6 ms·
Irresponsible by what measure? Genetics and family wealth still have a huge influence on "future impact," and that's what these schools are selecting for. It so
by pc86 6y ago
Irresponsible by what measure? Genetics and family wealth still have a huge influence on "future impact," and that's what these schools are selecting for. It sounds like legacy admissions are doing exactly what they're intended to do.
- solosoyokaze 6y ago> Genetics and family wealth still have a huge influence on "future impact," In what way would genetics have a huge influence on future impact? That sounds like eugenics.
- tharne 6y agoHow is it "like eugenics" to state that children inherit genes from their parents, and are often similar in many ways to their parents? That just sounds like biology. It's not helpful to trivialize terms like "eugenics".
- solosoyokaze 6y agoGenetics have no predictive power on future impact to society. Take one of those wealthy children and put them in an orphanage, see if they do the same as their siblings.
- tubesebut 6y ago> Take one of those wealthy children and put them in an orphanage, see if they do the same as their siblings. Or better yet, don't permit them to be born in the first place. Hereditary wealth should have no place in our society. It's time to sterilize the rich, and also purge those who don't contribute to the public good.
- ska 6y ago> Genetics and family wealth I suspect by "genetics" here you really mean something like "network you are born into", no?
- tharne 6y agoI'm pretty sure they mean that if two parents are of above average intelligence then they're more likely to produce children of above average intelligence.
- sanderjd 6y agoIrresponsible to society is what people are saying. You're making an "is" argument - the ivies optimizing for this "future impact" metric - where others are making an "ought" argument, that ivies ought to be focused on a different more societally beneficial metric.
- muh_gradle 6y agoBecause it's a terrible measure that is short sighted? It goes against everything affirmative action stands for? If we're going to pretend like diversity matters, then why try to justify legacy.