3 ms·
Electric commuter trains have other major benefits. They stop and start frequently, and electric train sets can accelerate and decelerate faster than diesel. On
by amluto 6y ago
Electric commuter trains have other major benefits. They stop and start frequently, and electric train sets can accelerate and decelerate faster than diesel. On the upcoming electric Caltrain, this will save quite a bit of time for long commutes. I believe that many electric trains can also regenerative brake. They can operate safely in long tunnels, unlike diesel. I suspect that diesel locomotives are considerably less efficient under the varying load conditions of a commuter train than they are for long freight routes.
And, as far as I know, all major high speed trains are electric.
- donarb 6y ago> electric train sets can accelerate and decelerate faster than diesel All locomotives use electric motors for traction. Diesel locomotives have a motor that turns a generator to produce electricity for the traction motors on the wheels. A diesel locomotive can stop and start just as fast as a fully electric locomotive, but commuter trains are relatively lighter than freight trains. Diesel locomotives can also use regenerative braking.
- amluto 6y ago> A diesel locomotive can stop and start just as fast as a fully electric locomotive, The Caltrain electrification plan respectfully disagrees. I am not remotely an expert, but I would guess there are two major factors at play. First, a lot of commuter electric trains are multiple units and have no locomotive. This means that more of the wheels can supply traction, which presumably increases the traction-to-weight ratio of the whole train set. Secondly, I think that efficient diesel generators tend to be most efficient at a specific output power, whereas a commuter train runs over a wide range of output powers. A grid-powered electric train set can briefly draw several MW from the grid without a major loss of efficiency.
- Symbiote 6y agoTo make a third factor a bit more explicit: there's a limit to the power you can apply to a wheel before it slips on the rail. Having more powered wheelsets means the total possible power is increased. Commuter trains usually use multiple units, and metro trains always do -- they start and stop often, so the improved acceleration is a benefit. Long distance trains can be multiple units, or a single locomotive: the time saving is less useful on a train that stops infrequently, so lower capital + maintenance costs win (plus passenger comfort, it's quieter inside).