6 ms·
Cloud-Making Aerosol Could Devastate Polar Sea Ice
- bb101 6y ago> “The more the ice melts, the more sea surface is exposed, the more iodine is emitted, the more particles are made, the more clouds form, the faster it all goes,” Kirkby said. A positive feedback loop. Not good. Reminds me of a passage from Daniel Quinn's "Ishmael". A man jumps off a cliff in a winged contraption. As he plummets to the ground, he truly believes for a short period that he is flying. If our biosphere is more fragile than once thought, I wonder if our current period will be humanity's short flight?
- singularity2001 6y agoso as long as clouds are above snow/ice they have a net warming effect and if they are above open ocean they have a net cooling effect?
- gibspaulding 6y agoI only skimmed the article, but it had me wondering about the same. There's been talk before about trying to form artificial clouds over the ocean in order to reduce warming. I'd be very curious to hear how this might relate to that. Is it possible that man made clouds could drift to the poles and make everything worse?
- shagie 6y agoThey can be relatively localized. Consider contrails, which with the grounding of air travel in the US after 9/11 had climate impacts that could be studied. https://globalnews.ca/news/2934513/empty-skies-after-911-set-the-stage-for-an-unlikely-climate-change-experiment/ https://globalnews.ca/news/2934513/empty-skies-after-911-set... http://www.bbc.co.uk/sn/tvradio/programmes/horizon/dimming_trans.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/sn/tvradio/programmes/horizon/dimming_t... One of the interesting aspects of that is that it returned to normal (well, contrails being normal) rapidly.
- m12k 6y agoIt would make sense that it depends whether the clouds have a higher or lower albedo than the surface they cover
- CWuestefeld 6y agoThat's what TFA says. I imagine that the latitude matters, too. Near the poles, the sun is coming in at such an oblique angle that any given surface area isn't getting much heating effect from it anyway, so it's easier for the insulating blanket effect to be a net positive.
- sep_field 6y agoIn Germany, they imprison holocaust deniers. Its time we start imprisoning climate change deniers.
- adrianN 6y agoClimate change deniers are not the problem. The problem are people who admit that climate change exists and is a serious problem but then do nothing substantial about it. Very few of our politicians are climate change deniers, but all of them fail to implement appropriate measures to reduce CO2 emissions quickly enough.
- sep_field 6y agoThey should be imprisoned as well. The Earth does not belong to us, rather we belong to the Earth. The Earth is more important than we are, we should put the Earth's needs ahead of our own needs. We must stand up for the rights of the Earth, or else human rights will be impossible to maintain. Anyone sacrificing the Earth for profit is committing genocide as well as ecocide.
- adrianN 6y agoFor that you need support from a large majority of the general populace, who unfortunately are just fine with the status quo (or the politicians would need to act differently to get reelected).
- sep_field 6y agoThe majority of the world's populace is scared of climate change. There's more than enough of us to eliminate the rich if we work together. Countries are an outmoded and unsustainable concept that only serve to artificially empower the rich. Global Ecosocialism is the only way to avert climate catastrophe. The way to eliminate the rich is for us to band together and strip them of their assets, then they will no longer be rich.
- grapecookie 6y agoAfter this covid fiasco, im done with models. You guys have fun supporting the climate austerity that is to come, I'm going to just believe that the earth has it's own regulation magic that we have not uncovered yet.
- mellavora 6y agoI share your pain in society's mishandling of covid, and understand your skepticism towards poorly applied models. Society is much more complex than most models can address. The issue with the faith in the earth's own regulation magic is that it also assumes that the regulation magic is friendly to us, and/or that the goal of the regulation is to maintain a steady state which is good for humanity, or that it is even to maintain a steady state (maybe it's idea of 'regulation' is maintaining a chaotic cycle). I used to joke that climate change was really the dinosaurs trying to come back; we are pumping FOSSIL fuels into the air with an end result of recreating a climate more similar to the warmer days when the dinosaurs roamed. by issue, I mean "problems even if we assume that the earth's regulatory/homeostatic mechanisms are properly functioning." That assumption is also problematic, if one allows for the possibility that our technological powers and population size mean we are pushing on the system faster than its regulatory mechanisms can compensate. Our bodies have highly tuned regulatory mechanisms to control body temp, which work amazingly well as long as ambient temps stay within a certain range. Outside that range, not so well.
- hshshs2 6y agoThe earth does self regulate, the problem is that it doesn’t care if we die along the way stopping climate change is ultimately about keeping the world habitable for humans, which is why it’s absurd we’re not doing much about it... worst case scenario is that we make the earth a nicer place to live
- rsynnott 6y ago> I'm going to just believe that the earth has it's own regulation magic that we have not uncovered yet. Well, it, er, does, but it isn't very good (see ice ages), and operates on timescales that would be inconvenient to us. If humanity died out tomorrow, then CO2 levels would likely get back to normal eventually, but it's not really a _great_ solution, is it? We can hopefully do better.
- CWuestefeld 6y agoMeta - I only recently discovered Quanta Magazine, and I'm very much enjoying it. Many years ago I abandoned Scientific American when it became overtly politicized. I don't necessarily disagree with the values they demonstrated, but part of the reason I enjoy reading science publications is for the opportunity to get away from political polarization for a while, and their editorial change took that enjoyment away from me. So I left SA, and found American Scientist magazine, which up until the last issue or two had maintained a separation from politics. However, they've now become explicitly political, as demonstrated in conversation here on HN about a recent article [1]. Not only have they dragged in the woke politics, but if this issue, and this article especially, are any indication, they've also drastically affected the quality of the science reporting. In disgust from AS's capitulation, I looked around for other sources of science journalism that could deliver something a couple notches more in-depth than, say, Discover or Pop Mech, but still stay aloof from politics. So far Quanta Magazine is the only thing I've found, but they are pretty good. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25799514 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25799514
- weberer 6y agoI've noticed that too about Scientific American. Its like circa 2015 a switch flipped and they became a completely different magazine. Anyway I found it much more informative to just go straight to the source in most cases and subscribing to peer-reviewed scientific journals. For example, can select any subject in Nature and get a RSS feed https://www.nature.com/subjects https://www.nature.com/subjects There are various open access journals in PLoS https://plos.org/#journals https://plos.org/#journals https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/find-and-read-articles#loc-new-articles-by-rss https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/find-and-read-articles#l... As well as many others listed in the Database of Open Access Journals https://doaj.org/ https://doaj.org/
- quickthrower2 6y agoThe style of this article reminds me of New Scientist. You might like that publication.
- mannykannot 6y agoAs arctic ice has decreased over the last couple of decades, I wonder if there is now noticably more cloud coverage over the arctic, and/or whether, over that period, the coverage has diverged upwardly from what current models would predict for the period.