4 ms·
in the past 3-4 decades Taxonomists have done a poor (some would say terrible) job at describing to the broader world why they are important Without disputing
by anigbrowl 6y ago
in the past 3-4 decades Taxonomists have done a poor (some would say terrible) job at describing to the broader world why they are important
Without disputing your claim, why is this taxonomists' job? Imagine spending 10-15 years of academic work to get a PhD and become the world expert on something important but obscure, and then being told you need to market yourself to the general public and devote a significant portion of your time to answering stupid questions (as in 'who cares about this boring stuff' as opposed to 'what is the airspeed of a pigeon').
If I understand your 3rd paragraph correctly, maybe the real problem here is university administrators ending up actually in charge of things rather than as mere functionaries whose job is to facilitate the academics' goals, mysterious as those may be.Every single academic person I know loathes the administrators of their institutions (as a class rather than at the individual level, though I can think of exceptions) but seem helpless to displace them.
- z77dj3kl 6y agoBecause that's unfortunately how the world works: you have to sell to people the importance of what you do.
- parsimo2010 6y agoBecause if you want to make a living you either have to do something that people are asking for, or you have to convince people that they should be asking for. If the world doesn’t see taxonomists’ worth on their own, it is up to them to educate us if they want to keep their jobs. We don’t have unlimited research funds and they need to play the game just like everyone else. Taxonomy has a tougher time of illustrating value compared to cancer research (as one example), but they still need to convince people that they should be funded. Hopefully the field will figure this out before there is a crisis. As a recent example, the field of public health usually struggles to get funding compared to individual medicine. Before the COVID-19 pandemic very few people saw the value in having robust public health policy, agencies, and research, especially when they considered that they could add a new wing to a hospital or buy ambulances with the same money. Public health as a field did a poor job of convincing people that the field had something valuable to offer. Hopefully taxonomy can figure out how to convince the world that they offer something valuable before they go extinct (pun intended).
- hertzrat 6y agoThis is an argument against specialization. You can’t do extremely difficult things while spending 20-30 hours a week on business management, public outreach, and fundraising. Since that’s the world were living in, might it explain how our tech progress has gotten less impressive in the last 2 decades?
- pishpash 6y agoSo it is somebody's job to sell to the public, but it may not be the researchers'.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoSo they should band together and hire a PR firm, it's possible for something to be your responsibility without having to do the work yourself.
- coliveira 6y agoSo now you propose that scientific researchers fight each other using advertisement and PR campaigns, and spend more of their already small grants, just to do what they were trained to do? Who would benefit from this other than PR companies?
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoIn this case a PR firm would be mostly about getting articles like this written, so maybe they already started. It's either that or they naturally grow their own Neil deGrasse Tyson, or Bill Nye to popularize their cause. The bottom line is they're essentially living off the government, so they need to compete with everyone else looking for tax money.
- pvaldes 6y ago> they should band together and hire a PR firm Maybe they should do it, yes, and I'm being 100% serious. That would solve a lot of newspapers abuse, always delighted to sell a history about crazy eccentric being chased by bees in some jungle, fourty years after falling in a pond at 8Yo. Journals seen politics or sports(wo)man as clients (they pay), but scientists... are products. They don't pay. Is a never-ending caricature.
- xipho 6y agoYour observation is bang on. I have expressed and argued this point of view to our community as well. I'm not sure there is an easy answer. I advocate strongly for a system that rewards doing something well, as an expert, and not being asked to do more. I don't want to be asked to design Mars landers, gourmet food (well, that might be fun), flight control systems, car brakes, etc. I do want to have pride and recognition for my hard work. Tangentially I expressed the frustrations of being asked to do more at a recent meeting. Talk slides for the curious [0] [0](https://github.com/mjy/presentations/blob/master/2020/tdwg_talk/59265_Yoder_Bubble_Bobble_TDWG_2020.pdf https://github.com/mjy/presentations/blob/master/2020/tdwg_t...)
- anigbrowl 6y agoI like your TaxonWorks platform. It feels like an important step towards a general empirical research infrastructure, eg the basic framework seems like it might be applicable in numerous non-bio fields, from (say) geology to sociology.
- xipho 6y agoThanks, that's nice to hear. There are certainly generalizations that have arrisen, we're not building this out of thin air but with reference to a lot of work done over decades (semantics, standards, pre-existing tools). It's open source, there is significant infrastructure there that could be grabbed and re-factored or extended to meet other needs. Of course the whole project is also a test of the oft stated, rarely proven "open-source it and people will join/contribute" too ;).
- xwolfi 6y agoBut the stupid people asking stupid questions are also the poor dudes with barely a future for their children giving a bit of what they earn so you can focus. I mean, people hate rich banking elites so far removed from society providing obscure services to each others. What do you think they think of intellectual elites complaining of stupid questions by the people who paid them ? You want funding you explain why. You don't want to explain why, accept nobody cares. It's because there's no absolute good in nature, nothing an expert can do to increase global knowledge is as necessary as the same guy growing lemons if society desires lemons more than knowledge. Make them desire knowledge more than lemon, THAT is part of the job.
- xipho 6y agoI'm not sure that comparing the derivative products of very rich people to a fundemantal understanding of the Earth we live on is a fair comparison. Suggesting we must sell everything feels short-sighted. Knowledge of the Earth benefits everyone in the long run. We should collectively have the intellectual capacity to acknowledge this. For example [0] there are cases where a semingly-obscure wasp, describe by a seemingly obscure person, for an audience of seemingly a handful of people, turns out to be critical to the lives and livelihoods of many, many people. The knowledge that lead to this discovery came from the passion of the taxonomists who dedicate their lives to this gathering of foundational knowledge, not from those who best knew how to sell themselves as useful. [0](https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20201124-the-tiny-parasitic-wasp-that-saved-the-cassava-industry https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20201124-the-tiny-parasit...)
- xwolfi 6y agoYou just sold it to me, though. Before, I thought only lemons mattered. See my point ? You have to tell your taxpayers why you spend their taxes, they can't guess it. And if they know nothing abt what you do with it, they'll just vote for the next magical unicorn telling them they're actually stolen by a conspiracy of elitist universities. Expecting people to be clever just because they exist is optimistic at best :)
- rorykoehler 6y ago
- coliveira 6y agoThis is a reflection of a crazy society that sees everything as a "product" that needs to be "advertised". If there is a scientific branch that needs no explanation of its importance is taxonomy. If a nation is stupid enough not to understand the importance of this, then it should not even label itself a modern, civilized society.
- RobertKerans 6y agoThat's seems a bit unfair. It's not about "products" or "advertising", or society being stupid, there has to be communication from researchers to wider society, research has to be allied to education.
- tsukurimashou 6y agoI think his point is that it should be the government job to promote these kind of things to society
- forgotmypw17 6y agoTo act in a stupid manner means to ignore obvious reality. Society is the collective sum of its individuals. Our collective sum of individuals is acting in a way which ignores the very obvious reality that it's quickly destroying the biome on which we are dependent. Therefore, I would say that our society is being stupid.
- RobertKerans 6y agoRight, I fully agree with that, but that's not what the comment I was replying to said: the parent said that society (in a nation) was stupid for not recognising [what is to parent] the self-evident importance of the scientific specialisation of taxonomy. And sure, that is important, but equally so are thousands of other academic specialisations. The point is that a specialisation has to communicate their importance to wider society, has to educate. That isn't a new thing, or capitalism, or a creeping anti-elitism, or productisation of universities, or whatever. It's just something that has to be done. Calling people idiots because they don't pay attention to a specific specialisation among thousands -- what is gained from that? It feels good to do that, but it doesn't help, it doesn't change people's bearing. It may be that people are just really, really thick! We'll just say that instead of communicating the importance of something! And I get that ignorance may be societally self destructive. That there are cultural/economic/societal systems that actively suppress communication
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoI think it's moving in the right direction in countries with national parks. I certainly can see that in France we still have working taxonomists, and that they even band to create FOSS for managing their work (TaxHub, Geonature 2, Geonature Citizen, etc).
- tjs8rj 6y agoKnowledge for knowledges sake is noble, but someone always pays for it out of their pocket meaning that even super educated researchers have to justify why they are worth someone’s dime. This isn’t a capitalist thing, or even a modern idea by any stretch. Science, as far as I can tell, has always been a matter of pragmatism, and science for science’s sake seems like a recent idea stemming from Cold War fears of falling behind stoking heavy investment and public messaging romanticizing science. For all of human history, science has almost always been public ally funded and often for military or otherwise strategic gain. So yes, even the most educated among us have to prove their value, because science isn’t some religious function or human right - it’s a discipline with pragmatic purposes to society.
- Krisando 6y ago> Imagine spending 10-15 years of academic work to get a PhD and become the world expert on something important but obscure, and then being told you need to market yourself to the general public and devote a significant portion of your time to answering stupid questions (as in 'who cares about this boring stuff' as opposed to 'what is the airspeed of a pigeon'). Sounds like life to me, I don't see the problem.