shared address space for everyone for a start, before you go anywhere deeper with what’s wrong with security). While it may not be a biggest concern for non internet connected devices, it makes it inherently unstable system (there are embedded systems without memory protection, but they’re much simpler). Don’t get me wrong, I love playing with toys like that (was involved in a broader Amiga community for a long long time), but for modern times, it’s just a toy.
- McMini 6y agoFunfact; AROS is also the name of a Danish art museum http://aros.dk/ http://aros.dk/. AROS means River mouth in old Danish and is the old name of the second largest city in Denmark, Aarhus.
- stpe 6y agoSame with Swedish city Västerås with original name West Aros. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V%C3%A4ster%C3%A5s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V%C3%A4ster%C3%A5s
- atomize 6y agoWest Aros. Like... Westeros? Is that where they got that from for GoT?
- robin_reala 6y agoIt’s all a pastiche. Even the map is just Great Britain on top of Ireland: https://brilliantmaps.com/westeros/ https://brilliantmaps.com/westeros/
- harshitaneja 6y agoI am in awe of the museum's website. With so much of animations I expected it to be a terrible experience but it is implemented brilliantly and functions so smooth.
- y8y387r47r734 6y agoyou are so stuipid
- snarfy 6y agoI was hoping there was a rpi port. It seems this is x86 only.
- vidarh 6y agoDefinitively not x86 only. There are targets for ARM, x86, m68k, PPC. There is a target specifically for rpi, but I have no idea if it is currently functioning.
- mnw21cam 6y agoI presume you didn't get to have a look at http://www.aros.org/nightly1.php http://www.aros.org/nightly1.php which contains links for multiple versions include rpi.
- snarfy 6y agoOh, nice! thanks
- albertzeyer 6y agoFor a desktop operating system, I was hoping for some more (recent) screenshots. While this seems to be under active development, the last screenshot is from 2017. (Obviously, screenshots really don't tell too much...)
- Narishma 6y agohttps://vmwaros.blogspot.com/2020/12/icaros-desktop-23-now-available.html https://vmwaros.blogspot.com/2020/12/icaros-desktop-23-now-a...
- RamblingCTO 6y agoSeems a furry got to decide on the logo or whatever that is on the top right. No comments on that yet? I'm disappointed ...
- fctorial 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AROS_Research_Operating_System#Name_and_identity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AROS_Research_Operating_System...
- qvq 6y agohttps://en.wikifur.com/wiki/Eric_W._Schwartz https://en.wikifur.com/wiki/Eric_W._Schwartz
- RamblingCTO 6y agoSo I was right about the furry part it seems. Funny that just stating "seems a furry got to decide on whatever that on the right is" seems to be against the guidelines. I get that it can come across as being snarky, but I'm not a native speaker and lacked the word "mascot". Maybe I might miss something entirely different though. The rest is just stating facts. I stand by that and feel that it's super unprofessional to use a mascot like that. Thanks for the links, much appreciated!
- grahamlee 6y ago> it's super unprofessional I don't think anyone is getting paid though.
- fogihujy 6y agoThe artist has a long history within the Amiga community. It's a project specifically catering to said community so it's quite on point. They could have some kind of explanation about it on the site though...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Qahlel 6y agoWhy every new OS seems like a bad skin of MacOSX or Windows 95 UI? Please innovate...
- donatj 6y agoThere's no need to innovate on perfection. That's how you get the current mainstream operating systems that have minimalized to the point of uselessness and cleaned to the point what is a UI element and what is decoration.
- sidpatil 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. In my opinion, the mid-1990s to mid-2000s were the pinnacle of GUI design, specifically that of stacking window managers, in terms of usability.
- madhadron 6y agoIt's a reimplementation of the Amiga OS, which predates both of the systems you mention by many years.
- cable2600 6y agoMicrosoft and Apple copied AmigaOS GUI and OS/2 Warp GUI features. Even BeOS had a start menu of sorts.
- justapassenger 6y agoAROS is anything but new OS. It started in 1995.
- mrtweetyhack 6y agoIf you have ideas, please share. Otherwise. STFU
- medicineman 6y agoFurries? No thanks.
- yboris 6y agoBit off topic. Anyone remember LiteStep? An amazing easy way to customize and skin your Windows OS. http://litestep.net/ http://litestep.net/
- lostgame 6y agoHeck yes, I remember LiteStep. There was also the (commercial) WindowBlinds[1] by StarDock, and; for 10.3/10.4 OSX versions, ShapeShifter by Unsanity. I used to be obsessed with desktop customization... [1]https://www.stardock.com/products/windowblinds/ https://www.stardock.com/products/windowblinds/ [2]https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/unsanity-shapeshifter https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/unsanity-shapeshifter
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krylon 6y agoBefore I got into Linux, I spent about half a year customizing the crap out of my Win98 PC using LiteStep. I must have tried about half a dozen alternative desktop shells for Windows back then. Fun times... Thanks for reminding me!
- Enderboi 6y agoI wrote a popular shortcuts plugin for Litestep (EasyCuts) and eventually ended up on the core team for while. Working on Litestep taught me so much about Windows internals - and I know a few people ended up being poached by Microsoft to work on the Windows shell proper due to their work on LS :)
- kristopolous 6y agoI met Mr. Aros himself at scale in LA a couple years ago. Every now and then I meet people who do pretty remarkable things that are so humble that it genuinely surprises me. Aros, VLC and Inkscape devs are the people that come to mind on this one. The debian people are also remarkably sane and modest for the levels of responsibility and complexities they have to deal with Edit: gosh, it was 10 years ago already (https://www.socallinuxexpo.org/scale9x/exhibitors/aros.html https://www.socallinuxexpo.org/scale9x/exhibitors/aros.html). I think I still have the disc he gave me
- tubbyjr 6y agoHave you had the pleasure of meeting Terry A. Davis?
- scruffyherder 6y agoYeah. It wasn’t pleasant.
- kristopolous 6y agoYes, I wrote an article about it over 10 years ago. It made the front page of a number of social media sites like reddit. Then, nearly simultaneously they were all removed. I didn't even post the article. It spilled there from I think a Google plus post. My candor was apparently off. I'm certainly not a psychologist. I meant no harm but clearly I did something wrong. There's probably tripwires to his condition I simply don't know. I might have crossed them. I never got an explanation but it's fine. Lesson learned: people with any kind of disease/disability should be added to things to stay away from writing about without the proper co-authors. Sorry about that, internet. I voluntarily pulled it shortly after. I'm not going to hurt someone for imaginary internet points. The interesting thing though was the implied coordination between the platforms. It may have been a coincidence, may have been real, I wouldn't be surprised if somebody with administrative power from all the major ones are on some chat server together. There's certainly a spillover effects between them. Honestly I haven't tried that kind of journalism in a while. Apparently I'm pretty good at, well at least the "making stuff popular" part.
- alvarlagerlof 6y agoWhy does all of these have such tiny and low-res screenshots?
- plun9 6y agoOld, but: http://nixon-development.com/guis/aros.html http://nixon-development.com/guis/aros.html
- smm11 6y agoJust buy my real Amiga and get it over with.
- orionblastar 6y agoReal Amigas aren't made anymore since Commodore went out of business. The Amiga One is a PowerPC version but too expensive. It is cheaper to buy a $50 used PC with AROS on it. There are some hardware replacement projects to fix existing Amiga computers but it is still easier to go thr AROS PC route.
- Animats 6y agoAnother Amiga OS clone is a cute retro project, but this is not forward motion. Nobody seems to want to clone QNX, which is a better architecture. QNX was a great technology lost to bad marketing. Blackberry has it now, and it's used industrially and in automotive systems. But Blackberry dropped the desktop version and the hobbyist version, and you have to cross compile from Windows now. It was open source for a while, and was suddenly made closed source when Blackberry bought it. Sadly, no one seems to have saved the open source version. I wish I had. I didn't have enough disk at the time.
- bkinman 6y agoFunny that you mention this. You are actually the reason I know QNX. I spent a decent amount of time some years ago pouring over code code you wrote for the Overbot. Thanks for donating that to UCSC :)
- tombert 6y agoOut of curiosity, what makes QNX a better architecture than AmigaOS? I had a Blackberry Playbook back in the day but that's the extent of my exposure to it.
- 6y ago
- cable2600 6y agoDon't forget about Commodore OS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_OS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_OS Linux based OS with Commodore Amiga UI look and feel. Also Anubis OS: https://www.osnews.com/story/20516/former-aros-developers-start-new-os-project-much-secrecy/ https://www.osnews.com/story/20516/former-aros-developers-st... Still under development but one day they will be ready and Linux based and AmigaOS emulators built in.
- betwixthewires 6y agoYou know what I'd really like to see? A desktop focused BSD distro that is easy to use as Ubuntu was in it's hayday (and arguably still is). Now that we see most hardware manufacturers allow for or even maintain open source drivers for Linux users I do not see why this is not a thing. I'm an avid Linux user that has wanted to get into BSD and other Unix like operating systems but just can never muster the energy and time and patience to build a BSD system from scratch. IMO the potential from BSD is greater than Linux but the effort to create easy to install and use BSD desktop systems is just not there.
- codewiz 6y agoNetBSD/amiga 1.0 was my first unix. It was much harder to install, update and admin than most contemporary OSes, but, wow, it was multi-user and open-source before the term open-source had been popularized. Years later, when I switched to Linux, I was surprised by how much more usable it was. Early Linux distributions put effort into enabling color ls, virtual consoles and readline. Then came package installers, etc. The BSDs lagged behind Linux in usability because they kept focusing on other aspects of operating system design, dismissing things like graphical installers as unnecessary frill. "man tar" was the canonical advice. New users getting stuck in the middle of the installation procedure were being welcomed by the BSD community with internal jokes like "RTFM!" and "man man". Development mailing-lists were also filled with comments ridiculing Linux as bloated (due to having bash with readline as /bin/sh) and not a real UNIX (due to not being a direct descendant of the AT&T sources). Not to mention all the attacks on the GPL and GNU as not being sufficiently free. It was a cult, essentially. Hopefully the BSD community has grown up since then, but it has already lost most of the mind share to Linux and macOS, which is arguably the only usable BSD desktop available to users who couldn't figure what to do with the "man man" advice.
- 0dayz 6y agoSadly it hasn't, it's still stuck in 2005 era flame war cult-like attitude.
- lmm 6y agoPC-BSD and to a lesser extent DragonFlyBSD do that. But there's just not enough people willing to put the work in (and in fairness why should they?). FWIW I found installing FreeBSD pretty straightforward as soon as they started supporting normal disk partitions. It's closer to Slackware than Ubuntu, but that's also the appeal of FreeBSD - it doesn't have a whole lot to offer someone who wants something automagic like Ubuntu IMO.