4 ms·
I strongly disagree as I personally flat out avoid the news. It’s simply not relevant that some school shooting happened somewhere yesterday or some pundits go
by Retric 6y ago
I strongly disagree as I personally flat out avoid the news. It’s simply not relevant that some school shooting happened somewhere yesterday or some pundits got upset over latest issue.
As far as the general public is concerned newspapers etc where and are simply another form of entertainment. As such, cat videos are just as much competition as whatever a famous person did yesterday. Becoming informed the week before an election is one thing, getting sucked in a year+ from an election is a waste.
Now direct sources like the National Weather Service and CDC are useful. However, channel X news isn’t funding that, tax payers are.
PS: I suspect many will have a strong options that I am wrong, but please post an objective justification for your viewpoint.
- alistairSH 6y agoPunditry isn't news. It's editorializing. As for shootings or other things that are news, they are critical for a functioning democracy. What's happening around you should be informing your decisions come election day.
- pb7 6y ago> What's happening around you should be informing your decisions come election day. Should it? Isn't that how we got into this mess where every single publication and topic is politicized? There's no chance this isn't why public trust in media is dropping aggressively.
- hobs 6y agoYour proposed alternate is to ignore information to vote, which seem obviously worse?
- Retric 6y agoPersonally, no. You can easily look up actual crime statistics for example and become informed, watching the news doesn’t make you actually informed about anything particularly relevant. Put another way, the news cycle is a thin slice of time and news organizations filter things based on what’s important to them in the moment. A mass shooting for example might only make the news because it happened to follow some other even larger mass shooting.
- pessimizer 6y agoReporting on shootings (and other things) is also punditry. There's an editorial decision being made about what deaths are important to report and what deaths are not.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoIf I was shot to death for no good reason of course I’d want people to tell other people about it so they can do something to ensure it doesn’t happen again. Bias is everywhere - but there is still a regression-to-mean for self-interest via societal progress.
- Retric 6y agoThat’s why we collect crime statistics and do police investigations etc. If I specifically get shot it’s only really relevant in a wider context or to people who know me. Having 1 million people hear about my death to then forget about it by next week isn’t really relevant to anyone. Meanwhile my friends don’t need to hear about it on the news.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoThe subtext of my reply was that I was advocating for gun control legislation. There won't be popular support for GC without the news media reporting on unnecessary deaths that could have been prevented with adequate GC.
- Retric 6y agoPlenty of ways to influence popular option without relying on news organizations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CJefferson 6y agoIf you avoid the news you should have been happy with Facebook being forbidden from linking to news. If the news is just "entertainment", why should Facebook get to use it for free?
- pb7 6y agoI'm not the GP but I personally was happy with Facebook's decision to ban links to news.
- bosswipe 6y agoYou do not avoid the news, you are on Hacker News right now commenting on a news story.