4 ms·
> It means the people who save by depositing cash in the bank lose value over time, causing them to purchase investments out of necessity. Ah you get it. That'
by arcticbull 6y ago
> It means the people who save by depositing cash in the bank lose value over time, causing them to purchase investments out of necessity.
Ah you get it. That's the idea. Buy gold if you want, buy real estate, buy annuities, buy fixed incomes, I don't care, but money is an intermediary - not a long-term store of value. If you treat it as one you'll have a bad time. Just like if you treated your car as a boat. It'll work for a bit, then it'll sink. Because it's the wrong tool for the job.
> Those are nominal returns, not real returns. Inflation generates no real returns.
Did I say inflation generated returns? No, I said it sets the benchmark rate of return for your investments. If your investments fail to exceed inflation they're not the right choice. That's your duty in a capitalist society - to pick winners by investment.
> Nice rhetorical judo, to frame the central bank’s actions as normal and the lack of an increase as a decrease.
They're paying you less value so it's a decrease. You're tripping yourself up focusing on units instead of what they represent. After all, inflation has many positives, too.
> Alas, if congress could lower the minimum wage without political fallout, economists might suggest they do that instead of inflating the money supply.
That's between you and congress, not between you and Janet Yellen.
> This is why time preference should be taught in school.
I'd argue this conversation is why ECON 101 should be mandatory, so folks have the tools they need to thrive in modern society instead of, well, tilting at windmills.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Ah you get it. That's the idea. Buy gold if you want, I don't care, but money is an intermediary, not a long-term store of value. Only because the wealthy benefit from depreciating currency. It doesn’t have to be this way, and it is this way because of policy that is designed to benefit the ultra-wealthy. > They're paying you less value so it's a decrease. You're tripping yourself up focusing on units. They’re paying the same, but the units depreciated because the oligarchs want workers’ wages to go down. > If you treat it as one you'll have a bad time. Just like if you treated your horse as a boat. Or treat a savings account as a savings account.
- AngrySkillzz 6y ago> Only because the wealthy benefit from depreciating currency Source this claim. Everyone benefits from a depreciating currency because inflation provides a buffer against deflationary spirals that lead to large recessions and job losses for people of all classes. Tell me exactly how inflation benefits only the ultra-wealthy and not anyone else. > because the oligarchs want workers’ wages to go down. I would suggest that you clarify this claim so it does not sound so much like a conspiracy theory.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Source this claim. Asset price inflation vs depreciation of debt in real terms. Wealthy people hold assets that are valued in currency. Depreciating currency causes those assets to go up in nominal terms, and additionally depreciating currency causes a flight to assets. Wealthy people (by definition) have more assets than non-wealthy people, hence this flight from currency to assets bids up the prices of assets. > Everyone benefits from a depreciating currency, because inflation provides a buffer against deflationary spirals that lead to large recessions. Thats a theory-laden and motivated explanation. Surely you can do better than just argument by assertion? > Tell me exactly how inflation benefits only the ultra-wealthy and not anyone else. Thats not my claim. > I would suggest that you clarify this claim so it does not sound so much like a conspiracy theory. I suggest you do your own research and discover that the central bank is very much fact and not at all theory.
- AngrySkillzz 6y ago> Depreciating currency causes those assets to go up in nominal terms That does not increase the real value of those assets, and it does not have any distributional consequences. > Thats a theory-laden and motivated explanation You could go read like, any of the vast literature on the great depression, the things that caused it and the things that made it worse. But you'd rather expose your ignorance on the Internet for us to see. > discover that the central bank is very much fact and not at all theory. I happen to know a lot about central banking, actually. You might be pulling a Dunning-Kruger on this one.
- unethical_ban 6y ago> That's your duty in a capitalist society - to pick winners by investment. See, that, and well as your first point, are where the other person's philosophy and yours collide. I daresay his point is that "It should not be my defacto requirement in society to buy stonks in order to not lose the wages I have duly earned". You are saying "your obligation in society is to take the wages you earn and keep your money moving, rather than keeping it safely".
- arcticbull 6y agoSo buy gold. The point is that an inflationary fiat currency offers maximum flexibility by not forcing anyone into treating it as more than a medium of exchange. The OP is demanding the creation of a new class of thing, which is designed to preserve wealth, with no risk. Ok, pitch that. But there's many reasons why that isn't a good thing. Inability to react to shocks such as a global pandemic, generational wealth consolidation and so on are all reasons its a bad idea. Many things people hate on such as wild value swings and boom/bust cycles were much worse on the gold standard. However, in a world where wages keep pace with inflation (they do) you can recreate the gold standard yourself by firing up Robinhood and buying GLD. By pegging the currency to an arbitrary asset class you're forcing me to use your asset class. By leaving it un-backed, you're free to back your personal economy with whatever asset you like. More freedom.
- jkhdigital 6y agoIf the central bank implemented inflation targeting by simply handing out cash to everyone, I'd probably shrug. But the current system is a moral abomination and I won't be surprised when it collapses in another decade or two. Looking forward to seeing your comments on future HN economics posts as that process plays out.
- arcticbull 6y ago"Moral abomination"? The fed controls interest rates. Lower interest rates are handed out to everyone. Credit card holders. Mortgage refinance. HELOC. Just who do you think is disproportionately benefitting in a way that's causing you to throw up the moral white flag? With sources please.