3 ms·
Interesting article, and I always find the history of early computer games fascinating (also see: Halcyon Days, freely available online: https://dadgum.com/halc
by the_af 6y ago
Interesting article, and I always find the history of early computer games fascinating (also see: Halcyon Days, freely available online: https://dadgum.com/halcyon/ https://dadgum.com/halcyon/)
However, what strikes me the most of this article is actually in the comments section...
... people don't know who Roberta Williams is, or what Sierra Online was!? In a videogame website?
Wow. How quick we videogame fans are to forget our own history. This reminds me of the multiple times I've seen people here on HN ask who Carmack was and why it mattered what he had to say about tech.
- rbanffy 6y ago> ... people don't know who Roberta Williams is, or what Sierra Online was!? In a videogame website? A lot of these people are interested in playing games, not on history. Sadly, lots of people seem to be unbothered by being ignorant of the history of their own favorite pastimes.
- treis 6y agoWhy is that sad? Can't I just mow down some pedestrians in GTA without a guilt trip?
- giobox 6y agoTime marches on. There's a similar phenomenon in the "top n games of all time" articles - its always what matters to the generation writing it. Your John Carmack example betrays our age. His most important contributions to gaming (at least from a history perspective) was arguably early 90s Shareware/Apogee/Id era almost 30 years ago now, I don't expect my kids to know who he is. Heck, why would a young gamer even know what "shareware" was? The idea of sharing and distribution at large scale via end users cloning physical media (floppies) is pretty much absurd in 2020s and of little use to know, despite being hugely important to Carmack's early successes. People just want to play fun games and that's fine. We shouldn't discourage it on basis you "don't appreciate the history properly" or be ashamed of this.
- the_af 6y agoI get your points, however: > Your John Carmack example betrays our age. His most important contributions to gaming (at least from a history perspective) was early 90s Shareware/Apogee/Id era almost 30 years ago now, I don't expect my kids to know who he is. First, Carmack is still relevant today. He still writes about tech, and he still takes part in groundbreaking tech developments. Here is for example a headline from 2019: https://www.engadget.com/2019-11-13-john-carmack-agi.html https://www.engadget.com/2019-11-13-john-carmack-agi.html It's relevant because he is a proven achiever, not just a "visionary" like we're used to in this industry. I'm similarly starting to read about people in tech/software who don't know who Stallman is! And I suppose eventually this will happen to Torvalds as well. Second, are readers of HN "kids"? I used Carmack as an example of someone who readers here on HN occasionally don't know. > People just want to play fun games and that's fine. We shouldn't discourage it on basis you "don't appreciate the history properly" or be ashamed of this. That's ok. However, this happened in the comments section of a website which also has commentary and articles beyond "just playing games", and specifically in an article about videogame history. And Roberta Williams was a huge influence. I suppose in 30 years people will similarly ask, "Nintendo what?". It's sad, though I suppose inevitable. --- edit: giobox, I don't know why you got downvoted, yours was a polite response. I upvoted your comment because I value the conversation.
- doc_gunthrop 6y agoJohn Carmack's contribution to the field of video games was revolutionary. He was the pioneer who brought smooth side-scrolling to PC gaming (e.g. Commander Keen) as well as 3D graphics to video games (e.g. Wolfenstein 3D, Doom). Seeing as how FPS games are one of the biggest (if not the biggest) genre of video gaming out there, Carmack has had an immeasurably massive impact on the industry. It's fine if people want to just play games, but don't belittle the titan whose shoulder countless subsequent developers have stood atop.
- sleepybrett 6y agoDanielle Bunten Berry MULE, Seven Cities of Gold, Heart of Africa > the entire sierra catalog
- the_af 6y agoThis isn't a contest. Yes, I know who Dani Bunten (RIP) was, and it was a huge deal. I suspect that, similarly, these people who don't know Roberta Williams don't know about Dani either. > MULE, Seven Cities of Gold, Heart of Africa > the entire sierra catalog Those are awesome, groundbreaking games, and the technical limitations they had to work around are very interesting. However, the entire Sierra catalog, and in particular the first two Space Quest games (text interfaces!) hold a special place in my heart. I learned English with them. So I must respectfully disagree :)