3 ms·
"Content is king." Google nor Facebook produce any. It's one thing for consumers to not want to pay for content. We are used to having news for "free". But
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"Content is king."
Google nor Facebook produce any.
It's one thing for consumers to not want to pay for content. We are used to having news for "free". But it's another thing for middlemen to expect to get news for free that
they can use to turn a massive profit, undercutting the source's own business.
Bravo to Australia for standing up to the middlemen.
It worked.
- aeternum 6y agoPerhaps we should wait until the deal is negotiated before claiming it worked. My guess is it was likely the Australian news agencies unhappy that their traffic dropped who then pressured the government to reconsider the law and restart talks with FB.
- johnnyYen 6y agoI think you are mis-understanding what the news organisations source of business is. It's NOT the consumers of news, and never was. It's the advertising companies who place ads on the news organisations properties - and now the news organisations customers (i.e. the ad companies) have found it more beneficial to advertise with Google and FB.
- AlstZam 6y ago> It's NOT the consumers of news, and never was. You're right for the vast majority of news organization on internet but we can't say that it's "never was" (or "is" for the matter). I have at least 3 examples [0] in mind of news organizations for which advertising is not part of their business model (or a very insignificant part compared to "consumers of news" part). And I'm sure we can find similar example all around the globe. Of course such organization generally relies on subscription and/or donation. And of course for this to works "consumers of news" need to pay for it. [0] Sorry all French : Le Canard enchainé (paper) ; Le Monde Diplo (paper and web) ; Mediapart (web)
- jay_kyburz 6y agoThis was not government standing up for anybody. This is a shakedown, pure and simple. If the government wanted to insure that Australians had a healthy independent news ecosystem, they would have legislated against filtering news for your bubble. They would have passed laws insuring balance and impartiality in the news itself. Update: There is nothing in legislation that says the money paid by these companies needs to be paid to journalists or to produce news. This money will go directly into executive bonuses and the news organizations will still go out of business.
- mfDjB 6y agoI've never really understood this argument, the content is still on the news sites right? The news sites provide blurbs and descriptions through OpenGraph metadata that Facebook use, if they don't want entities to use metadata to make a link richer they could just remove the metadata no? Basically I want to know how Google or Facebook are exploiting news content to make a profit.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoThe business model for news is "pay a journalist to write a story, serve that story to readers accompanied by ads, make enough money on the ads to pay the journalist". Neither FB nor Google pay journalists. But they have the audience. So the newspaper posts their news story to FB and lets Google index it in the hope that enough people click through the link to read their story and see their ads. But FB and Google both also serve ads along with the story listing, and they often post enough of the story so that the reader doesn't have to click through to the actual news site. So FB and Google get all the revenue that the story generates, and the news site gets none, despite having to pay the journalist to write it.
- postingawayonhn 6y ago> But FB and Google both also serve ads along with the story listing, and they often post enough of the story so that the reader doesn't have to click through to the actual news site. This is already covered by copyright law and the news sites can tell Google not to index the site and provide less OpenGhaph data for Facebook.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoThe problem is that the news sites don't have a loyal audience of readers, and instead rely on traffic redirected from Google and FB. > This is already covered by copyright law and the news sites can tell Google not to index the site and provide less OpenGhaph data for Facebook. They can't delist with Google, because then they don't get that traffic. They can't provide less data, because then FB's algorithm won't shove their article into enough people's feed. They can't sue for copyright infringement when they specifically granted both Google and FB permission to use their content as part of their listing. It's a really tough position for newspapers. The solution is that they need to charge readers directly for news. But that would be a massively difficult undertaking (though the success of the Guardian's "support us directly" campaign using the Wikipedia model does show some hope). It would also mean changing a generation's worth of journalistic practices.
- madeofpalk 6y agoYou're... saying this on Hacker News. A website that expects to get "news for free".
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoIs HN using the data it gets from HN users to sell services to advertisers. You dont think there is a non-commercial versus commercial distinction.
- madeofpalk 6y agoSo you think that any commercial website (is HN, ran by a VC firm, even non-commercial?) should have to pay the website for links its users submit?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoNo. But with respect to how Google News and Faceook use "news" to support their respective rackets, I think this is different from the example of HN. For one, HN is not trying to compete for advertiser payments with every website that gets submitted. "Commercial" in the sense I am using it means deriving revenue from the use of news. Perhaps HN does that somehow but to support its VC business but that seems a poor comparison to the likes of Google/Facebook. Big difference between Google News and HN, or a Facebook "news feed" and HN.
- intricatedetail 6y agoMedia wanted the cake and eat it too while breaking internet. Media want not only free promotion on FB but to also get paid for it. Its a money grab.