4 ms·
What this usually means is that the functions still exist but are named differently. Unfortunately the article does not go into any details beyond that attentio
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
What this usually means is that the functions still exist but are named differently. Unfortunately the article does not go into any details beyond that attention-grabbing headline, but it does not sound very appealing:
> "But what if there is a case of bullying to be resolved, or a contract dispute that requires specialist knowledge?
Jackson says he expects his managers to take personal responsibility for these things (with appropriate training) rather than "shelving responsibility to a third party" - just as he used to do when managing his teams."
Is he seriously claiming that he expects individual managers to deal with employment law disputes themselves? If so it only means that they have not had an employment law dispute yet...
- chmod775 6y agoEdit: I wrote a lot of text for little reason and started rambling, here's the gist instead: If you insert HR in the main company hierarchy, you now have managers who do HR stuff. Even if you don't call it HR, you still have HR.
- watt 6y agobut if you have HR which you call HR, then you might have something else, undesirable, too. I thought this is all understood and does not need spelling out?
- ojnabieoot 6y agoIncidentally: tech managers who have (nontrivial) HR duties are exactly as reliable, competent, and qualified as HR managers with programming and DBA responsibilities. But the latter is self-evidently ridiculous, whereas the former happens all the time...
- leesalminen 6y agoIDK, I’ve never seen HR add value to a company. They’re always a cost center and should be minimized as much as possible in order to hire more engineers.
- jasonlotito 6y ago> IDK, I’ve never seen HR add value to a company. That's a shame. I have. And absolutely love them, and wouldn't trade them for more engineers.
- ameister14 6y agoHR is often poorly implemented, I think. They could useful from an operational standpoint to make sure your resources are being allocated effectively if they focused on process improvements for the company that nobody else has time to test and implement. For example, HR should be keeping track of performance and worker satisfaction working from home; they should have data about performance and satisfaction in the office and compare it, be up to date on hiring and salary trends and have an opinion on what is necessary and appropriate in terms of perks and salary to hire competitively. This is all useful. There is also a perception issue, as in my experience it feels like they are usually just there to print off some information about health insurance for you and run useless exercises.
- lupire 6y agoAs CEO, why didn't you shut down HR?
- throwaway210222 6y agoNo mandate from the board. CEOs shouldn't be kings.
- ojnabieoot 6y agoHmm, I looked into your history as a founder a bit. This is your company? https://www.gingrapp.com/about-us https://www.gingrapp.com/about-us I am not sure if you still work there, but... it appears that out of 23 employees, there is maybe one who is not white. I understand that pet management software in Colorado is, sociologically, a bit of an “alabaster” field and that it’s almost impossible to get ‘parity’ with even state-wide demographics. But in my experience, a company with > 20 employees that’s basically all-white is one that made a deliberately exclusionary choice and does not care at all about diversity. It is the kind of thing a competent HR professional can help with if you do care! But when you say you’ve “never seen HR add value to a company” it occurs to me that you and I have very different conceptions of “value.”
- EveYoung 6y agoBesides the obvious legal risks of this hands-off approach, I cannot imagine that this is efficient in any way. Do you really want your managers to deal with things such as pre-screenings and visa appplications themselves? Or are they simply outsourcing these tasks to agencies.
- tpmx 6y ago> pre-screenings Yes. Otherwise you tend to get keyword-based filtering or random filtering based on perceived "cultural fit". > visa appplications That is easy to outsource and get good results.
- EveYoung 6y agoThey can still filter candidates based on things such as availability, salary expectations, or target universities/companies. And call them if some crucial information is missing.
- leesalminen 6y agoThat sounds like something software can automate away entirely.
- zimpenfish 6y ago> Otherwise you tend to get keyword-based filtering or random filtering based on perceived "cultural fit". You get that with non-HR managers though; it's not HR-exclusive.
- watwut 6y ago> Do you really want your managers to deal with things such as pre-screenings Yes. HR without software development background simply don't have knowledge to do this effectively.
- msandford 6y agoIt may well be that they'll have said dispute and will then be forced to bring in an HR department to do that work. But they'll have gotten to where they are now a billion dollar company at all which is a real feat. Or they might look at hiring a 10-20 person HR department and say "3 million a year vs a (theoretically) one-time 3 million judgment? We'll keep taking our chances" It could be a great place to work or an awful place to work. It probably depends a lot on who you are and which manager you end up reporting to.