3 ms·
It absolutely does not do any such thing. Speech can be well-regulated, just like other constitutional rights. Your right to speak does not mandate a megaphone.
by Spooky23 6y ago
It absolutely does not do any such thing. Speech can be well-regulated, just like other constitutional rights. Your right to speak does not mandate a megaphone.
What I described was the law from the 1930s until the 1980s. Our predecessors saw what happened in fascist and communist states and wisely took measures to avoid that.
- tiahura 6y agoI'd like a cite for Speech can be well-regulated. First Ammendment caselaw is a little muddled, however, content regulation falls between strict scrutiny and per se invalid depending on which way the wind is blowing. See eg. Simon & Shuster v. NY (invalidating Son of Sam law). See also, RAV (invalidating hate speech law).
- dnissley 6y agoWhat measures?
- sokoloff 6y agoI think there's a legitimate difference whether the Fairness Doctrine was imposed as a condition of licensing the use of a limited, public resource (frequency spectrum allocation) or as an attempt to regulate freedom of the speech or press. Because of the way it was implemented, I believe it was a condition of the use of public spectrum, not a regulation on speech broadly.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> Speech can be well-regulated, just like other constitutional rights Broadly, the opinion of SCOTUS has been that speech cannot be regulated outside of very particular circumstances, and those circumstances have, in general, been shrinking over time (from undefined to "clear and present danger" to "imminent lawless action" to clarify that "imminent lawless action" really means right now, and not just relatively soon) The Fairness Doctrine isn't a regulation on speech, it's a regulation on use of government licensed airwaves.
- sneak 6y agoFYI: the "well-regulated" of 2A refers to a concept more along the lines of "well oiled" than what we term "government regulation" today.