5 ms·
We don’t live in a hyper capitalist system. This hyperbole is harmful to any conversation about making positive change. This is the intellectual equivalent of
by mulmen 6y ago
We don’t live in a hyper capitalist system. This hyperbole is harmful to any conversation about making positive change.
This is the intellectual equivalent of burning coal. Your emissions have a cost that others have to pay.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI don't know where you live, but I would call US hyper capitalist. Overly privatized into the hands of the 1%. No health care. Everyday people mostly powerless and government pandering to companies for political support. My country is not much better.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dpoochieni 6y agoThat's not hyper-capitalistic, that's just fascist/pseudo-feudalist. Throughtout history everyday people have been pretty much powerless in any meaningful way, always, no exception except maybe for early USA history.
- Krisando 6y ago> Everyday people mostly powerless and government pandering to companies for political support. I lived in a post-socialist country, and trust me, just because it's post-socialist doesn't mean that the systems change to other things next day. It wasn't much different. There is a ruling class. Capitalism had nothing to do with it.
- esarbe 6y agoI think if you look from a point in time of where the term 'capitalim' was initially heh coined, you will find that it very much is a hyper-capitalistic society we live in. During the time when capitalism was first named an overwhelming majority of the populaces' exchanges of services and goods was not based on any capitalistic exchanges. And with capitalistic exchange I mean the exchange of good that were produced under a capitalistic agreement where the means of production are not in the hands of anyone with immediate social relations to the person controlling the means of labor. Most of the people were living and working in small villages, self-sufficient to a large degree and wholly preoccupied with agriculture. Goods and services were mostly produced in a feudal mode of production, not in a capitalistic mode. Nowadays however, for a vast majority of the population of most industrialized and developing economies of the world this means of exchange is the primary - if not the exclusive - means of procuring goods and services. So, I very much dispute that calling our society 'hyper capitalistic' is hyperbole, despite of the two sharing a prefix.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoMeans of production and money existed since the dawn of civilization. The law of Hammurabi discusses contracts, prices, private property, etc. Also, for example, Rome during the times of Roman Empire had to rely on imports of food from Africa because Appenine agriculture wasn’t self-sufficient. And throughout history in Europe and Middle East trade was a big part of every complex society. These stories about feudal mode of production is just bad outdated 19th century scholarship. It also seems completely ridiculous to call modern states hyper capitalistic when in most countries 35-65% of GDP is controlled by the government (yes, even in the US). 100 years ago it was more like 5% of GDP and income taxes didn’t even exist!
- esarbe 6y agoI think you might be conflating trade with capitalism. The exchange of goods and services for a representative value (i.e. money) is not capitalism. That's just trade. Could you explain why you think that the percentage of GDP a government controls has anything to do with capitalism?
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoI am not conflating trade with capitalism. I am explaining that the “feudal mode of production” was at best localized and relatively short period in the history of mankind. So contrasting capitalism with it is disingenuous because many periods in human history were more similar to what we have today than feudalism but there is often an implication that feudalism is the closest in time and place to the rise of capitalism and therefore it is the most similar one which is simply not true. If you look at the history of Rome it is much closer to what we have now in terms of its legal system, government expenditure, private relations, etc than feudalism. And they even had a similar sort of “capital” like private ships they used for trade that were very expensive, even though they didn’t have a modern idea of a corporation. Indeed, exchange is not always capitalistic exchange. Capitalism can be analyzed as a system defined by 3 core properties: (1) private ownership of the means of production (2) labor market (3) commodity market. This is what Adam Smith called “the system of natural liberty” and what Marx called “capitalism” (I am not sure he coined it, but he certainly popularized it). Hence, when the government uses spends money on big infrastructure projects or hires people to work on a mine, it has little to do with capitalism, thinks like that existed in Ancient Rome and even Ancient Greece! Compare our modern world to what we had 100-300 years ago when companies had personal armies. I don’t see how we are live in anything close to “hyper capitalism”.