3 ms·
The New York Times is a corporation with a government-granted charter that grants it things like limited liability. It's fallacious to characterize it as just s
by mindslight 6y ago
The New York Times is a corporation with a government-granted charter that grants it things like limited liability. It's fallacious to characterize it as just some ad-hoc "group" of individuals joining together to individually exercise their rights.
And yes, I agree that we don't actually have a free press. Given our microkernel government, institutions like the New York Times are better seen as part of the de facto government than independent organizations speaking truth to power - eg marketing the Iraq war. This relationship is easier to see with say Equifax than NYT, but the dynamic is similar.
- sneak 6y agoImportant to remember that corporations, like all groups, have no mouths, no hands, and cannot act. All corporate actions, all corporate speech, is carried out by individual humans. Group rights are individual human rights, as groups have no brain and cannot act.
- mindslight 6y agoExcept that there is a distinction between an individual performing an action of their own volition, and an individual performing an action to obtain income. The first represents the true will of the individual, while the latter only requires their desire to have a roof over their head. And as I said, the entity of the NYT is afforded protections that individuals are not. If individual rights are supremely important to the individuals making up the NYT, the individuals involved are still free to act outside of their corporate shell.
- bhupy 6y agoNew York Times employees are employed at-will. We're not talking about minimum wage workers publishing content under duress here, we're talking about journalists and editors who generally join organizations they believe in. Tucker Carlson doesn't go on air and say the things he says because he's forced to, he does it because he wants to. Full disclosure: my wife works for the New York Times.
- mindslight 6y agoSo your wife never complains that work is pushing her to do something that she does not want to do, and she's bargaining with management to try to do the right thing? And the transaction costs to her quitting and finding a new job are zero? IMO "at will" is only 99% correct, and the integral of its remainder builds up into some gross misbehavior.
- bhupy 6y agoMy wife has never been forced to publish anything against her will. That being said, she has disagreed with the editorial decisions of the paper on a number of occasions. This is not at odds with the freedom of association; every single organization is comprised of individuals that don't always agree with one another, but work together to overcome their disagreements. Nowhere has there ever been a guarantee that the freedom of association presupposes that every individual has the freedom to confer the exact same set of opinions to everyone in their association. Importantly, my wife doesn't feel like she's entitled to the power to censure other journalists or employees in her company. I know that I don't have the power to do that in my own company, nor should I. There's disagreement within every group, that doesn't render the concept of free association invalid. The Catholic Church has its disagreements, but that doesn't mean that they lose the freedom to congregate because they're somehow no longer a bona fide association on account of that internal disagreement. The Democratic Party has its disagreements (heaven knows), the Republican Party is essentially at war with itself, the Libertarian Party can never agree on what it stands for because it's a motley crew of weirdos. None of this matters, they are all protected by the First Amendment, as associations. Whether they are traded on the NYSE, or they are 501(c)4 non-profit corporations, or they are just an amateur club, they are protected by the same First Amendment, and are subject to the same narrow limits on speech established by Brandenburg v Ohio (and all other relevant precedents). Obviously the transaction cost to quitting and finding a new job is not zero; the Constitution's protection of the freedom of association has no guarantees on what the transaction cost to associate are. Just like free speech, you're free to say whatever you want, but you're not entitled to a free platform; promulgating speech costs money. You're free to keep and bear arms, but you're not entitled to a free rifle; guns cost money. Associations are more than capable of gross misbehavior; but in manners related specifically to the publishing of speech and expression, they enjoy outsized protection, at least in the United States.
- bhupy 6y ago> It's fallacious to characterize it as just some ad-hoc "group" of individuals joining together to individually exercise their rights. Nobody is arguing that the New York Times is some ad-hoc group of individuals; it certainly has its structure. The argument is that the same principles that afford an ad-hoc group of individuals the freedom of association (and expression) is what also affords a structured corporation like the New York Times the same protections. This isn't conjecture, it's the philosophy behind the landmark decisions of New York Times Co vs Sullivan, as well as Citizens United vs FEC (Citizens United was a 501(c)4 non-profit corporation). At the end of the day, the New York Times doesn't have a mind of its own; the articles it publishes and advertisements it chooses to sell are the output of the individuals that work there, including the journalists and the editors. If you and I want to join together and start a corporation for the purpose of advancing an issue, the First Amendment prohibits the government from enacting any law that may abridge that. > And yes, I agree that we don't actually have a free press. The Supreme Court has an established track record of aggressively protecting the rights of the organized press (NYT v Sullivan, Hustler Magazine v Falwell), group-speech (Citizens United), hate speech (Brandenburg) and even violent speech (Hess v Indiana). If that doesn't register as "press freedom", then I may as well lobby for legislation outlawing comments like yours on account of being misinformation.
- mindslight 6y ago> At the end of the day, the New York Times doesn't have a mind of its own; the articles it publishes are the output of the individuals that work there, including the journalists and the editors. The Chinese room argument says otherwise, and it behooves us as homo sapiens to pay attention. How many individual reporters at the NYT wanted to give support the Iraq war? And yet that's what the entity itself ended up doing, using their contributions. > Supreme Court has an established track record of aggressively protecting the rights of the organized press You totally ignored my argument. The point is that most of what constitutes de facto government in the US is actually outside of what we call "the government", and resides in corporations. Hence pointing to Equifax, which explicitly promulgates constraints on our individual behavior, and yet has escaped all sort of democratic accountability.
- 6y ago