4 ms·
My first thought (from the title) was that cloning won't save you from having too small of a population because below a certain threshold there's not enough gen
by yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago
My first thought (from the title) was that cloning won't save you from having too small of a population because below a certain threshold there's not enough genetic diversity (if you have 20 living specimens and you clone them to get 40, you still only have 20 individuals worth of DNA). But (on reading the article) it turns out that the big deal is that they cloned it from a (long) dead animal, which means that they've actually increased available genetic diversity in the living gene pool. So that's cool:)
- redisman 6y agoGreat news. I wonder is the new ferret fertile? I know that can be an issue with manipulated species.
- maxerickson 6y agoI'm sure the intent is that it be fertile (so they've chosen their methods and so on with that in mind), but it's still to young to know.
- staticassertion 6y agoWouldn't genetic diversity eventually occur naturally? Especially if you can source the clone dna from > 1 source. I personally don't know fwiw.
- Hemospectrum 6y agoIt does increase naturally. The catch is: If the overall gene pool is too small, the viability of successive generations will decrease faster than the rate at which the gene pool can expand.
- cratermoon 6y agoNot only that, but from a biologist's perspective: where are you going to put it? The main reason animals become endangered is habitat destruction. There's no place now to put a viable population of the species. You can't introduce them to a new environment easier, as Australians will be happy to tell you if you ask them about rabbits.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoI mean. If your goal is to make the species a going concern, the Australian problem is a win. It's a little... paperclip maximizer feeling, but going from "nearly extinct" to "invasive species overrunning a continent" does solve the original stated problem.
- cgriswald 6y agoAssuming they were live animals: Couldn’t you keep reintroducing the cloned individuals into a gene pool to increase diversity? Yes, you’re stuck with (say) 30 individuals, but cloning would help you get more combinations out of the DNA than just breeding the 30 animals, right?
- dtech 6y agoNo, cloning creates identical copies. If you clone a niece and nephew 1000 times the resulting population will still be very inbred.
- cgriswald 6y agoThat’s not quite what I’m saying. With say, 15 males and 15 females, you can create 15 pairings. If you can clone them, you can make 225 pairings. You still have to worry about inbreeding but you can make many more different combinations of the genes you do have and ensure none of the individual genes are lost by not being passed on.
- foxyv 6y agoIn addition to your point, inbreeding isn't necessarily a problem if you engage in selective breeding. (Sterilizing and euthanizing animals with fatal recessives or health problems) Genetic testing has made this a much more effective solution. With in-vitro testing and implantation you can clear these problems before the animal is even born or implanted. The problem is that a lack of diversity can lead to issues with adaptation to new environments and pressures. This is what has made a lot of these species endangered in the first place. They are adapted for very specific conditions which are suddenly changing due to habitat destruction. (Deforestation, urbanization, water works, farming) A typical population has a lot of mutant lines that do okay in the current environment but may be more adapted to different environments. A population of clones will take time to develop these and may not survive long enough to adapt. Also if there is a problem with the current line and you don't catch it fast enough you are hosed.