12 ms·
Epic will pay off class-action loot-box settlement with in-game currency
- Loughla 6y agoCan someone please explain to me how this is not just a complete travesty and perversion of settlements? >In a way, the digital giveaway could even be seen as an effective promotion, luring players back to the games and creating the potential for them to spend more on additional microtransactions down the road. That. That's the part I need explained to me. Get punished, but use the punishment to hook players even more. How is this allowed?
- jka 6y agoSimilar strategies have been used before; seven or so years after opening a lawsuit about a data breach at Zappos, claimants were offered 10% coupons for the Zappos online store. https://www.zdnet.com/article/zappos-data-breach-settlement-users-get-10-store-discount-lawyers-get-1-6m/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/zappos-data-breach-settlement-...
- dr_orpheus 6y agoYep, I remember getting Ticketmaster credit for their class action lawsuit.
- ourmandave 6y agoI owned an '76 Chevy pickup and GM sent a coupon worth $1000 off the purchase of a brand new pickup as a settlement. Never used it, but I assume Dealer Keeps All Incentives applied. (They had side-saddle gas tanks that increased the chances of a fire in an accident.) https://www.lieffcabraser.com/defect/gm-pickup-fuel-tanks/ https://www.lieffcabraser.com/defect/gm-pickup-fuel-tanks/
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoI got tons of free tickets in that one. I was never able to find an event to spend them on. What a fiasco.
- ashtonkem 6y agoBecause the regulators are completely captured.
- ChicagoBoy11 6y agoWhat regulators, though? Class sued the company and agreed to these ridiculous terms. I'd see a role to question maybe the integrity of the lawyers accepting the deal, or the mechanics of entering/disputing/leaving class action lawsuits in this world where now class members can easily reach into the many, many millions. But, like another commenter posted, if these were just two parties agreeing to this (which in some sense it is), we wouldn't have a problem with this at all.
- chriswarbo 6y ago> What regulators, though? Online gambling regulators.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post ideological battle comments and flamebait to HN. There's no information here, just a trope repetition; that makes this strictly a discussion-lowering comment. We penalize accounts that post like this, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dmurray 6y agoIt's legal because both sides agreed to settle for it. If it was an individual suing Epic, and they agreed to go away in return for some shiny digital magic beans, you wouldn't see anything wrong with that. What's different if a million customers settle for it? Customers can opt out of the class action, or start their own competing one. What would be a real problem is if other customers opted out, sued Epic individually, didn't settle, and the judge used the "payout" from the previous settlement to decide what a fair compensation would be. That hasn't happened here.
- A12-B 6y agoLol, I'm sure every single person in the class action suit agreed to the settlement, and otherwise would be able to afford to sue them again. Right. Settlements are decided by a single class representative, and other class members are often not given notice of their right to opt-out or counter-sue.
- sudhirj 6y agoAnd that's why you'd opt into a class action in the first place. You have a problem, you elect someone to handle it for you, give them decision making power and accept the outcome they've been able to achieve. It's just democracy, no?
- Arubis 6y agoAll of this makes sense except for the bit about democracy. That's unrelated; this happens to be a process that's in use here, but it would work just as well in a monarchy.
- njharman 6y agoThere are lots of things that are still illegal even if both sides agree to it. Slavery for instance. Also all the things covered by consumer protection litigation, which top commenter is probably thinking of. The conditions/clauses of the agreement must not be illegal.
- alasdair_ 6y ago
- josho 6y ago> Get punished But, this isn't even a punishment. In game currency isn't real. It doesn't cost the company anything. So, this is 'be found guilty and be forced to go back to your junkies and give them their next hit of crack for free.' I can imagine the ad banners: "Thousands of players will win new loot, will you be one? Play to find out".
- remram 6y agoI'm being pedantic, but no currency is "real". This one allows players to buy thing, which they are likely to want to do since they have in the past (and cared enough to start a class action over). You deciding that those goods are "hits of crack" is entirely subjective. However it is true that it only costs Epic the lost revenue from selling those v-bucks. If a freely-tradable currency was emitted to cover debt, you'd have the penalty of devaluation, but that is not the case here. Of course that makes no difference for the players, that's only about punishment.
- Krasnol 6y ago> I'm being pedantic, but no currency is "real". It is real in the sense that you can chose where you spend it. While this is like coupons. It may have value but that is very limited and therefore does not qualify as currency.
- tvprod1203 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_store https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_store Somehow feels familiar.
- joecot 6y agoOne time I bought a Nissan Versa. It had a Continuously Variable Transmission in it. They knew that they broke constantly, and they sold it anyway. They lied to me and said my transmission was fine a few months before the warranty was over, so they wouldn't have to replace it. Years after I traded that car in and it went immediately to a junk yard, Nissan settled a class action lawsuit over it. The compensation? A voucher for a few thousand towards a new Nissan. I promise that when I joined a class action lawsuit over Nissan screwing me over, my goal wasn't to buy more Nissans. I would hazard a guess that many players who felt cheated enough by Epic to join a lawsuit against them likely feel similar.
- jayd16 6y agoIs it even about punishment? This is a civil case about loot-boxes. The settlement is to pay off the lawyers and make the case go away. I'm not that morally opposed to loot boxes and I don't believe any laws were broken. What kind of punishment are you looking for?
- _Microft 6y agoI hope the lawyers are also paid with in-game currency.
- alpaca128 6y agoOr exposure
- stuaxo 6y agoThe point of the settlement is to hit a company hard enough so they stop before doing something like this again. Using in game currency and not real money is absolutely not going to achieve this.
- curryst 6y agoNo, that would be the purpose of a judgement. This isn't a judgement, it's a settlement. To Epic, the purpose is to make this go away. To those suing, the point is take a small but guaranteed windfall rather than risk a lengthy and uncertain court process.
- njharman 6y agoA disincentive to continuing the activity the class action suit was brought for. In theory, class action lawsuits are either or both 1) compensate victims 2) "force" company to stop activity society deems "bad" Victims care about #1, the rest of us want #2 so we don't become victims in the future. In this case, stop exploiting addiction and other human psychology for profit via loot boxes.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThe question is whether the class action suit's intent is to punish them (as in, did they commit a crime?), or to get compensation for their behaviour. If the latter, then the suing parties probably agreed to them settling via in game currency.
- chaostheory 6y agoIt reminds me of how Nintendo settled US AG lawsuits on price fixing with coupons for Nintendo products. There's definitely a precedent. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-07-26-fi-276-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-07-26-fi-276-st...
- rhino369 6y ago>How is this allowed? You are pretty much assuming they are liable for the allegations in the complaint against them. Settlements for low value are a sign that plaintiffs view their chances of success (including being awarded substantial damages) as being low. So one way of looking at this is, Epic did nothing wrong, and they are giving away essentially nothing to make the plaintiff go away. If plaintiffs thought they had a good case, they wouldn't take monopoly money.
- DevKoala 6y agoThey probably saw their chances of winning against EPIC’s legal team being very low. That legal team is stacked atm.
- jonas21 6y agoNotably, the attorneys aren't taking monopoly money. > Additionally, the attorneys who brought the lawsuit (see FAQ 10) will ask the Court to award them attorney’s fees and expenses in an amount not to exceed $11,300,000.00, for the time, expense and effort expended in investigating the facts, litigation, and negotiating the Settlement. The Class Representatives will also ask the Court for a payment of up to $75,000 collectively for their time, effort, and service in this matter. https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/Faq https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/Faq
- ccleve 6y agoThe lawyers get real money, and the victims get fake money. That's the real scandal. Our tort system is broken.
- gruez 6y agoIs the risk-adjusted price that the lawyers are being paid unusually high? Lawyers being expensive doesn't really mean "Our tort system is broken".
- freeone3000 6y ago
- mc32 6y agoThis would be like the big tobacco settlement being: big tobacco will pay smokers 100 billion tobacco bucks redeemable for cigarettes at an exchange rate of 100 tobacco bucks per cigarette.
- shagie 6y agoWith cigarettes, there's at least a real product there that has some cost to the company that made it. With epic game currency, it's just a bunch of bits that could be created without any resource use by the company. They could create 10x more game currency at no more cost to the company.
- edoceo 6y agoSome dev has to run an INSERT statement. And maybe a test case. Cheap.
- vmception 6y agoThis is common and there is some psychology involved in how to create these scenarios. Basically you can scare the government into thinking the state’s actions will reduce competition (because your company wont exist anymore if you pay). The government uses so much energy trying to create/continue private sector competition that they don’t want to be directly responsible for creating closer to a monopoly of the remaining companies in the sector. So they’ll accept these consequence free settlements, or even get behind settlements that actually are advertisements. The court here is granting approval of the settlement.
- nodesocket 6y agoRemember this next time the HN crowd gets their pitch forks out against Apple and their dispute with Epic. Who is really the “evil” company here.
- jpambrun 6y agoThey can both be evil.
- retox 6y agoIt's like a casino settling with victims of an addiction machine with tokens for other games that can't be cashed out.
- qwertycrackers 6y agoIt's because this is a settlement out-of-court. Basically the lawyers thought the case was really weak so they took what they could get. Or perhaps they were corrupt.
- yebyen 6y ago...but I'm sure the lawyers who brought the case aren't being paid with in-game currency, amiright?
- vorpalhex 6y agoHow many loot llamas does it take to buy a suit or a rolex?
- m463 6y agohttps://dilbert.com/strip/2001-03-15 https://dilbert.com/strip/2001-03-15
- skeeter2020 6y agothat's what the 25M in real money is for. Pay the lawyers and the ridciulously small number of people who will fill out and submit a claim. You can't make this stuff up; the only way it could be more over the top would be if the settlement was for "get a 20% bonus on all new V-bucks purchases!"
- raunakdag 6y agoInteresting side-note - as a minor who plays the game, Epic is essentially discouraging you at all from participating in the cash-sided part of the settlement with the follow-up of contract stipulation - if you request cash due to being a minor at the time of playing, Epic will force you to close your Epic Games account, across all games.
- AlexandrB 6y agoWe really need more robust consumer protections for digital goods. This is like asking you to return every product you bought at WalMart with no compensation as a condition for accepting a settlement from a WalMart class action suit. Likewise, getting an account banned for ToS violations at a storefront such as the App Store should not immediately strip you of all goods purchased on that storefront.
- antiterra 6y agoThey are obligated to allow refund by contractual disaffirmation, which must negate the contract in whole. It also makes sense that Epic also requires a subsequent replacement account to be opened by a non-minor.
- Macha 6y agoEthics of paying off class actions with promotional/discount rewards aside, I'm kind of surprised they did settle. While many EU regulators have held loot boxes to be in violation of rules regarding licensed gambling or marketing gambling to kids, I'd always assumed the US would be more open to letting whales be eaten by the sharks based on their attitude towards free markets.
- oceanghost 6y agoAmerican citizens attitudes and what our political/court system do are often very different.
- falcolas 6y agoIf there's a chance of setting a poor precedent for them, even a minuscule chance, they'll often settle after racking up the opponent's legal bills.
- skeeter2020 6y agoClass action lawsuits rarely go to trial. Did you note the 25 million in real cash that's included? The settlement is camouflage for the true goal, which was getting big fees for the lawyers. Their strategy is to take these cases as close to trial as possible without ever having to prepare for a courtroom. They ran this one to perfection.
- istjohn 6y agoOf course they settled. The only way the settlement could have been more favorable for them is if the plaintiffs agreed to pay Epic.
- jandrese 6y agoWhile this is probably not the case, this could be a subversive attack on potential competitors if Epic is planning to release a MMO in the near future that doesn't have Gamble Boxes. Many many competitors would be in danger of a similar lawsuit and could find themselves cut off at the knees right as Epic launches their own MMO or F2P mobile game. This is probably too Machiavellian, but it's not like the industry isn't rife with Gamble Boxes. There are a lot of companies that are basically dependent on gambling for the majority of their income.
- endisneigh 6y agoIs it possible to liquidate in-game currency for cash at the same price it would've cost to purchase it to begin with? If not the settlement cost Epic basically nothing.
- croon 6y agoHey now, it probably cost a couple of man hours to compile the lists and some compute time on the database cluster.
- meibo 6y agoNo, it's not - but you can buy funny dances with it!
- ttt0 6y agoThe best part is that they will shut down this game once people move on to something else and it's no longer profitable
- FatalLogic 6y agoThere seem to be two beneficiaries from such class action cases: Lawyers who get paid, and prosecutors who get publicity. The deterrent effect on the guilty party is negligible, and the benefit to the public is nil.
- bilekas 6y agowow.. I'm sure many companies facing class action law suits would love to reimburse people with in-store vouchers.. How is this legal ? Isn't the whole loophole around in-game currency not receiving gambling regulation is because the currency is NOT redeemable ?
- Majromax 6y ago> How is this legal ? Because this is a settlement of a lawsuit, rather than an independently-triggered regulatory action. The lawyers and representative plaintiffs may agree to this because an in-game-points payment inflates the notional value of the settlement and thus the legal fees, but that group would be paid in cash based on a fraction of the settlement value.
- hn8788 6y agoI don't see why they'd be able to do this, considering that one of the main arguments for why lootboxes and virtual currency don't count as gambling is that they have no monetary value.
- fritzo 6y agoConsider the two cases. If loot-boxes have no monetary value, then Epic won't be losing any monetary value in the settlement. If loot-boxes do have monetary value, then Epic should pay, and loot-boxes should be a valid form of payment. ;)
- thejoeflow 6y agoI thought this was an Onion article. Wow.
- pjmlp 6y agoThis same Epic that is screaming to the world how Apple and Google are so bad boys. Good example of dual morals.
- Cloudef 6y agoTim sweeney is just a big asshole to be frank
- colinmhayes 6y agoBad boys can still point out when others are behaving poorly, right?
- CivBase 6y agoNever let yourself become loyal to a company. Companies are motivated by profit. The only "support" you should ever give a company is payment in exchange for a product or service. Bad companies support plenty of good causes. Support those causes, but don't confuse that with support for the company itself. I agree with Google about link taxes being bad, but I do not support Google itself. I agree with Apple about Facebook's privacy violations being bad, but I do not support Apple itself. I agree with Epic about Apple's restrictions regarding what users can do with their devices being bad, but I do not support Epic itself. Companies are not heroes.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s not that simple - if you ‘agree’ with these companies, then you are agreeing with their self-serving framing, and supporting them. You might think there are problems with each company (I certainly do), but that doesn’t mean I need to agree with them in any way.
- im3w1l 6y agoJust because it's self serving doesn't mean it's wrong. They can reach the right conclusion for the wrong reasons.
- 6y ago
- onepointsixC 6y agoWhat an absolute travesty. Epic is running a casino, encouraging players to gamble, but not for something of value, but an infinitely repeatable digital good. To be able to "pay off", if you could even go as far to call it that, in digital goods at effectively no cost to them then we're just encouraging further bad behavior.
- skeeter2020 6y agoAt least in a casino they comp you physical goods and services that have a real value. Who knew the mob and wall street were the good guys?
- mfost 6y agoDon't let the drama fool you though. Epic only had those RNG loot boxes in the "Save the World" Fortnite game which is entirely different from the actual popular phenomena that is the battleroyal one. That and on Rocket League which they bought in that state while they were only implementing the standard TF2/Valve model of lootboxes. And when bought they made them switch to a non lootbox model. As such, that class action lawsuit is rather clickbait by itself. It rode on the popularity of "Fortnite BR" to make it look like Epic was selling tons of lootboxes to kids when the reality is they had so few players of Save The World it probably had a rather insignificant impact on kids getting exposed to gambling.
- _0ffh 6y ago"Even though it's settling a US lawsuit, Epic says this same deal will apply to all Fortnite players globally." They wish! This can be no more than an offer which must be accepted before it "applies". I just don't know if anyone will actually bring this to court rather than accept the offer.
- exabrial 6y agoClass action lawsuits are turning out to be a scam. It should be law that lawyers can't have more than something like 5% of the settlement, and companies should have to pay out as cash equivelant. Reminds me of the Equifax settlement which was a total scam. "Free Credit Monitoring" was BS, as Equifax was going to pay itself for the product, and everyone in the USA already has "Free Credit Monitoring" anyway. For leaking all of my personal details, I'd love to be paid for the time and money I've had to spend cleaning up their mistakes after Equifax hired a music major as the head of Information Security.
- CivBase 6y ago> It should be law that lawyers can't have more than something like 5% of the settlement The settlement wasn't even cash, though. Did the lawyers get paid in V-Bucks? They should have been.
- MikeUt 6y ago> It should be law that lawyers can't have more than something like 5% of the settlement Then finding a lawyer willing to go through the long and complex class action lawsuit will be even harder and/or more expensive, resulting in fewer class-action suits, meaning the punishment for these scams will be even more unlikely than it is now. Even if lawyers got 100% of the settlement, class actions would still be worth it as deterrent.
- istjohn 6y agoBut this isn't a punishment at all. I just don't believe that it's not possible to more closely align the interests of class action lawyers with that of the classes they represent. It doesn't seem like it's difficult to find lawyers willing to initiate class action lawsuits today. They just never seem to amount to much more than a pay day for the lawyers.
- exabrial 6y agocorrect: right now the interests of the lawyers are aligned with the people they're suing, not the people they're representing.
- nico__ 6y agoMaybe if loot-boxes are considered gambling it is because the digital asset has monetary value, therefore it could be used as reimbursement in this case? shady
- kowlo 6y agoI thought this was a joke, sounds like the premise for a south park episode.
- CivBase 6y agoSo as "punishment", Epic has to "pay" users in a fake currency which can only be redeemed for a limited set of Epic products and whose value is artificially controlled by Epic themselves. This sounds more like a marketing campaign than a legal settlement.
- nrhodes 6y agoReminds me of the airline antitrust suit in the early 1990's. The settlement was 10% discount coupons (AirScrip) for seven of the airlines that were involved. Two airlines that weren't part of the suit (Alaska and America West) agreed to accept the coupons since they didn't want to get left out.
- jacquesm 6y agoThe degree of 'unethical' at play here is nothing short of epic.
- rogual 6y agoMisleading, baity headline. Yes, the in-game currency settlement is awful, but the Ars Technica headline writer is making it sound more awful than it really is, because, quote: In addition to the virtual currency, Epic will also be providing "up to $26.5 million in cash and other benefits to U.S.-based Fortnite and Rocket League players" to settle the claims.
- dantillberg 6y agoYou make a good point, but for cash benefit, each individual person must fill out the claim form at [0]. It's not clear up front how Byzantine that process might be, but they're at least asking for detailed documentation of records Epic must already have on file. Payments are capped at $50 per person. $26.5 million is merely an upper limit on the total of all payments, but that requires at least 530,000 people successfully completing max-value claims. 0: https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/SubmitClaim https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/SubmitClaim
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoNonsense, it's a perfectly valid headline. The lawyers get first dibs on that $26.5M, players mostly get in-game currency. > Each Settlement Class Member who timely submits a valid Claim Form will be entitled to receive their choice of either a cash award (up to $50 ... The claim form isn't posted yet on the website. It has to be physically mailed in to the lawyers, with all your personal info. Of 10 million Rocket League and Fortnite players, how many do you think will actually mail that in? They're betting it's less than 1 in 20. I'd wager it's going to be more like 1 in 2000, which costs Epic just $0.25M, leaving $26.25M for the lawyers. > Upon receipt of a Claim Form, the Settlement Administrator will determine your eligibility to receive an award. Depending on the number of Approved Claims, it is possible that each Settlement Class Member’s award will be reduced on a pro-rata basis after payment of settlement administration costs, attorney’s fees and expenses, and Incentive Awards to the Plaintiffs. Even if the number of approved claims is not already small, the cash is for the lawyers first, Epic is paying the players primarily with in-game currency. https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/Faq https://www.epiclootboxsettlement.com/Home/Faq
- alasdair_ 6y ago
- AcerbicZero 6y agoCan I pay my taxes with special in-country vouchers?
- klmadfejno 6y agoWhat's the actual claim behind the lawsuit? I hate lootboxes, but what's the basis for damages?
- hundchenkatze 6y agoThat loot boxes are the same as gambling, and encouraging minors to gamble. > Epic was faced with a class-action lawsuit alleging, among other things, that it had "psychologically manipulate[d] its young players into thinking they will 'get lucky.'"
- klmadfejno 6y agoI guess I'm surprised that's illegal? They're hardly the only loot box offering company
- fingerlocks 6y agoCan someone explain to a non-gamer what this is all about? Specifically, what's the legal issue here? The article doesn't really say. Was Epic lying about the probabilities of getting rare items in these loot boxes? Or is it because "gambling" was marketed to children, in general? If the latter, why is this any different from similar non-online activities, like sweepstakes and raffles for children's toys?
- jandrese 6y agoThey were encouraging children to gamble with real money. I don't know how every MMO operator isn't clenching their butts at the outcome of this lawsuit. There are loads of Korean MMOs that really only have two things: Grind and Gamble Boxes. Three things if you count the Anime titties.
- jrockway 6y agoIs there any effect on the game industry as a whole here? As far as I can tell, Overwatch has exactly the same loot box model. Is anyone suing Blizzard over this? Or is there some particular miniscule detail that made Epic's actions illegal, but selling randomized loot boxes in general is still OK?
- istjohn 6y agoClass action lawsuits should require a "class advocate" who is only paid a flat percentage of the total amount awarded to the class in a settlement or court victory. The advocate would represent the class and would have the power to hire, fire, and negotiate compensation for any lawyers, and any settlement would require the advocate's approval. The advocate could choose to fork over half of the settlement to the lawyers if they judge that that is it what is necessary to win, but they could also negotiate lower fees or hire another firm if they believe the lawyers are charging exhorbitant fees or otherwise not representing the best interests of the class. HT @MikeUt https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26238726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26238726
- teddyh 6y agoTicketmaster lost a class action suit in 2016, but managed to be allowed to pay the customers it unfairly charged not in money, but in coupons for Ticketmaster. http://www.billboard.com/articles/business/7370600/ticketmaster-class-action-settlement-approved-details http://www.billboard.com/articles/business/7370600/ticketmas...
- medicineman 6y agoIt has never been more obvious how lawyers and politicians run this country as a giant scam.
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoDo they also pay employees with company scrips?
- ncmncm 6y agoSince this is a settlement, the court has nothing to say about it. It's entirely a private deal between the lawyers, who on one side are wholly failing to represent the plaintiffs. Epic got off practically for free, and have probably already hired the nephews of the opposing lawyers. Those lawyers should be disbarred. A solution might be to require the lawyers to take payment in whatever the injured parties got. But since legislators are mostly lawyers, don't expect anything to be changed about this sort of cushy arrangement.