4 ms·
It seems to work well. I am an occasional contributor so I don't have very much power there but I understand that communities collapse without this control sinc
by renewiltord 6y ago
It seems to work well. I am an occasional contributor so I don't have very much power there but I understand that communities collapse without this control since they get dominated by drive-by losers. I'm not one, but there's no signal I can provide that I'm not one. Metafilter has the model where you spend money as a signal that you're not one. I guess I'd pay $20 one-time as an upgrade that is revocable.
I am a Wikipedia auto-confirmed user, so that lets me make articles without needing to go through the process, so that's nice.
The problem with all of these sites is that they don't also police the opposite side: the obsessive guy who spends all his time on the site and attaches all of his identity to it so he is just a negative person despite having lots of 'karma'-equivalent.
It's like the value-to-community vs time-spent curve is like
| -
| - -
| - -
| - -
| -- -
| -- -
|---- ---
+----------------------
| -
| -
|
In fact, maybe HN should have a high-karma warning. "This user spends so much time on HN they can't possibly be productive in real life. You are getting the town drunk, not the star of the pub"
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> maybe HN should have a high-karma warning My intuition is that this is less of an issue on HN than on Wikipedia.
- hinkley 6y agoI need to hire you to talk to a community member I'm having trouble communicating with. Good stuff.
- cosmodisk 6y agoThis would have been a killer feature on dating sites around the time I was using them: some people were spending more time on those than there were hours in a day:)
- potta_coffee 6y agoAt one point in time, I was contributing at Stack Overflow just for the fun of it, and I answered some fun programming questions. After a short time I ran afoul of some of the obsessive types that you describe, and that was the end of my time at SO.
- DoreenMichele 6y ago"This user spends so much time on HN they can't possibly be productive in real life. You are getting the town drunk, not the star of the pub" I'm medically handicapped and "have no life" which is why I spend so much time online. When I first joined HN (July 2009), I figured everyone on the leader board here was basically some loser with no life. Not a big slam because I figured they were fairly intelligent losers. But I did figure "You people are spending so much time here for the same reason I am: You desperately need to get a life. (Only you seem to have less excuse than I have for your failure to get a life.)" That proved to not be an accurate assessment of the situation. Your point is not irrelevant, but I will suggest that karma count on HN is not a good measure of anything at all other than time spent actively posting on HN -- which, in some cases, is cumulative over many years and in some cases it is not. Some people here certainly are "the town drunk." And some people with high karma are people who have been here a long time and contributed a lot of good stuff while setting their ego aside and so on.