11 ms·
Aya Neo: A New Challenger for Handheld PC Gaming
- phendrenad2 6y agoIt'll be interesting to see if "handheld PC gaming" continues to grow in market share.
- ekianjo 6y agoHandheld PC gaming is still a niche on the PC Market, but with more and more devices capable of running games decently, it can only grow.
- seph-reed 6y agoI've always found it strange that phones never really went this way. There are attachments, I've seen attempts. But it just seems like such a large and available market to overlook.
- ekianjo 6y agoYou mean Gaming Android Phones? I guess the main reason is that it would detract from their primary use as phones? However you do have a lot of Android-based gaming devices with proper physical controls.
- qbasic_forever 6y agoIntel fumbled hard trying to go into mobile. It went so poorly it cost them billions of dollars, tens of thousands of jobs in layoffs, and quite a few executives (including the CEO): https://siliconangle.com/2016/05/01/intel-shuts-down-development-of-low-powered-chips-for-mobile-devices/ https://siliconangle.com/2016/05/01/intel-shuts-down-develop...
- bobthepanda 6y agoPhone gaming never quite took off outside of the freemium stuff. And gaming is a hard business for new entrants. The most likely path would’ve been if an existing gaming company made a handheld that was also a phone, but Microsoft doesn’t have a handheld entry, Sony’s Vita go down well, and Nintendo is just not really interested. This thing also costs $699, which is quite a bit more money than say a Switch. In fact a Switch is pretty much the cousin of a phone, hardware wise.
- TylerE 6y agoNokia did. It flopped. Horribly.
- ekianjo 6y agoAnd it did also because the execution was horrible. Not sure thought if it would have been successful were it done better...
- TylerE 6y agoThe problem is the target market (teens/young twenty-somethings) don't have an inflation-adjusted $1k to drop on a phone.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThey can, but you need iPhone-level cachet to get that kind of money from them, and Nokia is not that.
- Koiwai 6y agoSaying Switch is a phone is like saying phone is a PC. They use similar components, but designed very differently: Switch has dedicated controller, phones don't, at least the vast majority of them. Switch has lower resolution, targeting framerate instead. Switch has active cooling for sustained performance, phones usually only work on short bursts. Switch is cheap, comparing to premium phones. Phones are ok for a lot of things, but good for nothing, while Switch is good at gaming, undeniably the 1st in the mobile gaming market.
- jsnell 6y agoSony's Xperia Play. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xperia_Play https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xperia_Play
- bobthepanda 6y agoI feel like if you were to debut a gaming-oriented phone, you need to go all the way. Like, an Xbox phone that had all your Gamepass titles would be a compelling buy on day 1. This was a bit half-baked. It didn't even get the update to Ice Cream Sandwich.
- TylerE 6y agoCounterpoint: n-gage.
- sien 6y agoIt's interesting that the Sony Experia Play phones never got anywhere. They were pretty impressive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xperia_Play https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xperia_Play
- nemasu 6y agoYes! I still have one, and it is amazing.
- Causality1 6y agoI so want an "always in my pocket" smartphone gaming solution. Ideally a modern Xperia Play style slider phone with buttons and a slide pad but I'd also take a keychain-sized Bluetooth gamepad that attaches to the phone. Something visually like an iMpulse controller that plugged into the USB port and gave you an upright Gameboy-style experience. Every pocketable gamepad on the market expects you to have a table to rest your phone on.
- nkozyra 6y agoI think the problem is people want to play mobile games until they don't. What works about the switch is the option. I can play handheld or pop it in its dock and play on the TV with other people. Phones never quite got this. They had the mobile part built-in, but attempts at multiplayer on a screen were either ignored or botched horrifically. There's another big challenge with phone games, in my opinion ... Phones are also very personal, and I've observed that people are less likely to commit to longer-term games on their phones for some reason. Some of it is no doubt inertia - the early games on mobile were meant to be played in full in under an hour. But part of it is - I think - that having your phone occupied by something persistent like a game robs people of their ability to use the phone in the open gaps we normally use phones. Things like Switch or Stadia or whatever are dedicated gaming devices, even if they slingshot from your phone's computing power. I can use them and still have my phone in front of me. They do one thing and get out of the way. That's all depressing to write out, but it's the world we live in.
- chaosharmonic 6y agoYeah, one of the most limiting factors imo about phones-as-consoles is actually getting the game onto a larger display. They're more than powerful enough to run lower-spec console games - as evidenced by the fact that, say, remastered Square Enix titles have also been hitting mobile platforms. But the Switch, being a dedicated system for this, doesn't have to put nearly as much work into the implementation. You can easily just throw it into a dock and leave it there indefinitely, because you don't need it for anything else. While you can cast a phone wirelessly, the setup will depend largely on your ecosystem and/or accessory vendors. And even then, the entire thing is typically mirrored - which not only leaves the rest of your device otherwise unusable, but also raises further cases to handle around notifications (or worse, calls) while you're actually gaming on it. These issues would make single-player gaming annoying enough, and local multiplayer effectively becomes a nonstarter. (Never mind that one you introduce that as a requirement you also introduce the need to set up additional controllers a nontrivial amount of the time, and fast pair support within the Bluetooth spec is just as messy.) For phones to really be able to cover these things without introducing tradeoffs that just don't exist with a dedicated device, we'd need OS- and hardware- level support for running a secondary display, wirelessly, without also introducing lag in the process. Effectively, we're comparing them to the wrong platform. Because while the internals most directly line up with those of the Switch, the interface design they'd need in order to really make the experience work is arguably a lot closer to that of the Wii U. [0] Note that, for the sake of this discussion, on Android's side I'm referring strictly to what's available in AOSP. I'm aware of, say, DeX, but the app ecosystem as a whole doesn't tend to have great support for vendor-specific implementations, and the stock desktop mode is still a. experimental, b. wired.
- arduinomancer 6y agoIn case you haven't seen, there's actually a quite a big market of generic portable consoles now days. Specifically cheap linux-based emulator handhelds. Had no idea this was a thing until I came across this subreddit recently: https://www.reddit.com/r/SBCGaming https://www.reddit.com/r/SBCGaming Its quite impressive what you can buy for ~$30. It would have been pretty mind-blowing to have one of those as a kid.
- ekianjo 6y agoOdroid is also venturing in that space with the Odroid Go series.
- mxcrossb 6y agoI owned a GP32 back in the day. The killer app was of course Super Nintendo emulation, but it was also amazing to have a media machine at that time, and something you could easily develop for. I wonder if the mindset is different these days though. The title linked machine seems overkill for 16 but nostalgia. I wonder if people really want a portable machine that they can stick steam on and play indie games?
- ekianjo 6y ago> I wonder if people really want a portable machine that they can stick steam on and play indie games? Well it does not have Steam, but the Switch is full of indie games and it looks like there is a market for it.
- Splognosticus 6y agoMan, if my Switch supported Steam Link it'd be hands down my favorite portable ever. I've got a ton of games that would play just fine with the Switch's controls, but simply don't have Switch ports, plus plenty I'm just not going to buy a second copy of just for playing on the Switch.
- lspci 6y ago
- endisneigh 6y agoI hate to sound like a hater, but with 5G, plentiful power banks and things like Stadia and the Razer Kishi isn’t this super super niche these days? I have my computer, which doubles as a server, on all the time and was blown away how fast Steam Link worked on a remote connection (albeit I have gigabit upload speeds, but still). I imagine Stadia and GeForce Now are even better.
- ekianjo 6y agoNot sure if you heard but Stadia's future is probably not as solid as before. They have shut down first party studios already.
- evanextreme 6y agosure, but other services are likely to catch up fast. speeds / input lag on stadia are fantastic.
- ekianjo 6y agoYou will not have 5g everywhere and Stadia does not have every game in existence...
- toast0 6y agoDid you have expectations of good games coming from Google? Do they have a track record for that? Shutting down a Google game studio seems like a good decision. Stadia should be trying to make it easier for publishers to publish on their platform (or paying for exclusives); not trying to build their own games. That said, I'd have a lot more enthusiasm if I had better than 20 ms ping to my first hop.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Did you have expectations of good games coming from Google? Do they have a track record for that? Nope, but the fact they even considered it in the first place was kind of foolish. Now, there's so few titles available on Stadia it's hardly going to be a Steam competitor any time soon.
- noobermin 6y agoWhile I'm happy for the handheld pcs for gaming, I wish there were more iterations of the gpd p2 max, mini pcs that were geared towards productivity. I want a mini pc that has a webcam and a backlight, which the gpd p2 max doesn't have.
- 3np 6y agoMore than anything I wish there was more options in keyboard layouts. Even with remapping, the layouts of the GPDs and others are a hard no, but the only thing stopping me from buying on.
- Judgmentality 6y agoThis thing is clearly meant to have great specs for its form factor, but it doesn't even have 1080p on a 7" screen. It's slightly better than 720p, which is what I expected on my smartphone 5+ years ago on a smaller screen (and even then you could find that on a budget phone). This feels like a worse PSP. It's meant to be powerful, but the battery life will suck and it won't be powerful enough to matter. The fact that I can pull out my phone and have a substantially better screen (resolution and quality as OLED is preferable to LCD) just makes this a nonstarter for me. This is the sort of thing I'd salivate over when I was a teenager before I understood tech specs don't make a good product. In fact, it reminds me of this thing which I was excited for over 10 years ago (I don't remember when it launched, but it took forever and by the time it happened I'd lost interest). https://openpandora.org/ https://openpandora.org/ EDIT: The Pandora stopped production in 2013 and they've been working on the successor since, which apparently just delivered the first preorders. https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/pages/pyra/ https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/pages/pyra/
- mepian 6y agoSmartphones can't run PC games natively, which I personally prefer to smartphone games.
- glsdfgkjsklfj 6y agoCrazy how people buy computers nowadays based on which OS you are allowed to run on it, right? Almost feel like the early 80s all over again, but less for technical reasons.
- simias 6y agoIn this case it's also a hardware issue. If smartphones ran x86 I'm sure some clever hackers would've found a way to boot windows on them and from there you could play any game you like. But being ARM it's pointless.
- glsdfgkjsklfj 6y ago
- pdimitar 6y agoWhy such a small resolution though?
- p1necone 6y agoAt 7 inches higher resolutions are great for clearer text, but really don't make a hugely noticeable difference in games, especially fast moving ones. And the lower the resolution the better the framerates you'll get (and running upscaled ~1280x800 on a higher res screen would look worse than native 1280x800). 1280x800 @ 7 inches is already 215.63 PPI[0], which is more than twice the average 1920x1080 24 inch PC monitor. This is all especially important with a low powered GPU like the Vega 6. [0]: https://www.sven.de/dpi/ https://www.sven.de/dpi/ FWIW my preference with a device like this would definitely be lower resolution, until someone manages to stuff much faster hardware into the same form factor.
- Koiwai 6y agoYeah lots of people fail to see this, high resolution, high frame rate, low power consumption, you can only choose two. Modern phones have impressive burst performance, but they can't sustain for real gaming, while Switch and this thing can, this is a big difference. If Switch tell us anything, it is that phones are not (good) for gaming.
- Helloworldboy 6y agoIf apple launched a first-party controller attachment with consistent inputs that game devs could target, they would be worth another trillion
- hypertele-Xii 6y agoThat right-hand thumbstick looks like it's blocking access to the 4 buttons.
- nfriedly 6y agoI'm pretty excited about this device in particular, and the fact that the handheld PC gaming space is getting some competition in general! I'm also really happy to see AMD scoring a win here. Up until recently this market, niche as it is, has been pretty much dominated by GPD and their Win line of devices. I probably won't buy an Aya Neo, because I have a GPD Win Max that I'm still pretty happy with, and I prefer having the physical keyboard because I use it for non-gaming tasks on occasion. But if I don't, then I'd probably be backing this project. Oh, and because I've seen a couple of folks mention the screen size and resolution, I just want to say that it's well suited for this device and it's intended use. It's for handheld gaming on battery, on integrat,ed graphics. Higher resolution would draw more power, reduce frame rates, and not make much of a noticeable improvement to the actual gaming experience.
- Causality1 6y agoManufacturers aren't bold enough these days so I really hope this product succeeds, but I find myself not being as ravenously excited about it as I would've been a decade ago. Between my hacked Switch and my smartphone the emulation space and medium-low end gaming is basically covered. Maybe this could work well for someone who spends a lot of time on public transportation and couldn't easily use a laptop.
- danielEM 6y agoI'm just missing GSM module with modem and voice support and AMOLED screen and price below 500USD and the sales would skyrocket, otherwise it'll be another minor handheld PC