2 ms·
1. Diesel-electric engines are not regenerative. 2. If you can't get it up, you won't be going down. A 110 car unit coal train grosses 143 tons per car for a
by dredmorbius 6y ago
1. Diesel-electric engines are not regenerative.
2. If you can't get it up, you won't be going down.
A 110 car unit coal train grosses 143 tons per car for a 15,750 ton gross trainset weight, excluding locos. Metric is nearly the same, I'll round to 15,000 tonne.
Lifting that 1,000 metres (3,300 feet) requires about 150 gigajoules of energy, or the energy equivalent of over 3.5 tonnes of oil. You're not going to recover that fuel going downhill.
(Rough numbers for an approximate answer, but it's a lot of energy.)
The highest elevation mainline crossing in the US was on the Union Pacific Railroad, Tennessee Pass (10,240 feet, 3,121 m), built in 1882 and retired in 1997. Today it's the San Luis & Rio Grande Railroad, La Veta Pass (9,242 feet, 2,816 metres).
https://www.railserve.com/stats_records/highest_steepest_railroads.html https://www.railserve.com/stats_records/highest_steepest_rai...
- sudosysgen 6y agoDiesel electric locomotives don't use regeneration because it doesn't make much sense, not because it's not feasible. Locomotives that have regenerative braking actually do exist. 3.5 tons of fuel for 15 000 tons is 230g of fuel per ton, or around a tenth of a gallon per ton. So even on the highest climb, assuming none of the energy is used on the downhill, that's 3 tenths of a gallon per fuel per ton for the climb. For context, a car's engine could move the average car 5.4 miles on flat ground with the energy required for a locomotive to lift the same car up 3km. As you can see, it's really not that much energy. Which is why regenerative braking isn't used.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoNeed to have somewhere to put that regenerated energy. Either overhead wire/third rail, or some sort of 'tender' with storage like the old steamers had for coal and some water.
- sudosysgen 6y agoCertainly, in general it's done via overhead wire or third rail and feeds energy back into the grid. It's not worth it in general when those aren't already present.