4 ms·
How a secret European language ‘made a rabbit’ and survived
- ihm 6y agoCan't comment on the accuracy of this overall, but there are a lot of mistakes/sloppiness with the Yiddish. The word is "tsore" not "sore", "shul" has meant school in Yiddish for a long time and not exclusively synagogue, and "und" is German and not Yiddish.
- ncmncm 6y agoI forgive all.
- wahern 6y agoBut synagogue can also means a place for religious study. In some Islamic cultures even today (e.g. Afghanistan under Taliban rule), a "school" is synonymous with a place for religious study--learning to read & write and even basic arithmetic is incident to the purpose of studying religious texts. Couldn't this have also been true of many Jewish communities in Eastern Europe? That is, "school" simply referencing religious study activities at the local synagogue, such that going to school quite literally implied going to the synagogue? After all, in the West schools for children as we understand them today are relatively modern inventions--not just the details (e.g. the Prussian system), but the whole notion generally. Christians historically didn't emphasize literacy as strongly as Judaism and Islam.[1] In general it was something acquired at home, and when and where schools were eventually organized they naturally had a more secular character, notwithstanding they were usually administered by clergy. Few Christians would ever conflate "church" and "school"--neither place nor function--but in some other communities (contemporary and especially historically) such distinctions are rather subtle if not empty. [1] AFAIU, Islam always emphasized literacy as a component of religious practice. But for the first several hundred years still maintained a distinction between secular and non-secular scholarship that we would recognize today. Then a sect of Islam erasing that distinction became predominate, achieving in Islam what many Christian sects have heretofore failed to achieve despite unrelenting efforts over the millennia. (Absolutely nothing new about the religious right trying to "put god back into the classroom". It's just that Christianity as a whole, especially Western Christianity, has been an outlier in maintaining a persistent theological and practical distinction.)
- robocat 6y ago“being in a pickle”: “The original Yiddish phrase (Zores und Jokreszeit) had nothing to do with pickles, only sounded like them (to German ears, like Saure Gurkenzeit, or ‘pickled cucumber time’), so that German speakers mistakenly started talking of pickles when they were in trouble.” I love the ‘Chinese whispers’ between languages in this example. “The idiom derives from the Yiddish idiom Zores und Jokreszeit (time of need and price increases) and was assimilated to the similar-sounding German expression Sauregerkenzeit (cucumber time)” quote from: The Language of Thieves: The Story of Rotwelsch and One Family’s Secret History by Martin Puchner (who also wrote the article).
- onethought 6y agoMinor Nit: I cringe a bit every time a see or hear the use of "Chinese whispers" the US "Telephone" conveys the same message without the potential racial overtone. (I know in the commonwealth it's never used with intentional racial prejudice).
- oh_sigh 6y agoFrom wikipedia, it seems like there is one bad reason it might be called Chinese Whispers, and then a bunch of benign reasons it might be called that: > Various reasons have been suggested for naming the game after the Chinese, but there is no concrete explanation.[5] One suggested reason is a widespread English fascination with Chinese culture in the 18th and 19th centuries - including that now known as Orientalism. Another proposed theory is that English people of the 19th century believed that Chinese people spoke in a way that was deliberately unintelligible, thus in their minds associating the Chinese language with confusion and incomprehensibility. An additional explanation is the commonplace observation that when two people, such as English and Chinese speakers, try to communicate with each other in their own language, the result is often confusion, and equally often amusing to both parties. A further theory is that the game stems from the supposed confused messages created when a message was passed verbally from tower to tower along the Great Wall of China.[5] Out of curiosity, do you cringe when you hear the phrase "it's Greek to me"?
- 6y ago
- aarchi 6y agoThe intermixing of languages is fascinating. I'm familiar with the phrase „Bock haben“, but was unaware that it originated with Rotwelsch. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotwelsch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotwelsch
- ncmncm 6y agoThis is absolutely engrossing! Thank you, pepys, for posting this.