4 ms·
I'd argue that computing has never been more accessible than it is today. A Raspberry Pi costs less than an HDMI dongle for an iPad these days and there is mor
by lxgr 6y ago
I'd argue that computing has never been more accessible than it is today.
A Raspberry Pi costs less than an HDMI dongle for an iPad these days and there is more free educational material available on the web than ever before.
When I went to high school and started becoming interested in programming, I was using Windows XP on my general-purpose PC back home, as were all my classmates – yet only two out of more than 20 ended up going into tech.
I think articles like this commonly make the mistake of romanticizing the author's personal way of getting into tech and thinking it's the only way possible for others as well.
- PaulKeeble 6y agoEven the Raspberry pi has a few areas of concern with propriety firmware and closed codecs. It is not a completely open hardware platform, it does run code that no eyes can see.
- oytis 6y agoGo Beaglebone then. The SBC market is enormous these days.
- abewfbaew 6y agoBeaglebone is even worse, with a PowerVR GPU and blobs to make the PRUs work correctly. It's pretty difficult to find a device with completely open drivers, let alone open firmwares and memory initialization.
- new_realist 6y agoThat's because completely open drivers have no value even to tech. enthusiasts. If they did, vendors would offer them.
- wishysgb 6y agoI do believe system76 laptops are almost completely open source other than the intel microcode.
- oytis 6y agoYes you're right finding open source GPU drivers is hard. Rock Pi 4 with panfrost?
- ip26 6y agoI don't entirely get the notion that computing has to be 100% open for anybody to learn anything. My pulling-back-the-curtain moment was booting Linux on an Xbox & hand building a VGA adapter. Had never touched Linux or a soldering iron before that. Was it easy, no, but that's literally what made it so engaging & educational.
- rektide 6y agoyes but: the % of computing that people do that can be engaged in, explored, enhanced, modified continues to drop. most computing happens in far far away data centers, happens in invisible far off processes that society can not see or understand or learn about or tinker with. most computing done is now special purpose, and its purpose is alien & it's presence is saturating, utterly surrounding us. that we have some freedom for low cost on our tiny little free computing reservation does little. there is a full on society, a massive world of computing about, that we get to know nothing of, but if we want to set ourselves free & try things & explore we must utterly renounce the world about us & head off, like the elves of middle earth, cross the seas & leave the world behind. society is becoming ever more blind to what computing is. thank you cheap single-board-compyters for providing some homesteading experience. but the megalopolises of computing being all effectively alien artifice, impervious to science, too far away to learn about, secured against us: this is a real & genuine horror, something no technical advance has ever corrupted society with before. we have always been free to observe & learn but now we are denied at the firewall. knowledge burns.
- lxgr 6y ago> yes but: the % of computing that people do that can be engaged in, explored, enhanced, modified continues to drop. Yes, the number of closed systems is growing, but so is the number of open ones. So many commercial projects these days are based on open source software or even open hardware. I'd argue that the total set of complex systems to take apart, study and admire has never been larger than today.
- rektide 6y ago> So many commercial projects these days are based on open source software or even open hardware. In the 90's & aughts, Linux & open source was obsessed with "free desktop", with becoming a world-class environment for computing. But today my feeling is that 90%+ of open source development exists to help & equip corporations with better ways of making products & services. The only users the software is concerned with are other developers, businesses, most of whom will leech value & grow without contributing anything at all. But none the less, a couple folks persist, try to bring honor to the world, by being really good at something, by- for whatever usually very foibled reason- caring. > I'd argue that the total set of complex systems to take apart, study and admire has never been larger than today. It is cool that folk can go check out android, get in the source, kick the tires. It's colossal, a beast, but it's still cool. Having access to both an SDK & the means to go look beyond is compelling. Alas I still feel like the software world about us, the software we use, is radically out of reach. We spend enormous time on social networks, chatting, writing, sending media. None of these systems are at all observable, learnable, explorable. It matters that the digital matter about us is invisible, far off, unseeable. Except as the shadow of puppets, projected against a wall, opposite to where we are chained. It matters that society cannot see the mechanisms about us. How the "natural sciences" are supposed to carry on now that we've obstructed ourselves from our reality all about us is a mystery to me; we have only a legacy of engagement, a history of man the tool maker. Now we are man, the tool-made. Software has become the firm prison.
- mac01021 6y agoIn terms of hardware costs that is probably true. In terms of the ability to develop a technical understanding of computers and to use computers as a medium for certain types of creative expression, much ground has been lost over the last 25 years. Mr. Torvalds may never have got Linux off the ground if the state of the world had been such that, as today, a desktop operating system that didn't support WebKit were not useful to anyone. Even if you don't care about connecting to the internet and rendering modern DOMs, try building a desktop operating system from scratch for the raspberry pi and as soon as you want to interface with a keyboard you'll run into the fact that you have to do it through USB, the protocol for which will cost you months of your life to understand and implement. This is not to say the USB and the modern web are unequivocally bad things, but they were designed/evolved without any consideration of certain kinds of concerns (both pedagogical and engineering concerns) and the benefits that they provide could probably have been had without imposing these particular costs on the inhabitants of the modern computing ecosystem. Now, admittedly, most people (and even most people learning about computing) won't want want to build an operating system from scratch. But that's not the point. The problem is that (my personal, and yours, and society's at large) innovation is stifled by the contingency of a project's survival or success on its ability to provide feature parity and backward compatibility with incumbent juggernauts. No serious compiler author is going to use your code generation framework unless it does everything that LLVM does. Nobody is going to join your social network unless their posts will reach everyone that their posts reach on twitter. Is it a mistake to romanticize the idea that a person with less than a billion dollars could totally rethink a particular facet of computing and then execute on that vision and not have to give up, in the process, ostracize themselves from the rest of the computing ecosystem? 10-20 years from now, maybe 90% of everyone's interaction with computers will be via speech recognition and AR glasses, using devices and software infrastructure provided by Google, Apple, and Microsoft. These systems may be provided in a very closed way where the usefulness of the devices is dependent on connectivity to the proprietary cloud infrastructure of the megacorps and through which everything you say and everything you see is recorded. Maybe you'll have an idea for a similarly-useful personal computing system that works offline and doesn't invade the user's privacy. Or maybe their invasion of privacy won't be so egregious but you'll have some ideas about how to improve the UX in some way that's outside the range of your Apple device's configurability. In either case, the sophistication/complexity of both the hardware and the software involved will be such that you'll need a TON of capital in order to make a competing product. There are basically two ways you'll be able to get that capital 1. Crowdfunding and voluntary, gratis, open-sourcy contributions. This requires wide interest in what you're doing from the public at large (and waning public interest in privacy is one of the things that the OP is concerned about). 2. Venture Capital, which means you need a plan to generate return on the investment, which means you either need to plan to sell your system at a high retail price, in which case it won't win any market share from the cheaper established systems from the existing megacorps, or else you need a plan to monetize the data of your users by sucking it all up into your own proprietary cloud. I don't have enough time remaining in my day to make this rant shorter or more coherent, and I've spent too much time writing it to just leave it unposted. So I'm now going to post it in its current state.