15 ms·
Gyroplane Accidents 1985-2005
- jandrese 6y agoI've read that Gyroplanes are dangerous to beginners because if you get in trouble the instinct to pull back on the stick like a traditional aircraft can be fatal to gyro pilots. They have to un-learn one of the most basic skills they learned as pilots. Edit: I mean push on the stick. Sorry, had a brainfart. Good thing I'm not a pilot.
- garaetjjte 6y ago>in trouble the instinct to pull back on the stick like a traditional aircraft You mean push on stick? (that's what is done to avoid stall in normal aircrafts) Anyway, https://xkcd.com/1972/ https://xkcd.com/1972/
- elihu 6y agoThat was alluded to in this old xkcd commic, though it doesn't go into the details: https://xkcd.com/1972/ https://xkcd.com/1972/ I kind of assumed that "the one thing you instinctively do to escape a stall" is to push forward on the stick. Some answeres here seem to confirm that: https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/49865/why-does-xkcd-say-that-autogyros-will-crash-if-the-pilot-reacts-to-a-stall-as-in https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/49865/why-does-...
- phkahler 6y agoThe comic says it never stalls, but then says if it does you should not do the instinctive thing. ;-)
- elihu 6y agoIt says it crashes if you do the thing that you would do in a normal aircraft to prevent stalling. From the other discussion I linked, it sounds like the issue is that the rotor normally creates forward drag, and earlier designs have the engine/thrust propeller mounted pretty high. Pushing the stick forward causes the rotor to have less forward drag than it normally does, so the engine thrust effectively causes the whole craft to pitch forward. Which is sort of what you'd expect to happen when you push forward on the stick, but I guess it happens in a way that's hard/impossible to correct from.
- taneq 6y agoThe issue is that the drag is what spins the rotor, and the rotor's rotation is what makes your controls work. So when you get close to a stall, the rotor's already going slowly, and then you push forward and it slows even further. Now you have almost no control authority and the only major force acting on the aircraft is the thrust from the propeller, which pitches you rapidly forward. I'm not sure why (given sufficient altitude) you can't cut the engine and recover using autorotation the way a normal helicopter can, but I imagine it's pretty hard to do this in a normal helicopter too if you're falling upside-down.
- Kiro 6y agoI still don't understand. If it can't stall why would you ever try to prevent stalling?
- krisoft 6y agoIt’s a reaction trained to fixed winged airplane pilots to the point where it becomes instinctual. If your airspeed is dropping low you push forward the stick. You don’t do it because you have run a fluid dynamics simulation which warned you about the approaching stall, but rather as a reflex to a set of sensory cues.
- minieggs 6y agoFWIW during my PPL pulling back during (un?)expected situations instinctually was very much discouraged. edit: this parent comments makes more sense if instead the author meant push on the stick, as another pointed out.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Wistar 6y agoNot sure about gyrocopters but fixed-wing pilots who later transition to, or add, a rotary wing license are intensely counseled to resist the baked-in urge to push the nose over to counteract a stall or imminent stall. In almost all single-rotor helicopters, pushing the nose over — fixed wing style — runs a high risk of causing the tailboom to rise and collide with the main rotor. The rare rigid rotor ships (BO-105s, mostly) are less likely to have this happen.
- abeppu 6y agoShould a lot of vehicles have fundamentally different controls now than when they were first invented? In particular, should we move away from controls which map onto how control surfaces or other physical parts move, and instead focus on controls that describe the desired motion? Quad-copters are pretty easy to fly, but they would be really really hard to fly if you were supposed to manage the thrust on each motor. I've never flown one, but I understand helicopters are challenging to fly, and controls do map onto actually actuating the swashplate and tail rotor. I don't understand how a gyroplane flies, or why pulling back on the stick causes immediate problems. But ... should autogyros have controls where you describe the motion you want, and let a computer figure out the actuation? I think there's an analogy to software here, where generally we're less error-prone and more productive if we can specify what we want by expressing higher-level, declarative relationships, rather than demanding that humans always think in terms of the low-level operations that will need to occur.
- tjohns 6y agoIn aviation you want to avoid unnecessary complexity. You really want to avoid single points of failure. Most small aircraft are controlled via cables and pulleys because they're simple, can be redundant, easy to verify, and unlikely to fail. What's your backup plan when your flight control computer crashes? Or if you have an electrical failure? (There's an argument to have computers provide additional assistance on top of the manual systems, but we usually stop short of fundamentally remapping flight controls. And even then, we have to be careful otherwise we end up with situations like MCAS.)
- taneq 6y agoI think what you really want to do in aviation (or anything safety-critical) is reduce risk of failure. Avoiding risk of mechanical failure at the expense of controllability is simply pushing the blame onto the pilot. The general approach for critical hardware like flight controllers is triple redundant systems with two-out-of-three voting, driving redundant actuators. MCAS is a prime example of this NOT being followed, because it relied on a single sensor input to generate a significant control output.
- 6y ago
- rectang 6y agoHere's a video of a Gyroplane "bunting over" or "pushing over" once the rotors become unloaded... the final impact is not shown but it's implied the pilot died: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfjBzrSDrV0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfjBzrSDrV0 An explanation: https://www.kitplanes.com/gyroplane-safety/ https://www.kitplanes.com/gyroplane-safety/ > Fatal Sequence > As the rotor is unloaded, both control thrust and the drag of the rotor disc fall off rapidly. With a high engine thrustline (relative to the vertical c.g. and center of drag) and/or with a momentary gust that can increase fuselage drag, the gyro can pitch forward and tumble. Such tumbling, also known as bunting over, can occur almost instantly. There is no possible recovery, and bunting over is invariably fatal.
- taneq 6y agoFrom the description there, it seems like a simple "oh shit" lever to tilt the engine (or at least prop) upwards could fix this issue?
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI'm not an expert, but yesterday I've heard from a pilot that most US gyros don't have a tail stabilizer (is that how it's called?), unlike the Magni models (Magni is a small Italian manufacturer of gyros), which don't have the problem you are describing. If there's an expert, I'd love to hear if what I just wrote is correct.
- foxyv 6y agoSince there is no torque on the rotor (Except for maybe the part the spins up the rotor before takeoff) there is no need for a tail rotor. Typically autogyros will have a rear elevator and rudder like a traditional airplane. Since most have a pusher propeller that gives you even more control in a low velocity takeoff or landing which is what gyros are good at. A good picture of this setup: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autogyro#/media/File:AutoGyro_Calidus_-_Shuttleworth_Season_Premiere_2016_(26422815634).jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autogyro#/media/File:AutoGyro_... Edit Addendum: Typically loss of control in a nose down situation for autogyros is because they don't have ailerons to control roll. They rely on the cyclic of the rotor disk.
- akavel 6y agoWhat does "perception-based performance breakdown" mean?
- _s 6y agoMost light sport aircraft are day VFR only, with an altimeter and airspeed indicator being the primary instruments. Some ultra lights don’t even have those, and you use visual cues and the “feel” of the craft to judge your energy/speed/height - and our perceptions are not the most reliable.
- taneq 6y agoFancy words for "pilot fucked up."
- jcrawfordor 6y agoRefers to a problem where the pilot did the wrong thing because of disorientation or perceptual confusion. Take controlled flight into terrain, a common enough problem that aviation safety writing just calls it CFIT. This is when an aircraft collides with terrain, but there was no loss of control. CFIT is a relatively common occurrence, but why does someone fly a completely controllable aircraft into the ground? Almost always due to perceptual confusion, disorientation either to attitude or location. Unintended entry into instrument conditions (e.g. into a cloud or fog bank) is one cause, but disorientation can occur for a number of other reasons as well, including in good weather conditions.
- stevecalifornia 6y agoWell I have an oddly specific contribution to this thread: My first boss was absent all the time. He'd show up to the office and lock himself away, leave and then not come back for another 6 months. He hated software and computers and didn't want to be a part of the software product we were building-- which is self evidently strange. He used to race experimental cars. He was in a horrific crash on one of those salt flats and his personality was permanently changed. He went from being pleasant to the person I knew him as-- cold, strange and reclusive. Turns out he was coming in to the office just long enough to use Excel to run a calculation. He was designing a helicopter where the jet engines were on the tip of the rotors and you stood in a can above the whirling blades. We called it GarbageCopter. Anyways, he eventually gave up and bought a gyrocopter. He flies that thing all day, every day. Just circling in the pattern at our airport at 1,000 feet and 20 knots. He is very old and blind on one side. I have no idea how he got his health check. I am pretty sure he will be a statistic someday, but at least he's doing something he likes.
- julian_ap 6y agoFascinating. I have so many questions. How did this manager manage to not get his position terminated? Was he able to run Excel calculations for the GarbageCopter outside his office machine? I will stop here for now. Thank you.
- BuildTheRobots 6y agoTip jet [1] helicopters have been a thing, but it's never taken off commercially. The Fairey Rotodyne being a good example. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tip_jet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tip_jet [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairey_Rotodyne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairey_Rotodyne
- yesenadam 6y agoGee, [1] says they were invented by Wittgenstein! I never knew about that.
- 6y ago
- mrfusion 6y agoWhy aren’t autogyros more popular as drones? It seems like they would have a lot of advantages for photography and package delivery. And they could be cheaper to build and easier to operate?
- geocrasher 6y agoDrones are typically quad or hexacopters that can take off and land vertically even in a stiff breeze. If you're talking about some other kind of drone then maybe you could specify it. But compared to quad or hexacopter an auto gyro would have a lot more loiter time just as a fixed wing would, and it could come down vertically at least to a point, but would not be able to take off or land vertically. There is one particular brand of autogyro that can take off vertically by pre-spinning the rotor and then applying collective at the same time as disconnecting power from it. They tend to leap off the tarmac. But that is not the norm. Standard autogyros require a takeoff roll just as a fixing aircraft plane does. People often look at the rotor and think that it is like a helicopter but in fact it is more like a fixed wing aircraft in the sense that air must be passing over the wings / rotor in order to produce lift. That being said, an autonomous autogyro does sound very interesting. One could pre-spin the rotor with a typical brushless motor and then leave it unpowered during flight. It does require collective control to be able to do that but even hobby helicopters have collective and cyclic control, so adding just collective control seems very approachable.
- askvictor 6y agoWhy would they be cheaper to build? A quad-copter is ridiculously simple in it's design - 4 motors is all the moving parts it needs. The rest is sensors and software.
- greesil 6y agoThere is a slow rotor variant of an autogyro that has the same efficiency as small single engine plane, which is pretty cool. They also claim it can take off and land vertically. https://verticalmag.com/news/carteraviationtechnologiesadvancespaviislowedrotorcompoundai/ https://verticalmag.com/news/carteraviationtechnologiesadvan...
- nrjames 6y agoIgor Bentsen[1] was my neighbor. My kids like to play on the dilapidated old prototype autogyro [2] in his old backyard. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bensen_Aircraft?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bensen_Aircraft?wprov=sfti1 [2] https://imgur.com/gallery/MlJSqYK https://imgur.com/gallery/MlJSqYK
- fuzzfactor 6y agoWhen I was in high school, we initiated one as a senior class project in Mechanical Technology. Then graduated early and left the building.