3 ms·
One very effective way to solve this would be to allow in-kind payments. If the IRS believes your shares are worth $X, and they think you owe 25% of X, they sho
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
One very effective way to solve this would be to allow in-kind payments. If the IRS believes your shares are worth $X, and they think you owe 25% of X, they should be willing to accept 25% of your shares.
This would solve a lot of other tax issues relating to transfers of illiquid equity. Consider the estate tax - a guy owns a business the IRS values at $10M and dies. The kids don't have $1.75M sitting around in cash (35% of $10MM-$5MM exclusion amount) so they are forced to liquidate the business. Instead, wouldn't it be better to allow the business to continue running, but pay the IRS 17.5% of dividends/pass through income?
[edit: said profit, meant dividends. Thanks orijing.]
- orijing 15y agoYou mean 17.5% of the profits on top of the 35%?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's only 35% of value above 5MM, so (in my hypothetical) the IRS becomes a 17.5% shareholder of the company. Like any 17.5% shareholder, they are entitled to 17.5% of the profits (ignoring details like profits not immediately distributed to shareholders).
- random42 15y agoIRS is a revenue collecting body, not a VC firm. Why would they want to take undue risk? I see the following reasons (atleast), the proposed solution is a no-go. a. 17.5% cash >> 17.5% shares of a business, which is struggling to pay 17.5% cash. b. what happens if the business goes under and IRS owns 100% shares of the business? c. What happens if all IRS get in payment is shares. How the country economy is supposed to run? (with foreign trade etc.)
- kjksf 15y agoForcing the risk on IRS is exactly the point. The idea is to force them to value things in a (more) rational way. Today, they don't have to. Their incentive is exactly the opposite: overvalue things to get more tax out of it. I think we can all agree the best thing is to take away ability to tax phantom money from IRS. Next best thing is to setup the rules so that IRS is on the hook if they overvalue phantom money.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago17.5% cash >> 17.5% shares of a business, which is struggling to pay 17.5% cash. If 17.5% of a business is worth less than $1.75M then 100% of the business is worth less than $10M. Thus the tax bill should be lower than $1.75M. what happens if the business goes under and IRS owns 100% shares of the business? Then the IRS's initial valuation of $10M was inaccurate. Why should the business owner pay for mistakes made by the IRS?
- random42 15y agoIf 17.5% of a business is worth less than $1.75M then 100% of the business is worth less than $10M. Thus the tax bill should be lower than $1.75M. No, The point I was trying to make was that shares of a struggling business is always less in value (due to inherit risk), as compared to hard cash (Which is equal, irrespective of its genesis.) Then the IRS's initial valuation of $10M was inaccurate. Why should the business owner pay for mistakes made by the IRS? No reason. Similarly IRS has no reason to take the investment risks (as its interested in collecting revenues, not funding companies). I just gave a potential risk of scenario, where the business is unable to pay to the IRS money (due to lack of enough cashflow in the business), but still getaway with it. (When it eventually does get bust, but at the cost of IRS/government/Taxpayers, not the owners.)
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe point you are making is that the IRS's assessed value is higher than the value of the business. I.e., the IRS is charging the business owner taxes on $10MM even though they don't really believe his business is worth $10MM. You gave a potential risk scenario where the IRS declares a company is worth a lot, but in reality it is worth very little. You then advocated that a taxpayer (the business owner) should suffer for this mistake by paying cash (some percentage of an incorrect valuation) instead of equity. But that's silly - if the business is about to go belly up (i.e., it's really worthless), the taxpayer should owe very little in tax. Forcing the IRS to take equity is a self enforcing way to prevent the IRS from overtaxing people.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 15y agoBeing a minority shareholder of an otherwise closely-held, family business is usually a losing proposition, unless you have the family's goodwill. If they own 82.5% of the business and operate it, you own 17.5%, and it's not public or particularly large, it's quite easy for them to cut you out of the profits in about a dozen different ways (especially if you're not making any effort to monitor what's going on). Then the IRS is stuck not only owning thousands of small stakes in family businesses, but monitoring them to make sure they're getting fair treatment as a minority shareholder, and filing shareholder lawsuits when necessary.